Lai releases purse strings for transfer bonanza
#61
(10-29-2022, 12:32 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:11 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:48 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:44 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:41 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Well we’re £12m light in cash to where we should be because of loans which shouldn’t have been made.

Even allowing for the £12m, that takes us to £66m out of the £90m parachutes... Still doesn't add up as to why we'd need to go to some business loan sharks. Besides after today's start they'd be mad to lend us £25m.

We haven’t had £90m of parachute payments yet. It’s a cash flow issue as much as anything else.  We have a huge wage bill (at this level) and we have to keep paying off managers and their entourages

Also bear in mind that if we’d sold Pereira to a club in most other countries we could have factored the transfer fee and boosted cash flow.  But that’s impossible when you sell to a Saudi club as no factoring company will risk having to pursue recovery of the debt from Saudi if they default.

(10-29-2022, 11:47 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:44 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: Wages!  They were already being paid out of the PL money (£120m) so are still there to be paid (albeit with flexdowns for relegation) to be paid out the much lower parachute money.

I did a quick google for the wages and £25m seemed to be the consensus of the level, even allowing that to go to £60m it still does not add up.

Has to be considerably in excess of £25m based on my maths

The operating costs per annum is approx £70 million. Your missing transfer costs are spread over players contracts (eg Grant) The owners, board, legal, groundstaff, medical, recruitment dept, academy, electricity, even police costs, the list is endless. The wages is closer to £35m.
Even Bilics, Val's and Bruce's golden handshakes and their staff must be millions.
Also we only have 2 years of parachute payments, which ends this season.
As for Lai he answers to nobody. He borrowed the £5m and another £2m he agreed to pay the £5m loan back then renaged. He obviously has no money and is not to o be trusted. Any additional money he can get his grubby little hands on will be gone. And as he owns the club he can and does exactly as he likes.

Yes, more like £35m (total of all staff)

No - he (in fact Yunyai, not Lai!) owns only 88% if the club, so he cannot do “exactly as he likes”.  One of these days you’ll finally understand the basics of company law and the rights of minority shareholders.  The directors are PERSONALLY accountable for any action by them in breach of their fiduciary duty which results in a loss to the shareholders, which is how and when the 12% minority shareholders come in.  They can’t stop acts happening if sanctioned by the directors but it doesn’t mean that the directors are not accountable for those actions.

Prag just stop - you said previously he couldn't take money out of the club and used the same reasoning. I'm not disagreeing with what he should or shouldn't do.
But the very fact that he has already taken £7m is a clear demonstration he can and does what he likes.
Reply
#62
(10-29-2022, 12:32 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:26 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:55 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Found this one claiming it's £18m: https://salarysport.com/football/premier...ch-albion/

this one also claims £18m - https://m.aiscore.com/salary/team-west-b...dipn2a3736

Anyway it's moot, we're getting fucking trounced on the pitch here.

Are you just including the player wage bill?  What about all the rest of the staff?

I can't find Doris's salary anywhere, sorry! Big Grin

As I said, i excluded a lot of incomings too, tv for live matches, marketing etc... etc... I based my maths purely on £90m parachute payments. However if that £90m is actually only £60m then that makes things make a lot more sense.

It’s about £75m over 2 years.  We don’t get the 3rd year PP because we were only in the PL for one year this time around
Reply
#63
(10-29-2022, 12:42 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:32 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:26 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:55 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Found this one claiming it's £18m: https://salarysport.com/football/premier...ch-albion/

this one also claims £18m - https://m.aiscore.com/salary/team-west-b...dipn2a3736

Anyway it's moot, we're getting fucking trounced on the pitch here.

Are you just including the player wage bill?  What about all the rest of the staff?

I can't find Doris's salary anywhere, sorry! Big Grin

As I said, i excluded a lot of incomings too, tv for live matches, marketing etc... etc... I based my maths purely on £90m parachute payments. However if that £90m is actually only £60m then that makes things make a lot more sense.

It’s about £75m over 2 years.  We don’t get the 3rd year PP because we were only in the PL for one year this time around

Cheers.
Reply
#64
(10-29-2022, 12:36 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:32 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:11 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:48 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:44 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Even allowing for the £12m, that takes us to £66m out of the £90m parachutes... Still doesn't add up as to why we'd need to go to some business loan sharks. Besides after today's start they'd be mad to lend us £25m.

We haven’t had £90m of parachute payments yet. It’s a cash flow issue as much as anything else.  We have a huge wage bill (at this level) and we have to keep paying off managers and their entourages

Also bear in mind that if we’d sold Pereira to a club in most other countries we could have factored the transfer fee and boosted cash flow.  But that’s impossible when you sell to a Saudi club as no factoring company will risk having to pursue recovery of the debt from Saudi if they default.

(10-29-2022, 11:47 AM)MassDebater Wrote: I did a quick google for the wages and £25m seemed to be the consensus of the level, even allowing that to go to £60m it still does not add up.

Has to be considerably in excess of £25m based on my maths

The operating costs per annum is approx £70 million. Your missing transfer costs are spread over players contracts (eg Grant) The owners, board, legal, groundstaff, medical, recruitment dept, academy, electricity, even police costs, the list is endless. The wages is closer to £35m.
Even Bilics, Val's and Bruce's golden handshakes and their staff must be millions.
Also we only have 2 years of parachute payments, which ends this season.
As for Lai he answers to nobody. He borrowed the £5m and another £2m he agreed to pay the £5m loan back then renaged. He obviously has no money and is not to o be trusted. Any additional money he can get his grubby little hands on will be gone. And as he owns the club he can and does exactly as he likes.

Yes, more like £35m (total of all staff)

No - he (in fact Yunyai, not Lai!) owns only 88% if the club, so he cannot do “exactly as he likes”.  One of these days you’ll finally understand the basics of company law and the rights of minority shareholders.  The directors are PERSONALLY accountable for any action by them in breach of their fiduciary duty which results in a loss to the shareholders, which is how and when the 12% minority shareholders come in.  They can’t stop acts happening if sanctioned by the directors but it doesn’t mean that the directors are not accountable for those actions.

Prag just stop - you said previously he couldn't take money out of the club and used the same reasoning. I'm not disagreeing with what he should or shouldn't do.
But the very fact that he has already taken £7m is a clear demonstration he can and does what he likes.


No - check what I actually said!

I said that he can’t take it out without the directors being personally accountable for sanctioning it.  I made it very clear that the accountability doesn’t stop just because he’s done it.  Murdering someone is illegal but it doesn’t stop it happening.  The accountability for it does NOT disappear. 

I can’t find any smaller words with fewer syllables that you might comprehend to get a grasp of the basics of directors’ responsibilities and fiduciary duty under company law, something with which you are clearly unfamiliar.  I’ve only practised company law and governance for 39 years so what the hell would I know?
Reply
#65
(10-29-2022, 12:46 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:36 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:32 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:11 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:48 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: We haven’t had £90m of parachute payments yet. It’s a cash flow issue as much as anything else.  We have a huge wage bill (at this level) and we have to keep paying off managers and their entourages

Also bear in mind that if we’d sold Pereira to a club in most other countries we could have factored the transfer fee and boosted cash flow.  But that’s impossible when you sell to a Saudi club as no factoring company will risk having to pursue recovery of the debt from Saudi if they default.


Has to be considerably in excess of £25m based on my maths

The operating costs per annum is approx £70 million. Your missing transfer costs are spread over players contracts (eg Grant) The owners, board, legal, groundstaff, medical, recruitment dept, academy, electricity, even police costs, the list is endless. The wages is closer to £35m.
Even Bilics, Val's and Bruce's golden handshakes and their staff must be millions.
Also we only have 2 years of parachute payments, which ends this season.
As for Lai he answers to nobody. He borrowed the £5m and another £2m he agreed to pay the £5m loan back then renaged. He obviously has no money and is not to o be trusted. Any additional money he can get his grubby little hands on will be gone. And as he owns the club he can and does exactly as he likes.

Yes, more like £35m (total of all staff)

No - he (in fact Yunyai, not Lai!) owns only 88% if the club, so he cannot do “exactly as he likes”.  One of these days you’ll finally understand the basics of company law and the rights of minority shareholders.  The directors are PERSONALLY accountable for any action by them in breach of their fiduciary duty which results in a loss to the shareholders, which is how and when the 12% minority shareholders come in.  They can’t stop acts happening if sanctioned by the directors but it doesn’t mean that the directors are not accountable for those actions.

Prag just stop - you said previously he couldn't take money out of the club and used the same reasoning. I'm not disagreeing with what he should or shouldn't do.
But the very fact that he has already taken £7m is a clear demonstration he can and does what he likes.


No - check what I actually said!

I said that he can’t take it out without the directors being personally accountable for sanctioning it.  I made it very clear that the accountability doesn’t stop just because he’s done it.  Murdering someone is illegal but it doesn’t stop it happening.  The accountability for it does NOT disappear. 

I can’t find any smaller words with fewer syllables that you might comprehend to get a grasp of the basics of directors’ responsibilities and fiduciary duty under company law, something with which you are clearly unfamiliar.  I’ve only practised company law and governance for 39 years so what the hell would I know?

But, but, but, we have a budget and therefore everything will be ok.
Reply
#66
He may well be personally accountable for taking the money out.

He’ll suffer the consequences of that in time if he doesn’t repay, and it will probably go to a court in China as nominated point of resolution. Which will award in his favour naturally, and we all know why. We will then likely have to take it to the high court and then the Supreme Court in Beijing, before we see any of the money. It will be long and expensive. And probably not really worth it.

So yes, practically at least, he can do what he likes.

I have some experience of dealing in recovery of assets from PRC and it isn’t very easy. It’s one of the attractions of investing in the west, which to a lesser extent we are seeing some consequence of in the news in a different context entirely.
Reply
#67
BTA has done more in 2 minutes than Grant has done in 90
Reply
#68
(10-29-2022, 01:20 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: BTA has done more in 2 minutes than Grant has done in 90

He’s a trier but he doesn’t look like he’ll be the answer either. Two real chances those last few minutes.
Reply
#69
(10-29-2022, 12:46 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:36 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:32 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:11 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:48 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: We haven’t had £90m of parachute payments yet. It’s a cash flow issue as much as anything else.  We have a huge wage bill (at this level) and we have to keep paying off managers and their entourages

Also bear in mind that if we’d sold Pereira to a club in most other countries we could have factored the transfer fee and boosted cash flow.  But that’s impossible when you sell to a Saudi club as no factoring company will risk having to pursue recovery of the debt from Saudi if they default.


Has to be considerably in excess of £25m based on my maths

The operating costs per annum is approx £70 million. Your missing transfer costs are spread over players contracts (eg Grant) The owners, board, legal, groundstaff, medical, recruitment dept, academy, electricity, even police costs, the list is endless. The wages is closer to £35m.
Even Bilics, Val's and Bruce's golden handshakes and their staff must be millions.
Also we only have 2 years of parachute payments, which ends this season.
As for Lai he answers to nobody. He borrowed the £5m and another £2m he agreed to pay the £5m loan back then renaged. He obviously has no money and is not to o be trusted. Any additional money he can get his grubby little hands on will be gone. And as he owns the club he can and does exactly as he likes.

Yes, more like £35m (total of all staff)

No - he (in fact Yunyai, not Lai!) owns only 88% if the club, so he cannot do “exactly as he likes”.  One of these days you’ll finally understand the basics of company law and the rights of minority shareholders.  The directors are PERSONALLY accountable for any action by them in breach of their fiduciary duty which results in a loss to the shareholders, which is how and when the 12% minority shareholders come in.  They can’t stop acts happening if sanctioned by the directors but it doesn’t mean that the directors are not accountable for those actions.

Prag just stop - you said previously he couldn't take money out of the club and used the same reasoning. I'm not disagreeing with what he should or shouldn't do.
But the very fact that he has already taken £7m is a clear demonstration he can and does what he likes.


No - check what I actually said!

I said that he can’t take it out without the directors being personally accountable for sanctioning it.  I made it very clear that the accountability doesn’t stop just because he’s done it.  Murdering someone is illegal but it doesn’t stop it happening.  The accountability for it does NOT disappear. 

I can’t find any smaller words with fewer syllables that you might comprehend to get a grasp of the basics of directors’ responsibilities and fiduciary duty under company law, something with which you are clearly unfamiliar.  I’ve only practised company law and governance for 39 years so what the hell would I know?

I’d love to have a read of WBA Holdings Limited’s articles of association, to see if lending money to unconnected third parties is included.  I know the articles of association are generally written to be very wide, intentionally to allow a company great flexibility, but lending money, I wouldn’t expect to be in a football club’s articles.
Reply
#70
(10-29-2022, 12:46 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:36 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:32 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 12:11 PM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(10-29-2022, 11:48 AM)Pragmatist Wrote: We haven’t had £90m of parachute payments yet. It’s a cash flow issue as much as anything else.  We have a huge wage bill (at this level) and we have to keep paying off managers and their entourages

Also bear in mind that if we’d sold Pereira to a club in most other countries we could have factored the transfer fee and boosted cash flow.  But that’s impossible when you sell to a Saudi club as no factoring company will risk having to pursue recovery of the debt from Saudi if they default.


Has to be considerably in excess of £25m based on my maths

The operating costs per annum is approx £70 million. Your missing transfer costs are spread over players contracts (eg Grant) The owners, board, legal, groundstaff, medical, recruitment dept, academy, electricity, even police costs, the list is endless. The wages is closer to £35m.
Even Bilics, Val's and Bruce's golden handshakes and their staff must be millions.
Also we only have 2 years of parachute payments, which ends this season.
As for Lai he answers to nobody. He borrowed the £5m and another £2m he agreed to pay the £5m loan back then renaged. He obviously has no money and is not to o be trusted. Any additional money he can get his grubby little hands on will be gone. And as he owns the club he can and does exactly as he likes.

Yes, more like £35m (total of all staff)

No - he (in fact Yunyai, not Lai!) owns only 88% if the club, so he cannot do “exactly as he likes”.  One of these days you’ll finally understand the basics of company law and the rights of minority shareholders.  The directors are PERSONALLY accountable for any action by them in breach of their fiduciary duty which results in a loss to the shareholders, which is how and when the 12% minority shareholders come in.  They can’t stop acts happening if sanctioned by the directors but it doesn’t mean that the directors are not accountable for those actions.

Prag just stop - you said previously he couldn't take money out of the club and used the same reasoning. I'm not disagreeing with what he should or shouldn't do.
But the very fact that he has already taken £7m is a clear demonstration he can and does what he likes.


No - check what I actually said!

I said that he can’t take it out without the directors being personally accountable for sanctioning it.  I made it very clear that the accountability doesn’t stop just because he’s done it.  Murdering someone is illegal but it doesn’t stop it happening.  The accountability for it does NOT disappear. 

I can’t find any smaller words with fewer syllables that you might comprehend to get a grasp of the basics of directors’ responsibilities and fiduciary duty under company law, something with which you are clearly unfamiliar.  I’ve only practised company law and governance for 39 years so what the hell would I know?

Prag I agree with you.
Lai does not
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)