James McClean
#21
(10-23-2022, 10:21 AM)Squid Wrote:
(10-23-2022, 10:09 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It's always saddening to read these posts, because they tend to elicit unpleasant attitudes and undercurrents from some posters.

"McClean is a bigot" - no, he was born and brought up in a community which lived the worst horrors of the troubles. He could be much more diplomatic, to be sure, but you can't just turn off the influences of your childhood, family and friends. Possibly much easier for GMac to rise above the legacy of the troubles, being from Larne not Derry.

"McClean is a very limited footballer" - yes, but he always receives abuse above and beyond what is merited, because people can't leave the sectarian stuff out of their analysis.

This debate shouldn't be about James McClean, with his understandable reluctance to show deference to the Union Flag and other symbols, and his less understandable tendency to stoke things up rather than play them down. It should be about the fact that football fans think it's OK to sing sectarian songs, not just in Ireland and Scotland, but in England as well. McClean is quite right that action should be taken.

The Irish Question (as it was always known in old history books) is complicated. There was and remains a great deal of right and wrong on both sides. In 2022 I don't believe we English should be taking sides at all. I've met many Irish people (North and South, Catholic and Protestant) who live their lives as though there isn't an issue. I've met a few who can't help but bring the sectarian issues up on a daily basis. I don't think I've ever met an Irish person who can discuss the whole thing rationally, without taking up a stance one way or the other. But we football fans have absolutely no need to get involved.

The legacy of the Troubles is all over Northern Ireland and unlike GMac, McClean was barely a child when it was going on. I said elsewhere, that McClean is exactly like those teenagers who wish they were gangsters and that's part of what rubs people up thr with way

Spot on. 
As I said though I’d be angry at twats singing anti Catholic stuff. McClean is a moron but so too are these fans at Sunderland. 
Interesting Martin O’Neill, also from Derry didn’t need to behave like that. Shows what a difference being educated makes.
Reply
#22
(10-23-2022, 10:34 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-23-2022, 10:21 AM)Squid Wrote:
(10-23-2022, 10:09 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It's always saddening to read these posts, because they tend to elicit unpleasant attitudes and undercurrents from some posters.

"McClean is a bigot" - no, he was born and brought up in a community which lived the worst horrors of the troubles. He could be much more diplomatic, to be sure, but you can't just turn off the influences of your childhood, family and friends. Possibly much easier for GMac to rise above the legacy of the troubles, being from Larne not Derry.

"McClean is a very limited footballer" - yes, but he always receives abuse above and beyond what is merited, because people can't leave the sectarian stuff out of their analysis.

This debate shouldn't be about James McClean, with his understandable reluctance to show deference to the Union Flag and other symbols, and his less understandable tendency to stoke things up rather than play them down. It should be about the fact that football fans think it's OK to sing sectarian songs, not just in Ireland and Scotland, but in England as well. McClean is quite right that action should be taken.

The Irish Question (as it was always known in old history books) is complicated. There was and remains a great deal of right and wrong on both sides. In 2022 I don't believe we English should be taking sides at all. I've met many Irish people (North and South, Catholic and Protestant) who live their lives as though there isn't an issue. I've met a few who can't help but bring the sectarian issues up on a daily basis. I don't think I've ever met an Irish person who can discuss the whole thing rationally, without taking up a stance one way or the other. But we football fans have absolutely no need to get involved.

The legacy of the Troubles is all over Northern Ireland and unlike GMac, McClean was barely a child when it was going on. I said elsewhere, that McClean is exactly like those teenagers who wish they were gangsters and that's part of what rubs people up thr with way

Spot on. 
As I said though I’d be angry at twats singing anti Catholic stuff. McClean is a moron but so too are these fans at Sunderland. 
Interesting Martin O’Neill, also from Derry didn’t need to behave like that. Shows what a difference being educated makes.

Agreed Spandau

The position is slightly complicated at Sunderland. Quinn is still very popular but my Mackem mates reckon it was always a Protestant fan base in the main. The Seaburn Loyalists very prominent in their supporter base.
Reply
#23
(10-23-2022, 10:34 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(10-23-2022, 10:21 AM)Squid Wrote:
(10-23-2022, 10:09 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It's always saddening to read these posts, because they tend to elicit unpleasant attitudes and undercurrents from some posters.

"McClean is a bigot" - no, he was born and brought up in a community which lived the worst horrors of the troubles. He could be much more diplomatic, to be sure, but you can't just turn off the influences of your childhood, family and friends. Possibly much easier for GMac to rise above the legacy of the troubles, being from Larne not Derry.

"McClean is a very limited footballer" - yes, but he always receives abuse above and beyond what is merited, because people can't leave the sectarian stuff out of their analysis.

This debate shouldn't be about James McClean, with his understandable reluctance to show deference to the Union Flag and other symbols, and his less understandable tendency to stoke things up rather than play them down. It should be about the fact that football fans think it's OK to sing sectarian songs, not just in Ireland and Scotland, but in England as well. McClean is quite right that action should be taken.

The Irish Question (as it was always known in old history books) is complicated. There was and remains a great deal of right and wrong on both sides. In 2022 I don't believe we English should be taking sides at all. I've met many Irish people (North and South, Catholic and Protestant) who live their lives as though there isn't an issue. I've met a few who can't help but bring the sectarian issues up on a daily basis. I don't think I've ever met an Irish person who can discuss the whole thing rationally, without taking up a stance one way or the other. But we football fans have absolutely no need to get involved.

The legacy of the Troubles is all over Northern Ireland and unlike GMac, McClean was barely a child when it was going on. I said elsewhere, that McClean is exactly like those teenagers who wish they were gangsters and that's part of what rubs people up thr with way

Spot on. 
As I said though I’d be angry at twats singing anti Catholic stuff. McClean is a moron but so too are these fans at Sunderland. 
Interesting Martin O’Neill, also from Derry didn’t need to behave like that. Shows what a difference being educated makes.

MoN is from rural Co Londonderry - which is a very different place to the Creggan.

McLean is a figure of fun in Derry - drives round in a big flash car which regularly gets brake fluid applied.
Reply
#24
(10-23-2022, 10:09 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: It's always saddening to read these posts, because they tend to elicit unpleasant attitudes and undercurrents from some posters.

"McClean is a bigot" - no, he was born and brought up in a community which lived the worst horrors of the troubles. He could be much more diplomatic, to be sure, but you can't just turn off the influences of your childhood, family and friends. Possibly much easier for GMac to rise above the legacy of the troubles, being from Larne not Derry.

"McClean is a very limited footballer" - yes, but he always receives abuse above and beyond what is merited, because people can't leave the sectarian stuff out of their analysis.

This debate shouldn't be about James McClean, with his understandable reluctance to show deference to the Union Flag and other symbols, and his less understandable tendency to stoke things up rather than play them down. It should be about the fact that football fans think it's OK to sing sectarian songs, not just in Ireland and Scotland, but in England as well. McClean is quite right that action should be taken.

The Irish Question (as it was always known in old history books) is complicated. There was and remains a great deal of right and wrong on both sides. In 2022 I don't believe we English should be taking sides at all. I've met many Irish people (North and South, Catholic and Protestant) who live their lives as though there isn't an issue. I've met a few who can't help but bring the sectarian issues up on a daily basis. I don't think I've ever met an Irish person who can discuss the whole thing rationally, without taking up a stance one way or the other. But we football fans have no need to get involved.

My city got bombed by the ira does that mean I hate all Irish.

Of course it doesn't .
Reply
#25
Myself as well as my family have been on the end of sickening abuse since November 2012. For those you can’t grasp that, that is eight years of sickening abuse.'

Arf. Not the brightest is he?
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: