Ok, assuming we can't afford to get rid of him
#41
(10-02-2022, 05:43 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 05:40 PM)Dumbo Wrote: What has Rob Edwards done to continually get mentioned for the job?. If it’s, be a little less shit than Bruce, then I may as well apply.

Did very well with Forest Green and was doing a respectable job before Watford did a Watford.

He’s young and considered an up and comer. He might get found out at this level as many others have done, or he might thrive. It’s a risk but I couldn’t see how he could a worse job than Bruce currently is.

Like the look of Edwards. Progressive young coach.
Reply
#42
(10-02-2022, 08:26 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 07:28 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: I’m increasingly tempted by Neil Critchley and Michael Carrick as the two most appealing and realistic choices.

Critchley may have only just joined Villa, but this could be a huge opportunity for him. Clubs often give a number 2 a chance to talk to other clubs, and any compensation would probably be minimal. He’s also in the area already which might help.  Very impressive at Blackpool and could well be “on the up”.  Gerrard obviously rates him highly.

Carrick did well at OT when he did the caretaker role. Clearly competent and respected, and would be a big plus if he had Phelan assisting him.

That would be my shortlist.  Much as I’d love to see Steve Clarke return to his “unfinished business at West Brom” that he has referred to, I’m not sure he’d easily quit the Scotland job, but you never know.

Critchley is IMO the best option as he improves players, something weve not had a manager do in a bloody long time. Think Villa had to pay sizeable compo to take him from Blackpool so I doubt he’d be cheap. 

I thought Clarke had bad blood with us and was very anti-returning?

Clarke’s issue was with Peace’s regime of which there is no trace remaining today.  His son has tweeted favourably several times about the club and about “unfinished business” here
Reply
#43
(10-02-2022, 08:56 PM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 08:26 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 07:28 PM)Pragmatist Wrote: I’m increasingly tempted by Neil Critchley and Michael Carrick as the two most appealing and realistic choices.

Critchley may have only just joined Villa, but this could be a huge opportunity for him. Clubs often give a number 2 a chance to talk to other clubs, and any compensation would probably be minimal. He’s also in the area already which might help.  Very impressive at Blackpool and could well be “on the up”.  Gerrard obviously rates him highly.

Carrick did well at OT when he did the caretaker role. Clearly competent and respected, and would be a big plus if he had Phelan assisting him.

That would be my shortlist.  Much as I’d love to see Steve Clarke return to his “unfinished business at West Brom” that he has referred to, I’m not sure he’d easily quit the Scotland job, but you never know.

Critchley is IMO the best option as he improves players, something weve not had a manager do in a bloody long time. Think Villa had to pay sizeable compo to take him from Blackpool so I doubt he’d be cheap. 

I thought Clarke had bad blood with us and was very anti-returning?

Clarke’s issue was with Peace’s regime of which there is no trace remaining today.  His son has tweeted favourably several times about the club and about “unfinished business” here

I’d take him back in a heartbeat… a very, very good coach who was totally shat on by the McDonut and Peace.
Reply
#44
Honestly the way McDonut and peace treated Clarke, in any business other than football, Clarke could have sued for fucking fortunes, it was horrendous.

He never wanted to be part of the transfer process past saying I need A {position} who is good at {skill} and {skill}. Which is also an issue, we don't have the set up for that.
Reply
#45
(10-02-2022, 09:07 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Honestly the way McDonut and peace treated Clarke, in any business other than football, Clarke could have sued for fucking fortunes, it was horrendous.

He never wanted to be part of the transfer process past saying I need A {position} who is good at {skill} and {skill}. Which is also an issue, we don't have the set up for that.

Does he have a son in law playing in the lower leagues?
Reply
#46
(10-02-2022, 09:07 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Honestly the way McDonut and peace treated Clarke, in any business other than football, Clarke could have sued for fucking fortunes, it was horrendous.

He never wanted to be part of the transfer process past saying I need A {position} who is good at {skill} and {skill}. Which is also an issue, we don't have the set up for that.

Yep.

He was never the same since the Chelsea match where he was very close to ending Mourhinio's unbeaten home record.I seem to recall.

McDonough was a complete joke but remind me, who was the Italian fellow that we employed reminiscent of Comical Ali? He was brilliant.
Reply
#47
(10-02-2022, 09:18 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 09:07 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Honestly the way McDonut and peace treated Clarke, in any business other than football, Clarke could have sued for fucking fortunes, it was horrendous.

He never wanted to be part of the transfer process past saying I need A {position} who is good at {skill} and {skill}. Which is also an issue, we don't have the set up for that.

Yep.

He was never the same since the Chelsea match where he was very close to ending Mourhinio's unbeaten home record.I seem to recall.

McDonough was a complete joke but remind me, who was the Italian fellow that we employed reminiscent of Comical Ali? He was brilliant.

Yeah, that game was the turning point for him. 

McDonut went to Peace after that game with a dossier on everything Clarke did wrong, as he did when we beat Man Utd....
Reply
#48
(10-02-2022, 09:22 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 09:18 PM)Calgary_Baggie Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 09:07 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Honestly the way McDonut and peace treated Clarke, in any business other than football, Clarke could have sued for fucking fortunes, it was horrendous.

He never wanted to be part of the transfer process past saying I need A {position} who is good at {skill} and {skill}. Which is also an issue, we don't have the set up for that.

Yep.

He was never the same since the Chelsea match where he was very close to ending Mourhinio's unbeaten home record.I seem to recall.

McDonough was a complete joke but remind me, who was the Italian fellow that we employed reminiscent of Comical Ali? He was brilliant.

Yeah, that game was the turning point for him. 

McDonut went to Peace after that game with a dossier on everything Clarke did wrong, as he did when we beat Man Utd....

Forget that Italian,  my personal favourite involved with us was John Carver. 

Boy oh boy have we employed some idiots.
Reply
#49
(10-02-2022, 06:33 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 06:15 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 05:04 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 04:19 PM)Hopalong Wrote:
(10-02-2022, 03:37 PM)MassDebater Wrote: Surely would have to be gardening leave, and putting Brunt in charge? Is there anyone else at the club who could do it? I'm not even sure Brunt can, but can't think of anyone else.
Got to be better than this?

Can we afford not to sack him? 

There are plenty of people who would want the Albion job, still a big name in the football world.

Really? Which world is that?

WBA probably has a better standing in the game than we as Albion fans often think ourselves, despite the circus of the last few years. 

9 seasons in the last 12 in the World's biggest and richest league still make us an attractive proposition, if only we were perhaps more ambitious ourselves in our recruitment rather than turning to has-beens like Bruce and Allardyce.    The Championship itself is the 13th top football league in the world and we were able to attract Bilic who had previously managed in the Premier League and had other big european jobs including the Croation national team.  

We have a squad, which if properly coached still has an outside chance of promotion this season into the No 1 league that many in the world would love to manage in. 

We have a rich history and reputation for sound financial managment (one of the key reasons the Chinese investment company acquired us). 

We have been trail-blazers for equalities in the game and are well respected for it.  

Great stadium and great fanbase.

Very little of that actually matters in 2022.

Promotion already looks a forlorn hope. Assuming you need 75 points for the playoffs that means 64 from our remaining 35 games, or a rate of 1.83 points per game. That already looks massively unrealistic unless we sack Bruce tomorrow and can dig up a Cooper from somewhere. If you harbour dreams of automatic the run rate is roughly 2.11 points per game, which is downright impossible.

I disagree that very little of what I said matters in 2022,  in the context of attracting a new manager.  It's all part of the brand/product.  

I harbour no 'dreams' about WBA.  But it's not impossible to win 20 games and draw 4 from the remaining 35 - but not with the clueless Bruce in charge.  

Bruce was brought in to get us promoted and failed miserably.   What is the target for this season?  Everyone, including new signings when interviewed have said promotion.  So we're not doing very well towards that objective, are we? 

It's up to Lai, it's his club/business, everyone else is just an employee and couldn't give a toss ultimately.
Reply
#50
Some media gossip say's the decision to dump Bruce has now been taken. A quick look to see who we could get to take over this week will then see SB gone. Gardening leave costs being calculated.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)