Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(08-30-2022, 05:00 PM)wba13 Wrote: Perhaps at this stage of there careers Thomas - Asante looks the better prospect and at £ 300,000 I’m sure it’s possible to bring him on. Cleary is just a striker I think will score a lot of goals, Asante scores and makes goals and is said to have a great work ethic.
Asante has had 3 full seasons playing mens football being kicked from pillar to post and scored 11 last season in a poor side.
It's an absolute punt. We'll see - that's if he even signs!
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
(08-30-2022, 04:53 PM)Banbury Baggie Wrote: Can someone please explain the difference between paying for and playing Thomas-Asante vs playing Cleary (who is ours)?
B T-A is young, untested, and when tested only scores a few goals (according to some on here). Surely Cleary could come in and score goals with our set up we have now? In relation to Cleary I hear all of the 'loan him out' and other such comments so he gets experience....is B T-A really that more experienced that we are prepared to use him until Dike regains/retails fitness?
Sorry for this view, but it seems like we are cutting off our nose to spite our face here.
I'll have a go for you.
Cleary has just turned 18 and virtually no first team football experience. Played 2 league cup games and struggled a wee bit, needs to go out on loan to play first team football that matters, not kids football, and learn his game. There are very few that don't take this path.
BTA is 23, so not that young, has 100 or so L2 appearances to his name and scored at 1 in 4 to date. That ratio has improved quite a bit in the last year and from the bits we're hearing has more to his game than being a goal scorer, he may well be the Robbo replacement.
I'd say Cleary looks like someone who will score goals, BTA appears to have an all round game and isn't an out and out centre forward. It's certainly not the Dike replacement we're all thinking of.
BTA's first name is actually Solomon, Salomon added too and we'd have done ok attacking wise. Just midfield, centreback, full backs and goalkeeper to sort. I'm aware I'll be disappointed with a list with those expectations but I don't believe Button is the answer. He's the very definition of a mid-table Champ player.
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 10,859
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
(08-30-2022, 05:03 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: (08-30-2022, 04:53 PM)Banbury Baggie Wrote: Can someone please explain the difference between paying for and playing Thomas-Asante vs playing Cleary (who is ours)?
B T-A is young, untested, and when tested only scores a few goals (according to some on here). Surely Cleary could come in and score goals with our set up we have now? In relation to Cleary I hear all of the 'loan him out' and other such comments so he gets experience....is B T-A really that more experienced that we are prepared to use him until Dike regains/retails fitness?
Sorry for this view, but it seems like we are cutting off our nose to spite our face here. I'm with you on this Banbury. Cleary should have had more minutes in the league this season. Every game we haven't won has been crying out for fresh legs and all we get is Phillips or Reach.
This kid is a few years older which is the only difference really. Don't get me wrong, I'm all for looking at the lower leagues and hope we are unearthing a hidden gem, but it's a coin toss basically.
I'm a huge fan of Cleary as everyone knows and I agree he should have been on the bench more and given minutes when surrounded by first team players. Thats my frustration. He's played with fringe players in Carabo and hasn't had the luxury of having proper ammunition alongside him.
I think what people forget though is Cleary has just turned 18. BTA is 23 and has played league football a fair bit over the last few years, and by the looks of it, he is now progressing nicely as a result.
Its a huge step up and Cleary really is raw. I'm surprised Salford didn't ask for him on loan in return. I would have Cleary on the bench all day long but he probably needs to be loaned out if Bruce doesn't fancy him yet. I'd rather that than U23s as he has already proven he can bang them in at that level.
Posts: 4,322
Threads: 139
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
You have to hope we have unearthed the next Jamie Vardy, but it feels like Guarlay has been to cash converters and didn’t get as much as he expected.
Posts: 9,321
Threads: 720
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(08-30-2022, 05:19 PM)CA Baggie Wrote: (08-30-2022, 04:53 PM)Banbury Baggie Wrote: Can someone please explain the difference between paying for and playing Thomas-Asante vs playing Cleary (who is ours)?
B T-A is young, untested, and when tested only scores a few goals (according to some on here). Surely Cleary could come in and score goals with our set up we have now? In relation to Cleary I hear all of the 'loan him out' and other such comments so he gets experience....is B T-A really that more experienced that we are prepared to use him until Dike regains/retails fitness?
Sorry for this view, but it seems like we are cutting off our nose to spite our face here.
I'll have a go for you.
Cleary has just turned 18 and virtually no first team football experience. Played 2 league cup games and struggled a wee bit, needs to go out on loan to play first team football that matters, not kids football, and learn his game. There are very few that don't take this path.
BTA is 23, so not that young, has 100 or so L2 appearances to his name and scored at 1 in 4 to date. That ratio has improved quite a bit in the last year and from the bits we're hearing has more to his game than being a goal scorer, he may well be the Robbo replacement.
I'd say Cleary looks like someone who will score goals, BTA appears to have an all round game and isn't an out and out centre forward. It's certainly not the Dike replacement we're all thinking of.
BTA's first name is actually Solomon, Salomon added too and we'd have done ok attacking wise. Just midfield, centreback, full backs and goalkeeper to sort. I'm aware I'll be disappointed with a list with those expectations but I don't believe Button is the answer. He's the very definition of a mid-table Champ player.
If we get BTA, Cleary will probably go on loan. Salford wouldn't be a bad shout?
We still need a unit up to.
Posts: 612
Threads: 53
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
I would hazard a guess that Robinson is being sold as we will have to pay a fee for Asante and with no Robinson in the squad tonight it looks all the more likely that he will be leaving.
Posts: 13,256
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(08-30-2022, 06:23 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I would hazard a guess that Robinson is being sold as we will have to pay a fee for Asante and with no Robinson in the squad tonight it looks all the more likely that he will be leaving.
If the intention is that we’re replacing Robinson with BTA then that’s a risky strategy.
If it’s a genius plan to bring in BTA plus another 2-3 then I’m all for it
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
Sign BTA, send them Cleary on loan for the year.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
I think most would agree that if we sign BTA then Cleary would definately benefit from a season on loan up there. That is apart from those who believe 18yr old Cleary is the second coming of Cyrille and therefore the answer to our prayers.
Posts: 1,372
Threads: 13
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(08-30-2022, 06:25 PM)Sliced Wrote: (08-30-2022, 06:23 PM)Huggybear Wrote: I would hazard a guess that Robinson is being sold as we will have to pay a fee for Asante and with no Robinson in the squad tonight it looks all the more likely that he will be leaving.
If the intention is that we’re replacing Robinson with BTA then that’s a risky strategy.
If it’s a genius plan to bring in BTA plus another 2-3 then I’m all for it
Agreed. Surely that has to be it. Loaning out Mowatt and moving on Robinson to bring in Asante would make no sense whatsoever
|