Sam Field
#31
(04-17-2019, 06:10 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-17-2019, 05:44 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(04-17-2019, 02:52 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I think the contrast between peoples' attitudes to Rekeem Harper and Sam Field is interesting. Harper was praised to the heavens by all and sundry - clearly a player with huge talent - who then went on to be increasingly ineffective (not sure about the double negative there - - - ) as we struggled. Field has looked comfortable on the pitch, unhurried, generally in the right place to do the simple things well - the simple interceptions that our more experienced players weren't doing in the latter chaotic days of Moore and Jones. But he is judged a "run of the mill Championship player" who has "had too many chances".

It's harsh to judge any of the younger players on their contributions this season. It's been another shit-show, with a revolving door of coaching ideas and coaches. Difficult for a seasoned player to perform consistently, well nigh impossible for an inexperienced one to thrive. But we love to do our players down, don't we.

Well some Chesh, I've had strong reservations about Harper too althoguh I do think he's the better prospect of the two, if Field had Harper's mobility then I'd have no hesitation he could kick on and make it, as mentioned above his lack of mobility ultimately means he's a yard behind the play and slow to the 2nd ball

Harper has a good turn of pace and can get away from a player in midfield but his positional sense is poor and without the ball gives us next to nothing currently, if he moves on to a club on a higher stage it would be wasted IMO, he still has a a hell of a lot to learn IMO

Cuzer

I don't understand this lack of mobility. He just has a different style to Harper. They are as fit as each other. The two goals Field has scored for us (Newcastle and Bolton) show no lack of mobility at all. Late runs into the box and tidy finishes.

They are just different players with differing styles. Just because Harper glides past people with the ball at feet and does fancy flicks and Field sits back and sprays passes and keeps the ball ticking over doesn't mean he has a lack of mobility.

Harper is an attacking flair player and Field isn't. Nothing else to it.

It's like comparing Fernandinho to David Silva or Carrick to Pogba etc.

I don’t think people are saying they’re similar midfielders though, they are different players for me

The way field plays mobility isn’t all that essential but his lack of it for me will hamper him from kicking in from where he is
He is slow to the 2nd ball and is generally one paced getting around the pitch, therefore his best position is with the game in front of him, therefore a sitting role like Barry played or in a back three perhaps, getting around the pitch, box to box, is not his game

Cuzer
Reply
#32
(04-17-2019, 07:47 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(04-17-2019, 06:10 PM)Peachy Wrote:
(04-17-2019, 05:44 PM)Cuzer Wrote:
(04-17-2019, 02:52 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I think the contrast between peoples' attitudes to Rekeem Harper and Sam Field is interesting. Harper was praised to the heavens by all and sundry - clearly a player with huge talent - who then went on to be increasingly ineffective (not sure about the double negative there - - - ) as we struggled. Field has looked comfortable on the pitch, unhurried, generally in the right place to do the simple things well - the simple interceptions that our more experienced players weren't doing in the latter chaotic days of Moore and Jones. But he is judged a "run of the mill Championship player" who has "had too many chances".

It's harsh to judge any of the younger players on their contributions this season. It's been another shit-show, with a revolving door of coaching ideas and coaches. Difficult for a seasoned player to perform consistently, well nigh impossible for an inexperienced one to thrive. But we love to do our players down, don't we.

Well some Chesh, I've had strong reservations about Harper too althoguh I do think he's the better prospect of the two, if Field had Harper's mobility then I'd have no hesitation he could kick on and make it, as mentioned above his lack of mobility ultimately means he's a yard behind the play and slow to the 2nd ball

Harper has a good turn of pace and can get away from a player in midfield but his positional sense is poor and without the ball gives us next to nothing currently, if he moves on to a club on a higher stage it would be wasted IMO, he still has a a hell of a lot to learn IMO

Cuzer

I don't understand this lack of mobility. He just has a different style to Harper. They are as fit as each other. The two goals Field has scored for us (Newcastle and Bolton) show no lack of mobility at all. Late runs into the box and tidy finishes.

They are just different players with differing styles. Just because Harper glides past people with the ball at feet and does fancy flicks and Field sits back and sprays passes and keeps the ball ticking over doesn't mean he has a lack of mobility.

Harper is an attacking flair player and Field isn't. Nothing else to it.

It's like comparing Fernandinho to David Silva or Carrick to Pogba etc.

I don’t think people are saying they’re similar midfielders though, they are different players for me

The way field plays mobility isn’t all that essential but his lack of it for me will hamper him from kicking in from where he is
He is slow to the 2nd ball and is generally one paced getting around the pitch, therefore his best position is with the game in front of him, therefore a sitting role like Barry played or in a back three perhaps, getting around the pitch, box to box, is not his game

Cuzer

Shakes head......

He doesn't have a lack of mobility. He's a holding midfielder who keeps it simple. He's quicker to the second ball than most of our midfield which isn't saying much I grant you!

If you want a lack of mobility look at Livermore and the bulk he carries. 

It's in your head man....
Reply
#33
If you think Field gets around the pitch quicker than Livermore I think it's your head that needs examining!

Mind, my Nan is arguably quicker than the pair of em

For a holding midfielder he hardly plays there, watched him the other night for the U23's at Old Trafford and the game passed him by, he should be controlling these type of matches

Like I've said I hope I'm wrong and you're right but no manager so far has seen enough in him to give him a run in the side, fact

Cuzer
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: