Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
We didn't do the paperwork correctly.
It's the fault of different times between league's
It's because of the different rules
It's someone else's fault
It's over and done, either sack Pearce or forget it.
COYB
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(09-04-2022, 10:08 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I think it speaks volumes for the lack of trust we have with our owner that many fans immediately thought it was a deliberate mistake in order to save money.
We'll probably never find out the real reason, but it paints the picture of an unprofessional club, and the position we're in is the responsibility of our absent owner.
Gourlay was CEO at Chelsea for 5 years, so organising a department to ensure that a couple of loan signings go through smoothly on deadline evening shouldn't be beyond him.
I can't believe that there was any skullduggery on the Board's part to prevent these deals going through, not least because the only hope Lai has of not losing the vast majority of his investment is for us to get promoted. Therefore, sabotaging these deals would be absolutely senseless.
Consequently, I think the buck stops with Gourlay for the deals not going through on Thursday night. If the club is entirely blameless for what happened then it should come out and say so. For it not to do that would effectively be an admission of culpability in my view.
Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
IF, the reason the deals didn't go through is really all down to Brighton, & Fulham not giving the go ahead until they'd secured signings, why haven't our club issued a simple statement saying so?
It's really not rocket science, but the silence is deafening, Bruce was clearly not at all happy, & his demeanor makes me think that we might've fucked up on at least one of them.
Not citing any conspiracy theory, or skullduggery, but with all the nonsense over Lai's loans, the club not clearing the air on this is just making the fans suspicious, & wary of all sorts of shit.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
What I would say is that with Alzate in Brightons matchday squad of 18, alongside Gilmour, I do wonder how motivated they were to do the deal.
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
(09-04-2022, 12:48 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: What I would say is that with Alzate in Brightons matchday squad of 18, alongside Gilmour, I do wonder how motivated they were to do the deal. Clearly he would be on a good salary. Which begs the question of how motivated were we to deal?
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
I've been following the Albion since the mid-Sixties. I can't remember a time when the terraces weren't full of angry people who hated, mistrusted and abused the club ownership and management hierarchy. Didn't matter whether we were riding high or plunging down the divisions. Now we have social media, people can vent these negative feelings at will, they don't need to wait for match day or Saturday evening down the pub. The need for a spacegoat is so much more acute now, because people spend so much more time on-line - frankly like news, football doesn't have enough going on to fill 24 hours each day.
A lot of this is the politics of envy. You and I are never going to own a football club, so anyone who does is clearly a bad'un, to be disrespected. We had some shabby ownership through the successful Sixties and reasonably successful Seventies. Paul Thompson was good, Peace had a very good run - but at no time did the fans ever say "My word, they've done a good job". Now we have the archetypal bad, absentee owner. We were desperate for Peace to sell to a wealthy foreigner, and look what we got. We are in a mess because China's property market is in a mess, no doubt about that. But - - - -
I see no reason to assume that the failure of the two incoming loans was purely due to inefficiency at the Albion or skulduggery by the owners. There are credible mitigating factors in the differences between Premier League and EFL transfer protocols, and also differing requirements for selling to a Welsh club. A press release would be nice, but if the Albion outed Fulham and Brighton, we'd never get another loan. Would it have been different if we had cash to spend, instead of fishing for loans? Who knows, we'd still be at the end of the line waiting for Premier League clubs to conclude their business. There was probably fault all round which, with hindsight, should have been anticipated - we definitely should not have ended up where we are. But I find the attitude of many posters on here, the absolute conviction that our club is entirely at fault, the anger and abuse puzzling and rather disappointing. Negativity is a rather charmless Black Country trait. I wish we could try to rise above it sometimes.
Posts: 1,777
Threads: 5
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
4
(09-04-2022, 10:54 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote: (09-04-2022, 10:08 AM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote: I think it speaks volumes for the lack of trust we have with our owner that many fans immediately thought it was a deliberate mistake in order to save money.
We'll probably never find out the real reason, but it paints the picture of an unprofessional club, and the position we're in is the responsibility of our absent owner.
Gourlay was CEO at Chelsea for 5 years, so organising a department to ensure that a couple of loan signings go through smoothly on deadline evening shouldn't be beyond him.
I can't believe that there was any skullduggery on the Board's part to prevent these deals going through, not least because the only hope Lai has of not losing the vast majority of his investment is for us to get promoted. Therefore, sabotaging these deals would be absolutely senseless.
Consequently, I think the buck stops with Gourlay for the deals not going through on Thursday night. If the club is entirely blameless for what happened then it should come out and say so. For it not to do that would effectively be an admission of culpability in my view. I take your point. Gourlay has to be accountable for his teams failings. I've reached the point though where I feel the owner has to be accountable for the decisions that have been made over the last few years that have contributed to us dropping from top dogs in the Midlands to where we are now.
He owns the club, it's his name above the door. I remember Silk denouncing responsibility when we got relegated to the 3rd tier by stating that he didn't miss the penalties against Port Vale. I didn't buy that then, and I don't buy that Lai shouldn't be accountable now.
Posts: 2,953
Threads: 67
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
12
(09-04-2022, 01:27 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I've been following the Albion since the mid-Sixties. I can't remember a time when the terraces weren't full of angry people who hated, mistrusted and abused the club ownership and management hierarchy. Didn't matter whether we were riding high or plunging down the divisions. Now we have social media, people can vent these negative feelings at will, they don't need to wait for match day or Saturday evening down the pub. The need for a spacegoat is so much more acute now, because people spend so much more time on-line - frankly like news, football doesn't have enough going on to fill 24 hours each day.
A lot of this is the politics of envy. You and I are never going to own a football club, so anyone who does is clearly a bad'un, to be disrespected. We had some shabby ownership through the successful Sixties and reasonably successful Seventies. Paul Thompson was good, Peace had a very good run - but at no time did the fans ever say "My word, they've done a good job". Now we have the archetypal bad, absentee owner. We were desperate for Peace to sell to a wealthy foreigner, and look what we got. We are in a mess because China's property market is in a mess, no doubt about that. But - - - -
I see no reason to assume that the failure of the two incoming loans was purely due to inefficiency at the Albion or skulduggery by the owners. There are credible mitigating factors in the differences between Premier League and EFL transfer protocols, and also differing requirements for selling to a Welsh club. A press release would be nice, but if the Albion outed Fulham and Brighton, we'd never get another loan. Would it have been different if we had cash to spend, instead of fishing for loans? Who knows, we'd still be at the end of the line waiting for Premier League clubs to conclude their business. There was probably fault all round which, with hindsight, should have been anticipated - we definitely should not have ended up where we are. But I find the attitude of many posters on here, the absolute conviction that our club is entirely at fault, the anger and abuse puzzling and rather disappointing. Negativity is a rather charmless Black Country trait. I wish we could try to rise above it sometimes.
Excellent reasoned and thoughtful.
Won't make any difference to the moaners but good on you for trying.
Posts: 8,085
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
09-04-2022, 02:56 PM
(This post was last modified: 09-04-2022, 02:57 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Great post.
But things are still shit.
Personally, frustrating as it got at times, I never saw enough reason to want Peace out. The progress was there to see, particularly off-field (although he did leave us considerably better off there, even if on the wane), and through all of the penny-pinching you could see he was willing to protect his investment.
This lot seem to want to strip all of that, now they’ve realised they’ve botched and lost the main revenue stream; probably for good. It’s Lai’s only way now not to lose his shirt. So I don’t recall a time quite like this before, although admittedly my parents hadn’t even met by the mid-sixties. The club is vulnerable and I don’t think its best interests are at the owners’ hearts anymore.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(09-04-2022, 02:56 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: Great post.
But things are still shit.
Personally, frustrating as it got at times, I never saw enough reason to want Peace out. The progress was there to see, particularly off-field (although he did leave us considerably better off there, even if on the wane), and through all of the penny-pinching you could see he was willing to protect his investment.
This lot seem to want to strip all of that, now they’ve realised they’ve botched and lost the main revenue stream; probably for good. It’s Lai’s only way now not to lose his shirt. So I don’t recall a time quite like this before, although admittedly my parents hadn’t even met by the mid-sixties. The club is vulnerable and I don’t think its best interests are at the owners’ hearts anymore.
That's the truth of it
|