Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
Was wrong about Mel. Also had the underwhelmed feeling with Megson, but I think that was more born of a general malaise about football in general.
I also thought Pardew would do ok.
This'll shock some, I was underwhelmed with Val, but then changed my mind with how he conducted pre-season etc... It was only a few minutes into the Bournemouth game where I went back to feeling underwhelmed.
Slav, did make me feel we'd got the right bloke in. As did Moore and then Shan. Didn't want BFS, Plus or Bruce.
Saunders, and all others of that era I admit to not having enough knowledge or that football was assigned to match days only for me back then, and the day after for trying to get into a better mood after we'd lost. So most of my opinions were formed from the press, Grorty Dick or what my dad thought.
Can't really say I've ever got really excited by a managerial appointment, but have felt a lurching dread with many.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
Megson: I’d never heard of him and had zero expectations
Robson: Was dead against his appointment.
Mowbray: Was totally convinced he’d be the messiah after Robbo!
RDM: quietly confident and thought he fitted where we’d had success previously
Roy: was the only candidate I wanted at the time given what he’d done with Fulham
Clarke: was 50/50, seemed sensible and had faith in our set-up but would have preferred a “name” at that time
Mel: thought he was going to take us to new levels and heights 
AFI: was very anti-it…. Just felt lazy
Pulis: was pro- initially. It just made sense.
Pardew: again, thought it made sense… completely misjudged that one.
Moore: think everyone wanted Dave after the revival!
Billic: was super excited!!!
Allardyce: didn’t want him, felt he’d spend money we didn’t have and was a pointless gamble
Val: wanted him as felt he’d rebuild
Bruce: didn’t want him, was concerned about his Newcastle time and being a dinosaur.
Overall, I’m confident in my judgement (shock…) but have got a few wrong.
I like hipster managers and those that promise good football or have a new idea. We tend to do better when managers are riding a wave when they join and bring a new optimism… the last thing we need are tired managers, ones with nothing to prove who view us as a meal ticket.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
I thought Bilic would do what he did - start well and then drop off a cliff, just the same as he did at West Ham.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
10-21-2022, 11:06 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-21-2022, 11:11 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
Bruce probably because I’m not as interested or bothered about football as I was.
Pulis BUT only in so much as he should have left at the end of the season (the one before relegation).
I was right about:
Megson
RDM
Hodgson
Pardew (I thought he was dreadful and he was)
Mel (stupid appointment)
Clarke (ok until the rock solid foundations under Roy and Ashworth left).
AI (we seemed to think our DoF model was the reason for our success not the personnel running it)
You can argue either way about:
Moore (I didn’t think he was the right choice)
Mowbray (I thought he was the right choice at first but then felt he disappeared up his own bottom)
Allardyce (no one was saving that squad from relegation)
Bilic (I thought he would play nice but easy to play against football)
Val (I thought the style would alienate fans and it took me until the end of the first match against Bournemouth to realise how easy was to play against).
My biggest blunder by far was supporting Bruce.
Posts: 2,824
Threads: 190
Joined: Nov 2021
Reputation:
8
(10-21-2022, 10:26 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Was wrong about Mel. Also had the underwhelmed feeling with Megson, but I think that was more born of a general malaise about football in general.
I also thought Pardew would do ok.
This'll shock some, I was underwhelmed with Val, but then changed my mind with how he conducted pre-season etc... It was only a few minutes into the Bournemouth game where I went back to feeling underwhelmed.
Slav, did make me feel we'd got the right bloke in. As did Moore and then Shan. Didn't want BFS, Plus or Bruce.
Saunders, and all others of that era I admit to not having enough knowledge or that football was assigned to match days only for me back then, and the day after for trying to get into a better mood after we'd lost. So most of my opinions were formed from the press, Grorty Dick or what my dad thought.
Can't really say I've ever got really excited by a managerial appointment, but have felt a lurching dread with many.
That's the only positive I've seen written about TTITC.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
(10-21-2022, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Bruce probably because I’m not as interested or bothered about football as I was.
Pulis BUT only in so much as he should have left at the end of the season (the one before relegation).
I was right about:
Megson
RDM
Hodgson
Pardew (I thought he was dreadful and he was)
Mel (stupid appointment)
Clarke (ok until the rock solid foundations under Roy and Ashworth left).
AI (we seemed to think our DoF model was the reason for our success not the personnel running it)
You can argue either way about:
Moore (I didn’t think he was the right choice)
Mowbray (I thought he was the right choice at first but then felt he disappeared up his own bottom)
Allardyce (no one was saving that squad from relegation)
Bilic (I thought he would play nice but easy to play against football)
Val (I thought the style would alienate fans and it took me until the end of the first match against Bournemouth to realise how easy was to play against).
My biggest blunder by far was supporting Bruce.
A lot of it also comes down to whether you view a manager as being successful or not.
I think both Mowbray, Bilic and Val were successes and I guess you don’t.
Posts: 17,072
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
10-21-2022, 11:29 AM
(This post was last modified: 10-21-2022, 11:32 AM by Derek Hardballs.)
(10-21-2022, 11:22 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: (10-21-2022, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: Bruce probably because I’m not as interested or bothered about football as I was.
Pulis BUT only in so much as he should have left at the end of the season (the one before relegation).
I was right about:
Megson
RDM
Hodgson
Pardew (I thought he was dreadful and he was)
Mel (stupid appointment)
Clarke (ok until the rock solid foundations under Roy and Ashworth left).
AI (we seemed to think our DoF model was the reason for our success not the personnel running it)
You can argue either way about:
Moore (I didn’t think he was the right choice)
Mowbray (I thought he was the right choice at first but then felt he disappeared up his own bottom)
Allardyce (no one was saving that squad from relegation)
Bilic (I thought he would play nice but easy to play against football)
Val (I thought the style would alienate fans and it took me until the end of the first match against Bournemouth to realise how easy was to play against).
My biggest blunder by far was supporting Bruce.
A lot of it also comes down to whether you view a manager as being successful or not.
I think both Mowbray, Bilic and Val were successes and I guess you don’t.
Val wasn’t a success, he achieved diddly squat.
Bilic a kind of success but his teams are far too easy to play against for any prolonged success and left any manager replacing him with an impossible task of staying up.
Mowbray, best resources in league, promoted as expected and relegated as expected and did the almost impossible and made football pretentious
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
It's hard to remember back, BFR in his first stint is the first manager I remember. Ronnie Allen created an excitement, quite the opposite to Ron Wylie in our household.
I was excited about Johnny Giles because I'd heard so much, what a disaster and Ron Saunders... Nothing good comes from the Villa is my memory of that one.
Thereafter I gathered my own opinions outside of the family and like most it's hit and miss.
BFR coming back was exciting, but always felt short term,
Talbot - Again an excitement as he'd really got some decent results as interim boss. Results fell away once he wasn't playing!
Bobby Gould - I sang "We don't want you Bobby Gould" at the top of my voice, from day one. I remember being gutted when his appointment hit the E&S. He will forever the manager I rate as our worst.
Ardiles - Excited to have him, gutted when he left.
Burkinshaw - Thought he's be the right man to steady the ship after promotion. The organ grinder not the monkey.
Buckley - underwhelmed at the time and his whole time with us was underwhelming.
Harford - wasn't overly excited, he did well for a few months "We only need one chance", may have achieved something if his Mrs didn't want him back home.
Denis Smith - please god no. And that's how it panned out.
Brian Little - just typing the name brings a little shudder now. At the time thought it showed some ambition and he'd improve us. Villa Cunt, remember "Nothing good comes from the Villa"
SGM - Who? Another nobody to follow the likes of Buckley. May have got that one slightly wrong...
Robson - please not him ffs. Got that one spot on. After the GE thought he may be able to attract a few names and build for our second PL season, i think that optimism lasted a couple of weeks.
Mowbray - The one from the list I wanted at the time. Did a good job overall, shame it ended how it did.
RDM - Meh. Wasn't convinced he was all that and despite the promotion, still not. My group of mates were all in agreement to sack him before the PL campaign started.
Hodgson - A no brainer, just what we needed. And he was, shame England came calling when they did. Saw him at the Albion not that long ago when he did an after dinner speech. His version is that he was happy to sign a new deal but Roland was offering less than his current one! They haggled and it dragged on unsigned and then the England interest came along and then he was never signing it.
Clarkey Cat - Made sense at the time and thought he'd be ok, turned out that one the Hodgson defensive discipline vanished he had no answers.
Pepe - The exciting saviour, thought he'd do a job for us and make the football attractive. It was a worry when he couldn't bring his own people but thought we'd change that in the summer. He never made it that far!
AFI - the fact they buried it in the news for the England said it all. Don't know anyone who thought it was a good appointment, myself included.
Pulis - understood the logic, but hated having him. Wanted him gone the end of the season we appointed him. Thanks for keeping us up now fuck off. In the end he did what he does.
Pardew - wasn't happy with the man himself but thought he'd maybe bring one of his winning streaks and he'd keep us up at least.
Big Dave - he head to get the gig given the turnaround but it always felt destined to fail. Lovely fella and probably the one manager I've wanted it to work for more than any other. Thanks Graeme Jones for spoiling that.
Bilic - Boom. Back in the big time. Some ambition. Turned sour from both sides at the end, was a shame as though he wouldn't have kept us up I'd have been happy for him to have another crack at the Champo.
BFS - despite my preference for watching players pass the ball to each other rather than just into space I would have kept him. No one was going to keep us up but he instantly spotted the problems in the squad. Him walking away told us all we needed to know about the budget etc. Truly believe he would have got us into the play-offs at least.
Ismael - genuinely was unsure, felt like a gamble and was concerned by Dowling saying the fans wouldn't accept his football.
Bruce - understood the appointment at the time. Safe pair of hands, excellent record for promotion, boy was that wrong. Wouldn't have cared if he'd gone in the summer but once he was staying felt he deserved enough of a chance to fail and didn't think judging him on the previous season was fair. He's brought in some decent players so there's clearly a talent there but has lost the ability to make them play together.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 8,091
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
Megson: Couldn’t be worse than what had gone. What a great journey though.
Robson: Knew it wouldn’t work. Got laughed at by the lads when he was appointed, they kept laughing until he’d gone.
Mowbray: Gnurk
RDM: Seemed a confident appointment, shame it went kind wrong. Thought he’d do well
Roy: Was a little wary but the smart money was always that he’d do well
Clarke: Trusted the board on this one. Too big for a first job, I guess.
Mel: Knew it was a gamble, it got funnier and funnier people on here bending over to rim him though for work he didn’t even do.
AFI: See Robbo.
Pulis: Felt like a sell-out appointment. Knew we’d be fine while we had him, also knew that the longer that was the worse it would be when he left. We were warned.
Pardew: See Robbo.
Moore: I didn’t think it would work. It should have, and may have had he been his own man. Again – too big a first job?
Billic: I wasn’t really very well at the time. I just remember thinking ‘yeah, that makes sense’
Allardyce: Didn’t want him, but we had to take him.
Val: I had high hopes for him but knew he’d struggle coming in so late. Did not expect the wheels to come off so soon though.
Bruce: See Allardyce. Or even Robbo.
Crikey, what a bunch.
Posts: 295
Threads: 73
Joined: Jun 2022
(10-21-2022, 10:54 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Megson: I’d never heard of him and had zero expectations
Robson: Was dead against his appointment.
Mowbray: Was totally convinced he’d be the messiah after Robbo!
RDM: quietly confident and thought he fitted where we’d had success previously
Roy: was the only candidate I wanted at the time given what he’d done with Fulham
Clarke: was 50/50, seemed sensible and had faith in our set-up but would have preferred a “name” at that time
Mel: thought he was going to take us to new levels and heights 
AFI: was very anti-it…. Just felt lazy
Pulis: was pro- initially. It just made sense.
Pardew: again, thought it made sense… completely misjudged that one.
Moore: think everyone wanted Dave after the revival!
Billic: was super excited!!!
Allardyce: didn’t want him, felt he’d spend money we didn’t have and was a pointless gamble
Val: wanted him as felt he’d rebuild
Bruce: didn’t want him, was concerned about his Newcastle time and being a dinosaur.
Overall, I’m confident in my judgement (shock…) but have got a few wrong.
I like hipster managers and those that promise good football or have a new idea. We tend to do better when managers are riding a wave when they join and bring a new optimism… the last thing we need are tired managers, ones with nothing to prove who view us as a meal ticket.
You'd never heard of Gary Megson?
|