ID Politics Eating Itself again
#11
The moment you are removed from some of the WhatsApp groups your obligations to any part in this end.
Reply
#12
(09-29-2022, 10:05 AM)Protheroe Wrote: Hilarious

https://www.pinknews.co.uk/2022/09/27/ro...ie-izzard/

I'll jump to your defence on this Proth. Just because the party you pledge allegiance to is making a colossal mess of the economy does not mean you can't joke/comment about other stuff. Your views, although I often disagree with them, are well thought through and it's good to have old fashioned debate rather than shouting into an echo chamber.

Regarding the issues of this story I too think it's bizarre that Eddie Izzard be considered a woman by anyone. 'He' is a bloke.  I think Labour's pandering to micro minorities does them no favour. They should be miles ahead of the Tories by now but aren't and I believe this identity politics alienates many. It certainly does with many people I know 45 plus.
Reply
#13
Ha ha! Fucking hell, we've got the new "I'm not voting Labour because"...

This week I've seen:

Identity politics; cannabis legislation and Keith Starmer's personality.

Seems like, for some, Kwarsi and Jacob could DP their wife in front of them and they'd be just glad of the chance to get close to the elite.
Reply
#14
(09-29-2022, 03:36 PM)SophLad Wrote: Ha ha!  Fucking hell, we've got the new "I'm not voting Labour because"...

This week I've seen:

Identity politics; cannabis legislation and Keith Starmer's personality. 

Seems like, for some, Kwarsi and Jacob could DP their wife in front of them and they'd be just glad of the chance to get close to the elite.

Wake up then Soph and get off your high horse and don't get things out of context.

'I think Labour's pandering to micro minorities does them no favour,' does not mean I'm going to vote Tory FFS.

Labour have to engage with the middle-ground, because with the internet and algorithms ruling the roost and pushing buttons that's the way it is now. I know plenty bewildered by identity politics to varying degrees. Personally I'll vote Labour, as a floating voter who has voted for all 3 parties and see myself as slightly left of centre generally- I would have anyway after years of utter incompetence with the Tories having more changes in charge than Watford, but you scoffing like you are is why Labour have been blitzed from their traditional heartlands. Look at the last election!

Everyone will have their own reasons, but even yesterday walking around Leigh in Lancs the BBC were talking to traditional working class people still not convinced. These working class people who love Boris Johnston and Brexit.

Don't under-estimate how many people are a danger armed with a vote and how complex the political landscape is now.
Reply
#15
(09-29-2022, 03:52 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-29-2022, 03:36 PM)SophLad Wrote: Ha ha!  Fucking hell, we've got the new "I'm not voting Labour because"...

This week I've seen:

Identity politics; cannabis legislation and Keith Starmer's personality. 

Seems like, for some, Kwarsi and Jacob could DP their wife in front of them and they'd be just glad of the chance to get close to the elite.

Wake up then Soph and get off your high horse and don't get things out of context.

'I think Labour's pandering to micro minorities does them no favour,' does not mean I'm going to vote Tory FFS.

Labour have to engage with the middle-ground, because with the internet and algorithms ruling the roost and pushing buttons that's the way it is now. I know plenty bewildered by identity politics to varying degrees. Personally I'll vote Labour, as a floating voter who has voted for all 3 parties and see myself as slightly left of centre generally- I would have anyway after years of utter incompetence with the Tories having more changes in charge than Watford, but you scoffing like you are is why Labour have been blitzed from their traditional heartlands. Look at the last election!

Everyone will have their own reasons, but even yesterday walking around Leigh in Lancs the BBC were talking to traditional working class people still not convinced. These working class people who love Boris Johnston and Brexit.

Don't under-estimate how many people are a danger armed with a vote and how complex the political landscape is now.

I have no problem with anyone expressing their opinion on here on any subject.

But I do find it odd that both you and Proth rail against identity politics, but by and large you are the only ones to start threads that involve identity politics.
Reply
#16
Agreed. Calling it identity politics also seems to neglect or avoid the fact that this permeates all areas of daily life now. Often for good reason.

And when there are still legitimate things about Labour that the demographic of voter referred to may find off putting, it only has relevance when weighed against what they may also find off putting about how the current government is impacting their lives. I can’t for the life of me see a sensible argument for why, when all things are considered, anyone would consider it still wise to vote Tory. They’re an absolute joke.
Reply
#17
(09-29-2022, 03:52 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Wake up then Soph and get off your high horse and don't get things out of context.

'I think Labour's pandering to micro minorities does them no favour,' does not mean I'm going to vote Tory FFS.

Labour have to engage with the middle-ground, because with the internet and algorithms ruling the roost and pushing buttons that's the way it is now. I know plenty bewildered by identity politics to varying degrees. Personally I'll vote Labour, as a floating voter who has voted for all 3 parties and see myself as slightly left of centre generally- I would have anyway after years of utter incompetence with the Tories having more changes in charge than Watford, but you scoffing like you are is why Labour have been blitzed from their traditional heartlands. Look at the last election!

Everyone will have their own reasons, but even yesterday walking around Leigh in Lancs the BBC were talking to traditional working class people still not convinced. These working class people who love Boris Johnston and Brexit.

Don't under-estimate how many people are a danger armed with a vote and how complex the political landscape is now.

The last election was Brexit, that's it. Labour lost is as soon as the pandered to the fundamentalist Remainers.

Your average working class bloke, by and large is not thinking about what colour Eddie Izzard has painted his nails much in the same way as the BME population on the whole do not want to cancel Little Britain. The phony culture wars are classic Tory divide and conquer tactics, we should all be old enough and wise enough to see past it.
Reply
#18
(09-29-2022, 03:52 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-29-2022, 03:36 PM)SophLad Wrote: Ha ha!  Fucking hell, we've got the new "I'm not voting Labour because"...

This week I've seen:

Identity politics; cannabis legislation and Keith Starmer's personality. 

Seems like, for some, Kwarsi and Jacob could DP their wife in front of them and they'd be just glad of the chance to get close to the elite.

Wake up then Soph and get off your high horse and don't get things out of context.

'I think Labour's pandering to micro minorities does them no favour,' does not mean I'm going to vote Tory FFS.

Labour have to engage with the middle-ground, because with the internet and algorithms ruling the roost and pushing buttons that's the way it is now. I know plenty bewildered by identity politics to varying degrees. Personally I'll vote Labour, as a floating voter who has voted for all 3 parties and see myself as slightly left of centre generally- I would have anyway after years of utter incompetence with the Tories having more changes in charge than Watford, but you scoffing like you are is why Labour have been blitzed from their traditional heartlands. Look at the last election!

Everyone will have their own reasons, but even yesterday walking around Leigh in Lancs the BBC were talking to traditional working class people still not convinced. These working class people who love Boris Johnston and Brexit.

Don't under-estimate how many people are a danger armed with a vote and how complex the political landscape is now.

Labour are currently on track for a comfortable majority, while the SNP, Greens and Lib Dems have shored up 20% of the polls.

What the hell more are they supposed to do? The Tories are polling below they did in 1997.
Reply
#19
(09-29-2022, 04:11 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote:
(09-29-2022, 03:52 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-29-2022, 03:36 PM)SophLad Wrote: Ha ha!  Fucking hell, we've got the new "I'm not voting Labour because"...

This week I've seen:

Identity politics; cannabis legislation and Keith Starmer's personality. 

Seems like, for some, Kwarsi and Jacob could DP their wife in front of them and they'd be just glad of the chance to get close to the elite.

Wake up then Soph and get off your high horse and don't get things out of context.

'I think Labour's pandering to micro minorities does them no favour,' does not mean I'm going to vote Tory FFS.

Labour have to engage with the middle-ground, because with the internet and algorithms ruling the roost and pushing buttons that's the way it is now. I know plenty bewildered by identity politics to varying degrees. Personally I'll vote Labour, as a floating voter who has voted for all 3 parties and see myself as slightly left of centre generally- I would have anyway after years of utter incompetence with the Tories having more changes in charge than Watford, but you scoffing like you are is why Labour have been blitzed from their traditional heartlands. Look at the last election!

Everyone will have their own reasons, but even yesterday walking around Leigh in Lancs the BBC were talking to traditional working class people still not convinced. These working class people who love Boris Johnston and Brexit.

Don't under-estimate how many people are a danger armed with a vote and how complex the political landscape is now.

I have no problem with anyone expressing their opinion on here on any subject.

But I do find it odd that both you and Proth rail against identity politics, but by and large you are the only ones to start threads that involve identity politics.

I've seen identity politics at its worst chap, dating back many years and since then have always hated it.

1985 my girlfriend was a student at Wolverhampton Poly and shared a house with 2 other girls. One girl was West Indian background and we knew her well, for over a year. She was just Monica to us. She joined the then Afro Caribbean body at the Poly and practically overnight became utterly vile, aggressive and extremely racist to us for being white. She had to leave and she and a group of her new friends made life hell for my girlfriend and the other girl with late night parties etc.

I was a journalist too, many moons ago, and encountered many people with their big issues. A group of angry lesbians provided great entertainment once hissing venom at me for being a regular stereotype heterosexual bloke.

The 'them and us' bullshit surrounding identity politics is utterly toxic and I've encountered the bullshit of this in the public sector too.

Of course it is everywhere- It can be jokingly Dingles are like this and Seals are like that (unbelievably some people really believe it) or it can be far more insidious. 

I can be a father, a husband, a businessman, an Albion fan, an Irish lad, a Brummie, a real ale drinker, a dog owner, and a friggin heap of other labels, but if you allow an overarching feeling of victimhood based on a strong strand of your identity then the chances are you are going to be a pain in the arse for society.

This isn't to say victimisation and issues should be overlooked, but there's an unhealthy problem with this and it's getting a ridiculous amount of media coverage which is beyond doubt. Hope you understand chap.
Reply
#20
(09-29-2022, 03:52 PM)Yeah Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(09-29-2022, 03:36 PM)SophLad Wrote: Ha ha!  Fucking hell, we've got the new "I'm not voting Labour because"...

This week I've seen:

Identity politics; cannabis legislation and Keith Starmer's personality. 

Seems like, for some, Kwarsi and Jacob could DP their wife in front of them and they'd be just glad of the chance to get close to the elite.

Wake up then Soph and get off your high horse and don't get things out of context.

'I think Labour's pandering to micro minorities does them no favour,' does not mean I'm going to vote Tory FFS.

Labour have to engage with the middle-ground, because with the internet and algorithms ruling the roost and pushing buttons that's the way it is now. I know plenty bewildered by identity politics to varying degrees. Personally I'll vote Labour, as a floating voter who has voted for all 3 parties and see myself as slightly left of centre generally- I would have anyway after years of utter incompetence with the Tories having more changes in charge than Watford, but you scoffing like you are is why Labour have been blitzed from their traditional heartlands. Look at the last election!

Everyone will have their own reasons, but even yesterday walking around Leigh in Lancs the BBC were talking to traditional working class people still not convinced. These working class people who love Boris Johnston and Brexit.

Don't under-estimate how many people are a danger armed with a vote and how complex the political landscape is now.

I’ll wager a lead of 31% in the polls suggests things are looking fairly clear

https://mobile.twitter.com/BritainElects...101245440y
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)