Ratings…….
#1
Go as far as saying that's the worst we've been this season - If Carlos has watched all every minute of this season and felt that was our best line up to win the game lord help us.

We have not only continued the trends of not being able to pass to our own man, lacking defensive shape or ownership, and inability to connect a key pass around the opposition box, but we have also added some extreme fannying about at the back to our game.

Sheff Utd didn't have to work for those points today, we looked every inch a team that's given up and is going down - so much for a new manager bounce.

Livermore and Phillips are now a real problem for us. Sorry but there is no motivation from either of them, and it's stinking the team out. Too many of these players are having a very easy ride and need to be binned.

Palmer - 4 - so casual coming off his line, could have got a stronger hand on their second IMO

Townsend - 3 - offered nothing in attack and was his usual liability self at the back - made a couple clearances to gain a point.

Pieters - 4 - pick of the back 4 but still looked like an ageing fullback deputising at CB

O'Shea - 3 - being relied on to anchor the back line but isn't commanding enough and doesn't have the ability reading them game or the physical presence. IRegressing by the week.

Furlong - 3 - contributed more going forward than usual, unfortunately was able to play on after injury.

Livermore - 1 - absolutely shocking. Both goals from runs through his space. Lord alone knows why he was pushing forward and TGH deeper - our midfield parted like the Red Sea every time they broke into space.

TGH - 3 - see Livermore but made a couple of cracking passes to try and set up breaks

Phillips - 2 - absolutely shocking. Managed to show he's shit as a winger, wingback, number 10 and forward in one game. Received an extra point due always showing and not hiding despite having a mare. Carlos, his best position is in the fucking stand.

Grady - 4 - some invention, but absolutely no end product. Pressed them and didn't stop chasing so 5 points for effort and a -1 for actual contribution.

Wallace - 3 - It's taken 3 months but we've finally broken him. His weakest game since joining - Looked like he was going through the motions.

Grant - 2 - one of his better performances. Missed a couple chances and looks heavily overweight. Didn't miss a pen so bonus.

Molumby - 5 MOTM - showed industry and tenacity nobody else bothered with. Think he'll be a CC favourite.

Swift - 4 - showed why we have to play him with half chances that worked keeper or went narrowly wide. One of the few who can grab a goal.

Reach - 3.5 - marginally better than Townsend.

BTA - n/a - was already half way down the steps when he came on.

Carlos.... 1 - shocking line up. No idea what the hell we were trying to do. Early days but any hope of a bounce has been fully extinguished.
Reply
#2
TGH 5 for second half, and a couple of decent passes.
BTA 6 for effort and looking like he knows where a striker plays.

Rest I agree with.
Reply
#3
Grant 2!!!!!! Thats way, way to generous. The worst striker display I have seen in many a decade.
Reply
#4
Absolutely wow on Phillips by the way

Showed more today than any of them

Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Reply
#5
(10-29-2022, 01:39 PM)Peachy Wrote: Grant 2!!!!!! Thats way, way to generous. The worst striker display I have seen in many a decade.

Good God, no. Is he sliding into George`Rambo` Reilly, Stuart Evans,( the worst player to ever wear the shirt IMO ), Stewart Phillips, Paul Williams and Jeroen Boere  levels of abysmalness?
Reply
#6
(10-29-2022, 01:43 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Absolutely wow on Phillips by the way

Showed more today than any of them

Cuzer

He ran around a fair bit but every time he needed to cross a ball he hit the defender, took one too many touches (as ever) or was off the pace in retrieving something that a fitter player would catch.

He made one cross all game from memory - absolute dross. Earned points for showing effort but he was still absolute crap.
Reply
#7
(10-29-2022, 01:51 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 01:43 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Absolutely wow on Phillips by the way

Showed more today than any of them

Cuzer

He ran around a fair bit but every time he needed to cross a ball he hit the defender, took one too many touches (as ever) or was off the pace in retrieving something that a fitter player would catch.

He made one cross all game from memory - absolute dross. Earned points for showing effort but he was still absolute crap.

This ^
Reply
#8
(10-29-2022, 01:39 PM)Peachy Wrote: Grant 2!!!!!! Thats way, way to generous. The worst striker display I have seen in many a decade.

He is a complete waste of ixygen. Won nothing in the air, arrived late in the box time and again, no end product 

To those who say he is a winger - he isn't. He was signed to play as a striker. If he plays wide he can't beat a player and deliver a cross.

He is a left sided forward who can cut in and score - but what's his ratio this season? I think it's 3 in 15, with 1 pen. I stand to be corrected on those stats if wrong.
Reply
#9
(10-29-2022, 01:39 PM)Peachy Wrote: Grant 2!!!!!! Thats way, way to generous. The worst striker display I have seen in many a decade.

Honestly his performance today was like Luke Moore every single game he ever played for us that wasn't against Peterborough

(10-29-2022, 01:51 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 01:43 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Absolutely wow on Phillips by the way

Showed more today than any of them

Cuzer

He ran around a fair bit but every time he needed to cross a ball he hit the defender, took one too many touches (as ever) or was off the pace in retrieving something that a fitter player would catch.

He made one cross all game from memory - absolute dross. Earned points for showing effort but he was still absolute crap.

Exactly this, I can only assume he's getting credit for touching the ball a lot as opposed to the quality of those touches.
Reply
#10
(10-29-2022, 01:51 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 01:43 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Absolutely wow on Phillips by the way

Showed more today than any of them

Cuzer

He ran around a fair bit but every time he needed to cross a ball he hit the defender, took one too many touches (as ever) or was off the pace in retrieving something that a fitter player would catch.

He made one cross all game from memory - absolute dross. Earned points for showing effort but he was still absolute crap.

Yes he was awful.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)