How much does this board represent the wider fanbase?
#1
Just throwing it out there as I don't think it does much at all here or anywhere online.

In life it's proven the unhappiest moan, whilst the rest most of the time say nothing.

Also I think football is so emotional that many vent through this board.

My guess is based on my own visits to the Hawthorns etc is most people are mildly dissatisfied with the current state on the pitch, but nowhere near wanting Bruce out yet.

Bruce seems a fair distance from the anger that surrounded the last days of some previous incumbents.

I do think though he is close to veering into the choppy 'next one for the sack' waters, but suspect heading into the bottom half and several points off play-offs will only make the trigger be pulled. 

I'd hope a good result v Burnley would help make this place more congenial where we can then discuss power tools, best second hand car purchase etc again.
Reply
#2
How many are calling for Bruce to be sacked on here?

Can't say I've seen much of it, most simply saying the truth, he's doing a poor job, and it needs to improve or he will be sacked.

Twitter us almost totally anti-Bruce, but twitter is a cesspool at the best of times.
Reply
#3
(08-31-2022, 02:14 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: How many are calling for Bruce to be sacked on here?

Can't say I've seen much of it, most simply saying the truth, he's doing a poor job, and it needs to improve or he will be sacked.

Twitter us almost totally anti-Bruce, but twitter is a cesspool at the best of times.

To be fair Birdy I think most social media is the pits. The Albion Facebook feed is full of life's more troublesome characters who seem to get the kick of trolling the club at every opportunity.
Reply
#4
I think this board is more representative than other social media platforms.

I agree with Birdy. I've been called anti-Bruce but I genuinely want him to stay. I just want him to improve.
Reply
#5
The atmosphere at the home games so far has generally been much better than it was for the large majority of last season (obviously helped by good performances against Watford and Hull) which suggests that most of the crowd really want to get behind the team.

It's been an odd start to the season results-wise and cases could be easily made for either sticking with or getting rid of Bruce. He's been given a squad of serial underachievers with little flexibility to move players on due to their contracts and little money to spend. On the other hand, he's not getting best out of the players which he was clearly brought in to do.

I would say that the next 6 games or so will see the general opinion of our fanbase, both on the forums and at the games, sway one way or the other dependent upon whether we start turning draws in wins or drift down the table with turgid performances.

As said above, Twitter is only a representation of the biggest idiots in society in general regardless of the subject matter and should be largely just ignored.
Reply
#6
I think Bruce should go.

Not because I have an “agenda” or any of that childish bollocks. I just don’t think he’s a very good football manager anymore, he’s done a poor job since arriving and I have no confidence that he can deliver a promotion challenge.

And there’s nothing wrong with that viewpoint, doesn’t make me a hater per se, it’s not even as if I’ve been particularly vitriolic.
Reply
#7
(08-31-2022, 02:27 PM)Duffers Wrote: I think Bruce should go.

Not because I have an “agenda” or any of that childish bollocks. I just don’t think he’s a very good football manager anymore, he’s done a poor job since arriving and I have no confidence that he can deliver a promotion challenge.

And there’s nothing wrong with that viewpoint, doesn’t make me a hater per se, it’s not even as if I’ve been particularly vitriolic.

It's fair enough thinking he's useless and he's not given a great deal of reason to be optimistic. I think most want him to succeed as he seems a decent bloke and, most of all, it means things are going well on the pitch.

There can be a point when a football manager who has done good jobs goes way off the boil and should be in the studio on a Saturday teatime, like Souness has, or getting a gig at Bradford etc, like Mark Hughes is now.

Your patience with him has snapped and you may be proven right that he's yesterday's man. I hope you're wrong and I'm sure you hope you are to.
Reply
#8
I think it's a fair reflection, when looked at from a neutral standpoint. Most of my mates just want to see us play well and win games, if we don't then they start questioning.

I would say the vast majority are unhappy with Lai.
A minority are what I would call anti-Bruce and probably have been since he signed, whilst most want him to succeed, but are now starting to question his methods and application.

None, and I mean none, would pick Livermore or Phillips.
All of them believe we need a striker and to improve on Furlong and Townsend

These are blokes that I have been going with and discussing Albion with for 40 odd years, so I respect their opinions. They are not much different to those on here.
Reply
#9
I am totally ambivalent on Bruce.

Just believe this is a very difficult job for any manager.

The danger is there are a fair few managers out there who would do an even worse one.

How confident  are you that we would dodge those managers.
Reply
#10
(08-31-2022, 02:48 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: I am totally ambivalent on Bruce.

Just believe this is a very difficult job for any manager.

The danger is there are a fair few managers out there who would do an even worse one.

How confident  are you that we would dodge those managers.

There are always two big decisions to make - whether to sack and who to replace them with.

Getting the second one wrong doesn’t make the first one wrong.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: