In defence of Bruce…
(09-19-2022, 07:07 PM)Sliced Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 06:12 PM)strawman Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 05:11 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 04:31 PM)strawman Wrote: Trajectory
first 5 games 2.6pts per game
next 5 1.8, then 1.2, 1.2, 1.6. 0.75 in last 4 games and sacked.

TBF Bruce didn't improve upon anything but by that stage I suspect all confidence had gone anyway.

Whatever the truth is about a lack of confidence when Bruce arrived (if they supposedly hated Ismael's style of play so much, you'd have thought they'd have been buoyed by him going!), isn't it part of a manger's responsibility to be able to lift morale?

I might be misunderstanding, but you seem to be implicitly suggesting that Ismael was responsible for Bruce's non-performance in the 28 games the latter has been in charge of. Perhaps you could also give us 5 match splits for Bruce's PPG as well for comparison?

Not at all - I'm suggesting that they both overall had downward trajectories which basically translates to - I have no idea why we keep comparing them as with political parties it's like comparing 1 useless entity with another - aka they are both crap (for us anyway)

Bruce First 5 games 0.2 pts then 1.6 (Oh the hope), 1.4 then 2 pts per game for the last 2. 1pt per game this season saved from 0.11 per game by the remarkable acheivement of winning  1 game

It's a natural comparison to make when we sacked Ismael while sat in the playoffs and hardly anyone thought it was harsh, and now we're 21st.

(09-19-2022, 07:05 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm not going to bother repeating why I think at this moment he should stay.

But one thing I find baffling is this obsession with us being 21st.

We are only 10 games in, last season we were 2nd 10 games in, didn't mean we ended up there.

At this stage there are a handful of points separating about 20 teams, you can swap places with the team in 5th in a small number of games. Why stress about it.

It's a bit like worrying about other teams results before Xmas, what does it matter.

Because that's the only thing that matters. We're aiming for promotion and we have 20 teams above us. It's nothing like worrying about other teams results before Christmas because we carry over those lost points. 

Also why would anyone assume that we're going to shoot up the table, we can also drop lower.

Since Bruce has taken over we have only been moving in one direction, and it isn’t upwards.
I
Reply
(09-19-2022, 09:34 PM)hudds Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 07:20 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 06:48 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 06:33 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 05:55 PM)Duffers Wrote: Give him the season… then trust him to lead our League One campaign next year.

Maybe..but who knows.... Either way it's just as big a risk if we sack him too... 2 examples albeit from long a go and in a different landscape. Howard Kendall and Ferguson, gone into todays crazy climate yet led teams to glory.

Granted we are not Everton nor Man Utd but the same principle applies nonetheless .

Given that our trajectory has been indisputably downwards since he took over, and seems to be accelerating, is it not a bigger risk to keep him?

Can anyone genuinely look at the last 30 or so games and think “yeah, this guy will take us back up”? Are we really to believe there are no alternatives out there who can manage more than a point a game?
The problem is far more reaching than the manager, its the hierarchy of the club, and yet we still want the manager gone, with a belief things will be better the next time.

How tall is Bruce?  Stats say he is 4' 10".  That's four foot ten, kids.
Nah, that’s his waist
Reply
The league position can be misleading, that's why current form is important. Under Val, the form was atrocious, but league position good. Under Bruce the current form is atrocious, as is the league position.
If Val was rightly sacked, which I believe he was, then there is no defending Bruce.
Upshot is, they were both poor coaches, in relation to the squad they had, therefore, when Bruce goes, the key to recruiting the next bloke, is someone who's style and vision suits the players we have. Whether that person exists is the $1m question. My belief is that it does, but it will probably not be a fashionable name and will come from the lower leagues. as did Atkinson, as did Megson.
Reply
(09-20-2022, 08:29 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: The league position can be misleading, that's why current form is important. Under Val, the form was atrocious, but league position good. Under Bruce the current form is atrocious, as is the league position.
If Val was rightly sacked, which I believe he was, then there is no defending Bruce.
Upshot is, they were both poor coaches, in relation to the squad they had, therefore, when Bruce goes, the key to recruiting the next bloke, is someone who's style and vision suits the players we have. Whether that person exists is the $1m question. My belief is that it does, but it will probably not be a fashionable name and will come from the lower leagues. as did Atkinson, as did Megson.

Good post, spot on about a manager who comes from lower down the league. One who wants to be a winner.
Reply
...and knows his best/only chance of developing his career is by getting a club promoted to the Premier League (see Cooper, Frank and Dyche) as top clubs will not give jobs to lower league managers
Reply
Talks of trajectory…..surely had some point the draws are going to turn into wins / defeats sooner than later, otherwise we’re on for 32 draws from 46 games which is surely unheard of.

The way we’ve sued so far suggests we’re more than likely to turn draws into wins I think / hope?!
Reply
(09-19-2022, 06:12 PM)strawman Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 05:11 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 04:31 PM)strawman Wrote: Trajectory
first 5 games 2.6pts per game
next 5 1.8, then 1.2, 1.2, 1.6. 0.75 in last 4 games and sacked.

TBF Bruce didn't improve upon anything but by that stage I suspect all confidence had gone anyway.

Whatever the truth is about a lack of confidence when Bruce arrived (if they supposedly hated Ismael's style of play so much, you'd have thought they'd have been buoyed by him going!), isn't it part of a manger's responsibility to be able to lift morale?

I might be misunderstanding, but you seem to be implicitly suggesting that Ismael was responsible for Bruce's non-performance in the 28 games the latter has been in charge of. Perhaps you could also give us 5 match splits for Bruce's PPG as well for comparison?

Not at all - I'm suggesting that they both overall had downward trajectories which basically translates to - I have no idea why we keep comparing them as with political parties it's like comparing 1 useless entity with another - aka they are both crap (for us anyway)

Bruce First 5 games 0.2 pts then 1.6 (Oh the hope), 1.4 then 2 pts per game for the last 2. 1pt per game this season saved from 0.11 per game by the remarkable acheivement of winning  1 game

Thanks for working that out, there's nothing much for Bruce to be able to write home about there.
Reply
12 games is enough, he’s had his chance and time to go. Been unlucky in parts, poorly backed in transfers and points definitely don’t match the performances.

Ultimately failed, I just dread to think who they’ll dream of picking next…
Trump is a Cunt
Reply
I think that should be the end for Bruce.

Was prepared to give him time to bed in players like Rogic, Kelly, Pieters.

But his decision making is getting more confused.

And whilst the performance overall wasn't awful, another slow start and there is a lack of conviction and devil in our play.
Reply
(10-05-2022, 08:52 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: 12 games is enough, he’s had his chance and time to go.  Been unlucky in parts, poorly backed in transfers  and points definitely don’t match the performances.

Ultimately failed, I just dread to think who they’ll dream of picking next…
`Following an exhaustive process, and looking at several outstanding candidates, we have decided that Alex McLeish / Mick McCarthy / Chris Hughton * is the obvious choice to be our new head coach, his vast experience being perfectly suited to take us forward`.

*Delete as appropriate.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)