Neil staying at Preston
#11
That's made my weekend.
Never wanted him from the start.

More importantly what happens now?

Shan's done pretty well apart from Millwall and the disastrous first half v Bristol. 

Do we stick with him or get a more experienced man in?
Reply
#12
Get Craig Shakespeare in to help Shan out is my alternative .
Reply
#13
Perfectly fine with that, good luck to him.
Reply
#14
It makes sense to keep Shan in place. He plays people in their proper positions and makes sensible substitutions. He could perhaps do with an experienced old hand giving some advice - if the right person can be found. With the right motivator in the dressing room we could yet get something out of this abortion of a season. Jose is unemployed isn't he?
Reply
#15
There are four games to go till the play offs and Jimmy Shan has just won 4-1 and changed the system to something that seems to suit us. I really don't see the point in appointing any new manager now if we are serious about promotion. Surely bringing in a new man who disrupt things.

Wait and see what division we are in next season the appoint accordingly.

But FFS Albion have someone lined up. We don't want to piss about half the summer trying to get a manager in when he should be preparing for the new season.
Reply
#16
(04-14-2019, 12:38 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Get Craig Shakespeare in to help Shan out is my alternative .

Any chance Club would go back to Moore? A nagging doubt of mine has been would Shan feel comfortable with someone new. Who would have the authority?
Reply
#17
(04-14-2019, 12:34 PM)Albionmad Wrote: That's made my weekend.
Never wanted him from the start.

More importantly what happens now?

Shan's done pretty well apart from Millwall and the disastrous first half v Bristol. 

Do we stick with him or get a more experienced man in?

I’m not sure anyone could have done much more than Shan has so far really.

4 wins from 6 on the back of some dodgy form, and missing a lot of key players.

Millwall was horrendous, but had JRod scored that pen we’d have got something, and the Bristol game we were down to the bare bones, and despite gifting them 3 goals he made changes that should have seen us get a point.

For me a manager needs to get the best out of a group of players, and proactively impact matches when Plan A isn’t working and he’s shown himself capable of doing this.

I’d like to see us bring someone with a bit of experience to act as a sounding board, but the decision ultimately needs to be Shan’s.
Reply
#18
(04-14-2019, 12:38 PM)The liquidator Wrote: Get Craig Shakespeare in to help Shan out is my alternative .

Why has he been out of work for 18 months?
Reply
#19
Derek Jenk.. sorry Hardballs won't be happy
Reply
#20
(04-14-2019, 12:41 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(04-14-2019, 12:34 PM)Albionmad Wrote: That's made my weekend.
Never wanted him from the start.

More importantly what happens now?

Shan's done pretty well apart from Millwall and the disastrous first half v Bristol. 

Do we stick with him or get a more experienced man in?

I’m not sure anyone could have done much more than Shan has so far really.

4 wins from 6 on the back of some dodgy form, and missing a lot of key players.

Millwall was horrendous, but had JRod scored that pen we’d have got something, and the Bristol game we were down to the bare bones, and despite gifting them 3 goals he made changes that should have seen us get a point.

For me a manager needs to get the best out of a group of players, and proactively impact matches when Plan A isn’t working and he’s shown himself capable of doing this.

I’d like to see us bring someone with a bit of experience to act as a sounding board, but the decision ultimately needs to be Shan’s.
Agree with all you've posted.

However the prospect of us going into a double header vs The Vile with a rookie manager is the stuff of nightmares
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)