In defence of Bruce…
(09-19-2022, 06:12 PM)strawman Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 05:11 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 04:31 PM)strawman Wrote: Trajectory
first 5 games 2.6pts per game
next 5 1.8, then 1.2, 1.2, 1.6. 0.75 in last 4 games and sacked.

TBF Bruce didn't improve upon anything but by that stage I suspect all confidence had gone anyway.

Whatever the truth is about a lack of confidence when Bruce arrived (if they supposedly hated Ismael's style of play so much, you'd have thought they'd have been buoyed by him going!), isn't it part of a manger's responsibility to be able to lift morale?

I might be misunderstanding, but you seem to be implicitly suggesting that Ismael was responsible for Bruce's non-performance in the 28 games the latter has been in charge of. Perhaps you could also give us 5 match splits for Bruce's PPG as well for comparison?

Not at all - I'm suggesting that they both overall had downward trajectories which basically translates to - I have no idea why we keep comparing them as with political parties it's like comparing 1 useless entity with another - aka they are both crap (for us anyway)

Bruce First 5 games 0.2 pts then 1.6 (Oh the hope), 1.4 then 2 pts per game for the last 2. 1pt per game this season saved from 0.11 per game by the remarkable acheivement of winning  1 game

It's a natural comparison to make when we sacked Ismael while sat in the playoffs and hardly anyone thought it was harsh, and now we're 21st.

(09-19-2022, 07:05 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm not going to bother repeating why I think at this moment he should stay.

But one thing I find baffling is this obsession with us being 21st.

We are only 10 games in, last season we were 2nd 10 games in, didn't mean we ended up there.

At this stage there are a handful of points separating about 20 teams, you can swap places with the team in 5th in a small number of games. Why stress about it.

It's a bit like worrying about other teams results before Xmas, what does it matter.

Because that's the only thing that matters. We're aiming for promotion and we have 20 teams above us. It's nothing like worrying about other teams results before Christmas because we carry over those lost points. 

Also why would anyone assume that we're going to shoot up the table, we can also drop lower.
Reply
(09-19-2022, 06:48 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 06:33 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 05:55 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 05:52 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote:
(09-17-2022, 06:12 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: I’m sure I’m now in a minority and I’m beginning to question how much he should get too.

However a few things need to be considered, which does include ‘who else then’.

1) i don’t blame him for last season.  Yes he failed to hit the remit but we we’re sixth and teams had games in hand to drop us to 8th.  Val’s style had stopped working after 10 games, Bruce tried to change it and found the players wanting.  There was a lack of forwards and zero midfield creativity, as soon as he started to try and make us more expansive we shipped goals.  The squad was totally unbalanced and had no focal point to play off.

2) The finances.  I’m sure what he’s said in the press and how he really feels are 2 different things.  It’s rare to find a manager who doesn’t want that extra player.  We clearly had to cut the wage bill and you can only shift players that other clubs want.  I’m sure Martin Kelly wasn’t the first player he thought of ffs.

3) Resources.  I keep hearing our wage bill is so much higher we should be doing better.  Bartley, Livermore, Phillips and Zohore must be taking £6m a year from our budget and offering fuck all.  Furlong a fair chunk alongside Grant.  

4) The squad.  How many would get in a top of the table squad, or the newly relegated teams?
Our keeper is mist, the ball goes through him.
We don’t have a defender, maybe O’Shea, worthy of a top 6 starting XI.
Molumby is at best a bang average Champ midfielder, Livermore is shot.
The only quality we have is Okay, Swift, Wallace, Diangana and we don’t know about Dike.  Grant is a decent Champo player but having to play out of position. 
Basically the best players we have Bruce has brought in, maybe he should get January to add to that?

5) Luck.  Has been in short supply, what bit there has been is all bad.

One win in 10 isn’t good enough, but all bar 2-3 games we’ve deserved more, which shows the performances are there just, to me, that lack of quality.  Dike may make a huge difference, he should be able to hold the ball up and be a focal point for the quality we do have to play off him.

We haven’t kept anyone long enough to form a balanced squad for a few years now which is why we’ve ended up with this potpourri overpaid shit bunch.  They’re difficult to motivate because they know it’s down hill from here, nothing left to achieve, they need weeding out and replacing.  Bruce is at least getting that bit done.

For me I’d give him the opportunity to get Rogic fit, get Pieters and Kelly involved and hopefully Dike and let’s see where we are at the World Cup break.

Good post and sensible approach in my opinion. I don't see the value in sacking Bruce. Firstly, financially it will cost the club money they can ill afford, secondly we have lost just 2 games, and probably should have won more, there are some shoots of optimism. 

If we sack Bruce who comes in? Bruce should be given the season at least, I do not think we will go down. After all we are a club in decline financially, the parachute payments have dried up and the investment is clearly not there, personally it will do more harm than good.

To compare league position to previous manager is not a true or fair comparison, the squad is now poorer, certain players are now in decline, bad luck with injures has not helped either, sack him now and we must start all over again. The continuity suffers. 

It has been proven before. Bilic went and Allardyce came in and did little to arrest the decline, all we are doing is rearranging the deck chairs.

As the post above suggest give him more time, with everyone back fit, and over a season.

Give him the season… then trust him to lead our League One campaign next year.

Maybe..but who knows.... Either way it's just as big a risk if we sack him too... 2 examples albeit from long a go and in a different landscape. Howard Kendall and Ferguson, gone into todays crazy climate yet led teams to glory.

Granted we are not Everton nor Man Utd but the same principle applies nonetheless .

Given that our trajectory has been indisputably downwards since he took over, and seems to be accelerating, is it not a bigger risk to keep him?

Can anyone genuinely look at the last 30 or so games and think “yeah, this guy will take us back up”? Are we really to believe there are no alternatives out there who can manage more than a point a game?
The problem is far more reaching than the manager, its the hierarchy of the club, and yet we still want the manager gone, with a belief things will be better the next time.
Reply
(09-19-2022, 07:20 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 06:48 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 06:33 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 05:55 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 05:52 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote: Good post and sensible approach in my opinion. I don't see the value in sacking Bruce. Firstly, financially it will cost the club money they can ill afford, secondly we have lost just 2 games, and probably should have won more, there are some shoots of optimism. 

If we sack Bruce who comes in? Bruce should be given the season at least, I do not think we will go down. After all we are a club in decline financially, the parachute payments have dried up and the investment is clearly not there, personally it will do more harm than good.

To compare league position to previous manager is not a true or fair comparison, the squad is now poorer, certain players are now in decline, bad luck with injures has not helped either, sack him now and we must start all over again. The continuity suffers. 

It has been proven before. Bilic went and Allardyce came in and did little to arrest the decline, all we are doing is rearranging the deck chairs.

As the post above suggest give him more time, with everyone back fit, and over a season.

Give him the season… then trust him to lead our League One campaign next year.

Maybe..but who knows.... Either way it's just as big a risk if we sack him too... 2 examples albeit from long a go and in a different landscape. Howard Kendall and Ferguson, gone into todays crazy climate yet led teams to glory.

Granted we are not Everton nor Man Utd but the same principle applies nonetheless .

Given that our trajectory has been indisputably downwards since he took over, and seems to be accelerating, is it not a bigger risk to keep him?

Can anyone genuinely look at the last 30 or so games and think “yeah, this guy will take us back up”? Are we really to believe there are no alternatives out there who can manage more than a point a game?
The problem is far more reaching than the manager, its the hierarchy of the club, and yet we still want the manager gone, with a belief things will be better the next time.

Completely agree that the entire club needs a shake up from top to bottom… but it does not excuse the terrible job Bruce is doing so far.

Whatever is going on behind the scenes that squad should be doing better than 21st.
Reply
Colin West appointed as Assistant at Hartlepool. Go get him, Ron.
Reply
(09-19-2022, 08:09 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Colin West appointed as Assistant at Hartlepool. Go get him, Ron.

Compensation might be the issue…
Reply
(09-19-2022, 08:13 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 08:09 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: Colin West appointed as Assistant at Hartlepool. Go get him, Ron.

Compensation might be the issue…

We should have been all over this before he signed  Cool
Reply
We could put Richard Beale the under 23 coach in charge because it’s an improvement on Bruce.We actually need a good coach on the training ground,somebody to organise and set the team up.Our squad isn’t that bad and should be more than competitive in this League.
        To put Beale in charge for a bit would be no more of a risk than keeping Bruce and sometimes a fresh face and new ideas work.Could Beale do it long term ,then I’m not sure but he is certainly someone who is a good coach and would give us time to get the right person in.
Reply
(09-19-2022, 07:20 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 06:48 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 06:33 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 05:55 PM)Duffers Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 05:52 PM)Robbo2604 Wrote: Good post and sensible approach in my opinion. I don't see the value in sacking Bruce. Firstly, financially it will cost the club money they can ill afford, secondly we have lost just 2 games, and probably should have won more, there are some shoots of optimism. 

If we sack Bruce who comes in? Bruce should be given the season at least, I do not think we will go down. After all we are a club in decline financially, the parachute payments have dried up and the investment is clearly not there, personally it will do more harm than good.

To compare league position to previous manager is not a true or fair comparison, the squad is now poorer, certain players are now in decline, bad luck with injures has not helped either, sack him now and we must start all over again. The continuity suffers. 

It has been proven before. Bilic went and Allardyce came in and did little to arrest the decline, all we are doing is rearranging the deck chairs.

As the post above suggest give him more time, with everyone back fit, and over a season.

Give him the season… then trust him to lead our League One campaign next year.

Maybe..but who knows.... Either way it's just as big a risk if we sack him too... 2 examples albeit from long a go and in a different landscape. Howard Kendall and Ferguson, gone into todays crazy climate yet led teams to glory.

Granted we are not Everton nor Man Utd but the same principle applies nonetheless .

Given that our trajectory has been indisputably downwards since he took over, and seems to be accelerating, is it not a bigger risk to keep him?

Can anyone genuinely look at the last 30 or so games and think “yeah, this guy will take us back up”? Are we really to believe there are no alternatives out there who can manage more than a point a game?
The problem is far more reaching than the manager, its the hierarchy of the club, and yet we still want the manager gone, with a belief things will be better the next time.

How tall is Bruce?  Stats say he is 4' 10".  That's four foot ten, kids.
Reply
(09-19-2022, 07:05 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm not going to bother repeating why I think at this moment he should stay.

But one thing I find baffling is this obsession with us being 21st.

We are only 10 games in, last season we were 2nd 10 games in, didn't mean we ended up there.

At this stage there are a handful of points separating about 20 teams, you can swap places with the team in 5th in a small number of games. Why stress about it.

It's a bit like worrying about other teams results before Xmas, what does it matter.

Too sensible post
As I said previously my mindset on Bruce Changes daily/ hourly
Think he should get until the WC break if no better push the button (he can go as well)
Reply
(09-20-2022, 05:36 AM)Hughie Reed 31 Wrote:
(09-19-2022, 07:05 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I'm not going to bother repeating why I think at this moment he should stay.

But one thing I find baffling is this obsession with us being 21st.

We are only 10 games in, last season we were 2nd 10 games in, didn't mean we ended up there.

At this stage there are a handful of points separating about 20 teams, you can swap places with the team in 5th in a small number of games. Why stress about it.

It's a bit like worrying about other teams results before Xmas, what does it matter.

Too sensible post
As I said previously my mindset on Bruce Changes daily/ hourly
Think he should get until the WC break if no better push the button (he can go as well)
Spot on this. If we are going to change and I have no issue with changing, we need to get a DoF in first, assess the situation, come up with a long term plan and find someone who fits that vision. Otherwise, we'll be back in this situation in six months.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 12 Guest(s)