Ratings Today
#1
SJ 6 - Not a great deal to do

Hegazi 7 - Was going well until injury forced him off
Dawson 7 - Best performance for a while
Bartley 7 - Best I've seen him play 


Holgate 7 - a more advanced position suits him 
Livermore 6 - Sluggish
Johansen 6.5 - Would have been a 7 but for him fannying out the 50/50 with the keeper early on
Brunt 8.5 - Ran the show
Gibbs 7 - Getting back to his old self

Gayle 9 - Dial G for goal!
JRod 7 - Unselfish link up play

Subs

Tosin 7 - Did well when he came on
Townsend 6 - Not suited to the wing back role
Philips 6 - Rusty, but managed not to get injured which is something

Jimmy Shan 7 - signed off with a win
Reply
#2
That Phillips rating made me loff!
Reply
#3
Today was utterly infuriating.... I've been banging on and on for the need for us to return to 3-5-2 at home because with Gibbs/Phillisps/Hoglate we have the best wing backs in the division and it crucially allows Gayle and JRod to play where they can cause teams harm. Had we stuck with it and not reverted to the wholly impractical 4-3-3 for so long (at home at least!) we'd have been up by now.

Still, at least we look to be regaining and element of form!

Johnstone - 7 - What he needed after a ropey week. Was surprised not to see Bond start.

Hegazi - 8 - Our best defender by a mile, and kept them out of it. Quite why we persisted with Bartley on the left when Hegazi can distribute fairly well is another nail in Moore and Jones' coffins
Dawson - 7 - Looked interested today as he got to battle with a big lad in Stockley. Could have done better from attacking set pieces.
Bartley - 8 for his top half, 4 for his bottom half. Headed a lot away and was a commanding presence, but every time it went to his feet he went to pieces.

Holgate - 7 - If only he could cross he'd be brilliant, but we seem to have killed his distribution. Consider Phillips there on Friday.
Livermore - 7 - Looked composed and linked play. Did a lot more running than usual and actually gave Brunt the space to play. Felt Brunt suffered when he went off.
Brunt - 8 - First half he was exceptional, but he tired late on and when Livermore went off he didn't have as much space as Johansen wasn't quite as disciplined.
Johansen - 8 - Finally looking like the player in his Fulham showreel... Such an intelligent player and now looks to have the legs to go with his brain. He could well be the difference in the playoffs
Gibbs - 6 - Looked rusty, and the fact Townsend didn't do any worse suggests he's a bit out of it. Needs games, but I'm sure he'll be back to his best soon.

Gayle - 10 - What a difference playing him in the middle makes...
Rodriguez - 8 - See Gayle, but with 2 less goals...

Shan - 8 - Glad he finally saw sense and went back to the system we have the players for. Had we done it sooner we'd have probably been breathing down the Yorkshire pair's necks right now.

Neil - 2 - Really disappointed with how he handed the game today... Think the 3-5-2 took him by surprise, as it looked like he'd set his side up to close us down at the back and pressure us through the middle, but when it was clear his game plan wouldn't work he didn't change anything. Made a couple like for like changes and was found wanting.

I think I'd be tempted to leave Shan in the dugout Friday, as it feels like he's finally got to grips with how to get the best out of the players we have.
Reply
#4
(04-13-2019, 05:19 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Today was utterly infuriating.... I've been banging on and on for the need for us to return to 3-5-2 at home because with Gibbs/Phillisps/Hoglate we have the best wing backs in the division and it crucially allows Gayle and JRod to play where they can cause teams harm. Had we stuck with it and not reverted to the wholly impractical 4-3-3 for so long (at home at least!) we'd have been up by now.

Still, at least we look to be regaining and element of form!

Johnstone - 7 - What he needed after a ropey week. Was surprised not to see Bond start.

Hegazi - 8 - Our best defender by a mile, and kept them out of it. Quite why we persisted with Bartley on the left when Hegazi can distribute fairly well is another nail in Moore and Jones' coffins
Dawson - 7 - Looked interested today as he got to battle with a big lad in Stockley. Could have done better from attacking set pieces.
Bartley - 8 for his top half, 4 for his bottom half. Headed a lot away and was a commanding presence, but every time it went to his feet he went to pieces.

Holgate - 7 - If only he could cross he'd be brilliant, but we seem to have killed his distribution. Consider Phillips there on Friday.
Livermore - 7 - Looked composed and linked play. Did a lot more running than usual and actually gave Brunt the space to play. Felt Brunt suffered when he went off.
Brunt - 8 - First half he was exceptional, but he tired late on and when Livermore went off he didn't have as much space as Johansen wasn't quite as disciplined.
Johansen - 8 - Finally looking like the player in his Fulham showreel... Such an intelligent player and now looks to have the legs to go with his brain. He could well be the difference in the playoffs
Gibbs - 6 - Looked rusty, and the fact Townsend didn't do any worse suggests he's a bit out of it. Needs games, but I'm sure he'll be back to his best soon.

Gayle - 10 - What a difference playing him in the middle makes...
Rodriguez - 8 - See Gayle, but with 2 less goals...

Shan - 8 - Glad he finally saw sense and went back to the system we have the players for. Had we done it sooner we'd have probably been breathing down the Yorkshire pair's necks right now.

Neil - 2 - Really disappointed with how he handed the game today... Think the 3-5-2 took him by surprise, as it looked like he'd set his side up to close us down at the back and pressure us through the middle, but when it was clear his game plan wouldn't work he didn't change anything. Made a couple like for like changes and was found wanting.

I think I'd be tempted to leave Shan in the dugout Friday, as it feels like he's finally got to grips with how to get the best out of the players we have.
Totally agree
Reply
#5
Holgate 5
Crossing was dreadful again ,only found an Albion player once all game ,and Rodriguez blasted over the bar
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)