Comparative Healthcare
#11
(11-01-2022, 11:45 AM)SophLad Wrote: 2013:  Andrew Lansley's Health and Social Care Act disaggregates healthcare and public health by placing health into the Clinical Commissioning Groups (almost trippling the amount of governing bodies despite pledges for no top down reorganisations) and Public Health into councils.  Key staff are TUPEd but aren't ringenced.
2008-2018:  Local government funding savagely cut.  Public Health cuts help fund shortfalls in other areas of LGA spend.
2018-22:  Persistent changes to the role, size and function of Public Health England.
2022:  Therese Coffey - an anti abortionist who voted against the smoking ban appointed as health secretary.
Today:  wHy dONt wE Do PrEvenTATive mEdIcinE?

Today there are 1.6 million people and an annual budget of £200 billion unable to provide basic healthcare provision.

If that isn't the definition of a failing organisation then I don't know what is. It won't be saved by even more of our money and a bit more advice to fatsters not to eat so many crisps.
Reply
#12
My uncle is in hospital at the moment having had a stroke and has found out he needed an operation due to a fractured hip. As he also has Parkinsons this made it even more risky (he did get through but still in a bad way). My aunt is in there every day to see him but has to leave Post-It notes everywhere as she has seen nurses attempt to feed him without the necessary thickener or whatever he needs to enable him to eat/drink and not choke which could kill him. There are other notes she has dotted around as he has sensitive skin due to his condition so should use an electric razor instead, even though the staff have been doing without. She's cared shitless that someone will not be aware of what needs to be done for his care.

I understand people are under pressure with harsh workloads but the above is indicative of a broken system or process. Surely this is where the focus should lie within the NHS.
Reply
#13
NHS might function better if it didn't have so many unfilled job vacancies for nurses and doctors.

You cannot provide an excellent service if you don't have sufficient staff.

I wonder why there are so many unfilled NHS posts?
Reply
#14
(11-01-2022, 11:44 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(10-31-2022, 05:26 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Eh? Turkish healthcare reforms this millennium have massively expanded preventive healthcare provisions. It's a massive factor.

Right. So the only reason we could be seen immediately (twice) is because of that. OK. Fine.  Shy

Likely three key reasons:

Median age being lower meaning health issues are less prevalent

More healthcare personnel per capita 

More efficient use of preventive care

Two of those three are directly because of the Conservative Party that you voted for. Both those points relate to better access to healthcare officials. The Tories don't want the NHS to provide preventive care and they don't want more doctors and nurses.

It's not hard, I don't know why you're playing stupid games over this.
Reply
#15
(11-01-2022, 11:57 AM)Fido Wrote: My uncle is in hospital at the moment having had a stroke and has found out he needed an operation due to a fractured hip. As he also has Parkinsons this made it even more risky (he did get through but still in a bad way). My aunt is in there every day to see him but has to leave Post-It notes everywhere as she has seen nurses attempt to feed him without the necessary thickener or whatever he needs to enable him to eat/drink and not choke which could kill him. There are other notes she has dotted around as he has sensitive skin due to his condition so should use an electric razor instead, even though the staff have been doing without. She's cared shitless that someone will not be aware of what needs to be done for his care.

I understand people are under pressure with harsh workloads but the above is indicative of a broken system or process. Surely this is where the focus should lie within the NHS.

Yes.

I had a healthy uncle who went in to the Royal Free for a minor operation and died in there 4 months later with a hospital acquired infection. I don't even want to revisit the treatment both my parents received for stage 4 cancer, but suffice to say I would rather die in pain at home than suffer the indignities and cruelty they suffered at the hands of the NHS - before my brother and I pretty much kidnapped them into the Marie Curie.

I am sick and tired of the NHS and its staff being beatified. I am sick and tired of more money being demanded from us all in tax.

I happily pay for health insurance to avoid the NHS. I'd happily pay the same amount in tax if I could be guaranteed anything like the same level of service from the NHS.

The institution is rotten. It's consistently at the bottom of the league for keeping people alive. Yet people put up with it. Why?
Reply
#16
What is this league of which you speak Proth.

Going back to your op, you're not seriously suggesting that the NHS would not be able to satisfactorily deal with a gashed foot.

Last year my daughter broke her arm and the treatment she got from the NHS was first class. And we weren't at the end of the treatment presented with a bill for the treatment at its conclusion.

Now that is just an isolated example of anecdotal evidence and there will be others that are far less positive.  The size of the organisation , it would be unlikely if there weren't negative patient feedback.

But let's not pretend that there isn't great work done by the NHS each and every day
Reply
#17
(11-01-2022, 03:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: What is this league of which you speak Proth.

Going back to your op, you're not seriously suggesting that the NHS would not be able to satisfactorily deal with a gashed foot.

Last year my daughter broke her arm and the treatment she got from the NHS was first class. And we weren't at the end of the treatment presented with a bill for the treatment at its conclusion.

Now that is just an isolated example of anecdotal evidence and there will be others that are far less positive.  The size of the organisation , it would be unlikely if there weren't negative patient feedback.

But let's not pretend that there isn't great work done by the NHS each and every day

I snapped by bicep tendon during lockdown, within 4 weeks I'd had a triage, an x-ray, an ultrasound, one hospital appointment and two consultant appointments. I was offered an operation to reattach the tendon but advised I only needed it really for aesthetic reasons as it will still work perfectly fine. All of that on the NHS and not out of pocket a penny apart from the car park charges.
Reply
#18
Fact. Cuba has one of the best state health services in the world.
Reply
#19
(11-01-2022, 03:33 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: What is this league of which you speak Proth.

Going back to your op, you're not seriously suggesting that the NHS would not be able to satisfactorily deal with a gashed foot.

Last year my daughter broke her arm and the treatment she got from the NHS was first class. And we weren't at the end of the treatment presented with a bill for the treatment at its conclusion.

Now that is just an isolated example of anecdotal evidence and there will be others that are far less positive.  The size of the organisation , it would be unlikely if there weren't negative patient feedback.

But let's not pretend that there isn't great work done by the NHS each and every day

The Commonwealth Fund Survey ranks 11 developed nations' Healthcare performance. The NHS is usually near to the top in how it runs the bureaucracy (hurrah) but always in the bottom three when it comes to healthcare outcomes. Depending on your perspective (producer or consumer) this is either a good or a bad result.

Going back to my foot (and P Major's ear) we were dealt with IMMEDIATELY - there was literally no wait. I was presented with a bill which I'll claim back via insurance. What's not to like?

There is great work by the NHS everyday. Just not enough of it. Far too often the organisation exists to serve itself rather than us. It's not alone in that, don't get me on to the crap I've had to put up with from Royal Mail in the last two days...
Reply
#20
(11-01-2022, 03:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The Commonwealth Fund Survey ranks 11 developed nations' Healthcare performance. The NHS is usually near to the top in how it runs the bureaucracy (hurrah) but always in the bottom three when it comes to healthcare outcomes. Depending on your perspective (producer or consumer) this is either a good or a bad result.

Going back to my foot (and P Major's ear) we were dealt with IMMEDIATELY - there was literally no wait. I was presented with a bill which I'll claim back via insurance. What's not to like?

There is great work by the NHS everyday. Just not enough of it. Far too often the organisation exists to serve itself rather than us. It's not alone in that, don't get me on to the crap I've had to put up with from Royal Mail in the last two days...

I'll ask the obvious question. What about those who can't afford either insurance or the bill that is presented to them upon treatment?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: