Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
09-03-2022, 06:43 AM
(This post was last modified: 09-03-2022, 06:44 AM by Fido.)
(09-02-2022, 11:29 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote: Not sure I’d give anyone over a 7… was 6s/7s all round really… we played alright, created a few changes and made a few errors that they could have punished. Have only seen it live, and felt their penalty build up was offside.
We play with really low intensity, and our build up play is so laboured. Burnley broke with a lot more purpose and their passing around the box was much more decisive and accurate. We have no excuses for being so sloppy around our opponent’s box as we have some very talented players for this division and that needs Ru improve.
Set pieces better tonight, Bartley a threat from dead balls and we managed to hit him a couple times.
Button - 6
Townsend - 6
Bartley - 7
O’Shea - 6.5
TGH - 6
Okay - 6.5
Molumby - 4 (seriously he is garbage but can run)
Diangana - 7*
Swift - 6
Wallace - 6.5
Grant - 5
BTA - 6
Phillips - 5
Livermore - 5
Thought Bruce had his best tactical game tonight… several tactical changes, swapping to a 4-2-4 and then a weird back 3/4 hybrid. Having fewer options seems to make him work a bit harder and be more enterprising.
Decent point, could have won it, could have lost it.
I’d take off a point from both full-backs who didn’t have great games and give them to Okay.
Posts: 295
Threads: 73
Joined: Jun 2022
Blimey some differing opinions on tonight’s ratings (not least on Bartley).
I suspect most of the rose tint brigade would have posted more realistic marks as I have done had we not scored a last minute equalizer by a debutant striker.
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(09-03-2022, 06:39 AM)Duffers Wrote: (09-03-2022, 06:25 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (09-03-2022, 06:14 AM)strawman Wrote: (09-03-2022, 06:04 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Button - 6 - wasn't a Peno, he got the ball. Nothing else to do.
TGH - 6 - plenty of running and endeavour, little in the way of quality. Still behind furlong for me.
Bartley - 3 - nearly scored, won some headers, but aside from that, shite. Needs to be a bench option for if we are defending a lead and people are pumping the ball in. No more.
O'Shea - 7 - Solid, good distribution. Grew into the game when Okay dropped in.
Townsend - 5 - Solid for the most part, nearly cot us and never looked like creating. Maybe needs a 'rest'. Reach to start next game.
Molumby - 6 - Does the hard things well and basics poorly. There were times I was thinking he should be replaced but then his energy and drive really got us going. All in all he did enough to stay on for me, and should start again next game. But he needs to sort him self out in terms of his contribution in possession.
Okay - 9 (MOTM) - Rolls Royce. Still isn't 100% fit, but my god he's class, seemed even better at CB too with the whole pitch ahead of him.
Wallace - 7 - Always looks likely to create, and never stops. Turning into Mr Reliable. Should've scored though, twice. Would have been a ten if he had have done.
Swift - 8 - Anything good we do comes through him. Yes he doesn't dribble past 4 players, or he isn't the best athlete. But he has a bit of class that will help us unlock teams. Need to drop deeper.
Grady - 7 - Always involved but stuff just didn't come off for him. Still our best creative outlet and should be given a. Free role with another attacker replacing one of the DMs.
Grant - 7 - Thought his hold up play was decent, and he just never stops grafting. As always limited but tried his best.
Subs:
Phillips - 6 - Added width, an attacking outlet and a bit of drive. But delivery frustrating given his undoubted crossing ability.
Livermore - 6 - Steady when he came on and broke up the play in deeper areas when we evacuated the midfield somewhat towards the end. Him or Okay can play that role alone between them and be fine.
BTA - 7 - Got his goal, showed pace, aggression, hunger and plenty of confidence. Needs a good week in training picking up patterns of play, but should give us more of a threat from that deep forward role.
Bruce - 9 - Got all the major calls right in game, and made good, effective and ambitious changes which asked questions of Kompany. Much better. But I hope this was just out of desperation. He needs to have the mindset consistently, and my worry is he just doesn't. But fingers crossed.
Fans - 10 - Happy to hear them in fine voice. They are better fans than me no doubtbat all. Fantastic showing by them.
Getting the ball first has minimal relevance as to whether a foul has occurred. There is no reference to making contact with the ball in the section relating to Fouls and Misconduct in the Laws of the Game, but it may be considered by the referee in deciding whether contact was careless, reckless or excessively forceful.
There are six offences in which contact is made with an opponent that cause a direct free kick to be awarded: - kicks an opponent carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force
- trips an opponent carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force
- charges an opponent carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force
- strikes an opponent carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force
- pushes an opponent carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force
- holds an opponent
Button plainly tripped an opponent carelessly so it's a penalty
You are allowed to trip an opponent if the challenge was successful, then it's based on reckless or excessive force, neither of which Buttons challenge were. The challenge by button wasn't 'Careless' it was a textbook 'K' block and his foot won the ball. For me it wasn't a Peno, but it is what it is. They should've had one for Dara's handball, so it was 1-1 in my mind, anyway.
It was a penalty because even though Button touched the ball it would not have made any difference to Tella going through. Had Button not taken him down Tella was still going to score regardless of that touch.
Agree. I always try and look at a penalty against us and ask myself what I would want if it was an Albion player. I'd be fuming if that wasn't given.
Secondly that first touch from Tella was absolutely incredible. The lad deserved that penalty for the touch alone.
Posts: 1,039
Threads: 48
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
For me Button was a 5 max. There were two occasions at least where he should have come out quickly but he misjudged it both times and ended up either in no man's land or rooted to his line.
Generally I think he's been okay this season and was unlucky for his penalty foul so that doesn't come into his rating today but he wasn't strong enough in certain areas and we'd have been punished further had it not been for Burnley being a bit crap.
Posts: 10,545
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
Agree with a lot of what's already been posted.
One who is sticking out for all the wrong reasons at the moment is Conor Townsend, he's been absolutely honking so far this season. Honestly wouldn't mind seeing Reach have a run at left back.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
(09-03-2022, 07:47 AM)HLS Wrote: For me Button was a 5 max. There were two occasions at least where he should have come out quickly but he misjudged it both times and ended up either in no man's land or rooted to his line.
Generally I think he's been okay this season and was unlucky for his penalty foul so that doesn't come into his rating today but he wasn't strong enough in certain areas and we'd have been punished further had it not been for Burnley being a bit crap.
I think one of those times you refer to was when he hesitated to come out because although it was a 50-50, he had been booked once and could not afford to get it wrong.
I really can't agree with whoever said Burnley were crap, I think they'll be up there this season. For me, that double sub when they took off Tella and 27 (I think) helped us no end.
Posts: 7,408
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(09-03-2022, 06:25 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (09-03-2022, 06:14 AM)strawman Wrote: (09-03-2022, 06:04 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Button - 6 - wasn't a Peno, he got the ball. Nothing else to do.
TGH - 6 - plenty of running and endeavour, little in the way of quality. Still behind furlong for me.
Bartley - 3 - nearly scored, won some headers, but aside from that, shite. Needs to be a bench option for if we are defending a lead and people are pumping the ball in. No more.
O'Shea - 7 - Solid, good distribution. Grew into the game when Okay dropped in.
Townsend - 5 - Solid for the most part, nearly cot us and never looked like creating. Maybe needs a 'rest'. Reach to start next game.
Molumby - 6 - Does the hard things well and basics poorly. There were times I was thinking he should be replaced but then his energy and drive really got us going. All in all he did enough to stay on for me, and should start again next game. But he needs to sort him self out in terms of his contribution in possession.
Okay - 9 (MOTM) - Rolls Royce. Still isn't 100% fit, but my god he's class, seemed even better at CB too with the whole pitch ahead of him.
Wallace - 7 - Always looks likely to create, and never stops. Turning into Mr Reliable. Should've scored though, twice. Would have been a ten if he had have done.
Swift - 8 - Anything good we do comes through him. Yes he doesn't dribble past 4 players, or he isn't the best athlete. But he has a bit of class that will help us unlock teams. Need to drop deeper.
Grady - 7 - Always involved but stuff just didn't come off for him. Still our best creative outlet and should be given a. Free role with another attacker replacing one of the DMs.
Grant - 7 - Thought his hold up play was decent, and he just never stops grafting. As always limited but tried his best.
Subs:
Phillips - 6 - Added width, an attacking outlet and a bit of drive. But delivery frustrating given his undoubted crossing ability.
Livermore - 6 - Steady when he came on and broke up the play in deeper areas when we evacuated the midfield somewhat towards the end. Him or Okay can play that role alone between them and be fine.
BTA - 7 - Got his goal, showed pace, aggression, hunger and plenty of confidence. Needs a good week in training picking up patterns of play, but should give us more of a threat from that deep forward role.
Bruce - 9 - Got all the major calls right in game, and made good, effective and ambitious changes which asked questions of Kompany. Much better. But I hope this was just out of desperation. He needs to have the mindset consistently, and my worry is he just doesn't. But fingers crossed.
Fans - 10 - Happy to hear them in fine voice. They are better fans than me no doubtbat all. Fantastic showing by them.
Getting the ball first has minimal relevance as to whether a foul has occurred. There is no reference to making contact with the ball in the section relating to Fouls and Misconduct in the Laws of the Game, but it may be considered by the referee in deciding whether contact was careless, reckless or excessively forceful.
There are six offences in which contact is made with an opponent that cause a direct free kick to be awarded: - kicks an opponent carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force
- trips an opponent carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force
- charges an opponent carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force
- strikes an opponent carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force
- pushes an opponent carelessly, recklessly or with excessive force
- holds an opponent
Button plainly tripped an opponent carelessly so it's a penalty
You are allowed to trip an opponent if the challenge was successful, then it's based on reckless or excessive force, neither of which Buttons challenge were. The challenge by button wasn't 'Careless' it was a textbook 'K' block and his foot won the ball. For me it wasn't a Peno, but it is what it is. They should've had one for Dara's handball, so it was 1-1 in my mind, anyway.
I’m with you lurker on both counts with the penalties.
Posts: 5,322
Threads: 356
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Thought everyone did well tonight.
Work rate and resilience was first rate.
Only criticism is a lack of composure in key moments, and sometimes a lack of conviction, shots and headers can be a tad tentative.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
OK, none of us agree so I'll stick my neck out.
Button 6. Playing on a yellow, not a huge amount to do, distribution was better than of late.
TGH. 6. Really up against it tonight and did OK.
Townsend 6. I'm for resting him but couldn't fault his effort tonight, linked well with GD 1st half, docked a half due to that error.
O Shea 7.5 . Steady, one great interception 2nd half.
Bartley 6. I'm not a fan but credit where due, he got on the end of some set pieces.
Grady 7. A handful all night, even when it didn't go for him he kept them busy.
Molumby 7. Best game yet, what you see is what you get.
Swift 7.5. Another best game yet, some good through balls.
Wallace 7. Mr consistent.
Okay 7.5. This guy is too good for the league.
Grant 6. Kept busy and was always looking for the opening.
Bruce 9. Got a lot right. Jake (did well btw), for Molumby was just to keep the pressure on. I suppose MP for TGH was because he thought he might offer more going forward. Plus Brucey put the goalscorer on when we were all watching Big Ken on the line going through the motions.
The fans 10. After a crushing week really showed why we are proud to be Baggies. The dings would have been holding up the banner again and wanting to spend another zillion. Villa fans would have gone home on 75mins.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(09-03-2022, 09:00 AM)Tom Joad Wrote: Bruce 9. Got a lot right. Jake (did well btw), for Molumby was just to keep the pressure on. I suppose MP for TGH was because he thought he might offer more going forward. Plus Brucey put the goalscorer on when we were all watching Big Ken on the line going through the motions.
The fans 10. After a crushing week really showed why we are proud to be Baggies. The dings would have been holding up the banner again and wanting to spend another zillion. Villa fans would have gone home on 75mins.
Completely agree with both these.
A really great night that made the long drive worth it.
Just a tiny negative.....I like Townsend.....but I thought he was terrible yesterday
|