Priorities
#11
(07-21-2022, 03:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2022, 12:18 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All that approach will do is encourage people to spend their available funds, sell assets and dispose of cash that they have. There should be a state level of social care available which should reflect the actual cost of care, we already have as position where people have to sell their houses to fund, for example, dementia care and anything other than the basic 'sit them in the corner and feed them three times a day' care that is provided.

Years of austerity has led us to the position of having to pay for it anyway - I think we can call that a failed policy.

It has nothing to do with "years of austerity" and everything to do with longevity (something to celebrate), the dependency ratio and the exceptionally generous tax treatment of retirees.

It's really quite odd that I seem to be the only one on here that doesn't think it's right that the state protects those who've gained the most in wholly unearned wealth.

(07-21-2022, 01:04 PM)Ossian Wrote: I know of many people who are having what should be their retirement years effectively stolen by having to confront responsibilities which no previous generation ever had to consider.

Christ you know a lot of narcissists then. I'd give anything to have to "confront the responsibilities" of looking after my late mother and father, as they looked after their parents.

There's nothing narcissistic about being knackered, in poor health yourself, and with two sets of dependant parents to support on your own because your only sibling lives 5,000 miles away and your spouse has no siblings at all. That's just one example to be going on with; I have others...
Reply
#12
No, that's treating your responsibilities seriously. I only wish I still had those responsibilities.
Reply
#13
(07-21-2022, 03:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So you'd prefer the lowest paid to contribute via taxation to protecting the unearned inheritances on unearned wealth (and fun in retirement) for sons and daughters in the south of England.

I just find that whole concept breathtaking.

I'm just pointing out what would happen in the real world, you can make up as many policies in a bubble as you like, but if they mean there are unintended consequences that would take advantage of tax avoidance already in place then you are being a bit naive.

Much simpler to close off the tax avoidance routes 1st and use those funds to increase tax revenue and fund better services.
Reply
#14
(07-21-2022, 03:47 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 03:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So you'd prefer the lowest paid to contribute via taxation to protecting the unearned inheritances on unearned wealth (and fun in retirement) for sons and daughters in the south of England.

I just find that whole concept breathtaking.

I'm just pointing out what would happen in the real world, you can make up as many policies in a bubble as you like, but if they mean there are unintended consequences that would take advantage of tax avoidance already in place then you are being a bit naive.

Much simpler to close off the tax avoidance routes 1st and use those funds to increase tax revenue and fund better services.

So who pays? The user, or the ever shrinking labour pool on which they're becoming dependent?

This isn't a trick question. It's exactly the same issue that's at the heart of the housing debate.
Reply
#15
(07-21-2022, 03:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 03:47 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 03:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So you'd prefer the lowest paid to contribute via taxation to protecting the unearned inheritances on unearned wealth (and fun in retirement) for sons and daughters in the south of England.

I just find that whole concept breathtaking.

I'm just pointing out what would happen in the real world, you can make up as many policies in a bubble as you like, but if they mean there are unintended consequences that would take advantage of tax avoidance already in place then you are being a bit naive.

Much simpler to close off the tax avoidance routes 1st and use those funds to increase tax revenue and fund better services.

So who pays? The user, or the ever shrinking labour pool on which they're becoming dependent?

This isn't a trick question. It's exactly the same issue that's at the heart of the housing debate.

If we don't start plugging the gaps of housing, social care, health and all other public services soon we will find that it will be untenable to run them for the most in need. We will end up with a two tier system of a) basic social care for all that isn't fit for purpose and b) a tier for those who can pay for it. The private tier will attract all of the good staff because they can afford it and the social group will just sink lower and lower. 13 years of Tory rule, austerity and staffing money in their mates direction has left the country woefully short of where it needs to be, we can continue down your path and end up with no social system to talk of or we can do something now.

You keep focussing on taxing the individual, lets start by taxing the offshore account holders (or making it hard for them to continue saving offshore) and the corporations that make the profits now. Lets see where we are then, short of a Logans run solution or your one generation solution of selling off the only assets the proles actually have now, lets look at longer term solutions.

Your policy would only work for the 1st generation, once that has been stripped away where will the asset growth that will fund your theory come from? People won't have the assets, 50 year mortgages and property prices that price most of our kids mean the majority will never own the assets to draw on in old age.
Reply
#16
(07-21-2022, 04:40 PM)baggy1 Wrote: If we don't start plugging the gaps of housing, social care, health and all other public services soon we will find that it will be untenable to run them for the most in need. We will end up with a two tier system of a) basic social care for all that isn't fit for purpose and b) a tier for those who can pay for it. The private tier will attract all of the good staff because they can afford it and the social group will just sink lower and lower. 13 years of Tory rule, austerity and staffing money in their mates direction has left the country woefully short of where it needs to be, we can continue down your path and end up with no social system to talk of or we can do something now.

You keep focussing on taxing the individual, lets start by taxing the offshore account holders (or making it hard for them to continue saving offshore) and the corporations that make the profits now. Lets see where we are then, short of a Logans run solution or your one generation solution of selling off the only assets the proles actually have now, lets look at longer term solutions.

Your policy would only work for the 1st generation, once that has been stripped away where will the asset growth that will fund your theory come from? People won't have the assets, 50 year mortgages and property prices that price most of our kids mean the majority will never own the assets to draw on in old age.

For someone who joined the Labour party to get rid of Corbyn, you don't half like his policies  Tongue
Reply
#17
(07-21-2022, 03:44 PM)Ossian Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 03:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2022, 12:18 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All that approach will do is encourage people to spend their available funds, sell assets and dispose of cash that they have. There should be a state level of social care available which should reflect the actual cost of care, we already have as position where people have to sell their houses to fund, for example, dementia care and anything other than the basic 'sit them in the corner and feed them three times a day' care that is provided.

Years of austerity has led us to the position of having to pay for it anyway - I think we can call that a failed policy.

It has nothing to do with "years of austerity" and everything to do with longevity (something to celebrate), the dependency ratio and the exceptionally generous tax treatment of retirees.

It's really quite odd that I seem to be the only one on here that doesn't think it's right that the state protects those who've gained the most in wholly unearned wealth.

(07-21-2022, 01:04 PM)Ossian Wrote: I know of many people who are having what should be their retirement years effectively stolen by having to confront responsibilities which no previous generation ever had to consider.

Christ you know a lot of narcissists then. I'd give anything to have to "confront the responsibilities" of looking after my late mother and father, as they looked after their parents.

There's nothing narcissistic about being knackered, in poor health yourself, and with two sets of dependant parents to support on your own because your only sibling lives 5,000 miles away and your spouse has no siblings at all. That's just one example to be going on with; I have others...

Sorry you've had some harsh responses. The Sandwich Generation is a real issue. https://www.bbc.com/worklife/article/202...ressed-out
Reply
#18
(07-21-2022, 04:42 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 04:40 PM)baggy1 Wrote: If we don't start plugging the gaps of housing, social care, health and all other public services soon we will find that it will be untenable to run them for the most in need. We will end up with a two tier system of a) basic social care for all that isn't fit for purpose and b) a tier for those who can pay for it. The private tier will attract all of the good staff because they can afford it and the social group will just sink lower and lower. 13 years of Tory rule, austerity and staffing money in their mates direction has left the country woefully short of where it needs to be, we can continue down your path and end up with no social system to talk of or we can do something now.

You keep focussing on taxing the individual, lets start by taxing the offshore account holders (or making it hard for them to continue saving offshore) and the corporations that make the profits now. Lets see where we are then, short of a Logans run solution or your one generation solution of selling off the only assets the proles actually have now, lets look at longer term solutions.

Your policy would only work for the 1st generation, once that has been stripped away where will the asset growth that will fund your theory come from? People won't have the assets, 50 year mortgages and property prices that price most of our kids mean the majority will never own the assets to draw on in old age.

For someone who joined the Labour party to get rid of Corbyn, you don't half like his policies  Tongue

Big Grin

It was more to do with getting someone electable and Corbyn was too much of an easy target for the lying machine that is in power.
Reply
#19
(07-21-2022, 04:40 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 03:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 03:47 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 03:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So you'd prefer the lowest paid to contribute via taxation to protecting the unearned inheritances on unearned wealth (and fun in retirement) for sons and daughters in the south of England.

I just find that whole concept breathtaking.

I'm just pointing out what would happen in the real world, you can make up as many policies in a bubble as you like, but if they mean there are unintended consequences that would take advantage of tax avoidance already in place then you are being a bit naive.

Much simpler to close off the tax avoidance routes 1st and use those funds to increase tax revenue and fund better services.

So who pays? The user, or the ever shrinking labour pool on which they're becoming dependent?

This isn't a trick question. It's exactly the same issue that's at the heart of the housing debate.

If we don't start plugging the gaps of housing, social care, health and all other public services soon we will find that it will be untenable to run them for the most in need. We will end up with a two tier system of a) basic social care for all that isn't fit for purpose and b) a tier for those who can pay for it. The private tier will attract all of the good staff because they can afford it and the social group will just sink lower and lower. 13 years of Tory rule, austerity and staffing money in their mates direction has left the country woefully short of where it needs to be, we can continue down your path and end up with no social system to talk of or we can do something now.

You keep focussing on taxing the individual, lets start by taxing the offshore account holders (or making it hard for them to continue saving offshore) and the corporations that make the profits now. Lets see where we are then, short of a Logans run solution or your one generation solution of selling off the only assets the proles actually have now, lets look at longer term solutions.

Your policy would only work for the 1st generation, once that has been stripped away where will the asset growth that will fund your theory come from? People won't have the assets, 50 year mortgages and property prices that price most of our kids mean the majority will never own the assets to draw on in old age.

It's not a zero sum game though is it? You don't *just* deal with this issue - you have to deal with the housing issue too.

As an alternative to asset grabs, how about compulsory insurance instead? Or Pensioners paying NI? You can't exempt those who will benefit the most from payment.
Reply
#20
(07-21-2022, 04:40 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 03:53 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 03:47 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(07-21-2022, 03:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So you'd prefer the lowest paid to contribute via taxation to protecting the unearned inheritances on unearned wealth (and fun in retirement) for sons and daughters in the south of England.

I just find that whole concept breathtaking.

I'm just pointing out what would happen in the real world, you can make up as many policies in a bubble as you like, but if they mean there are unintended consequences that would take advantage of tax avoidance already in place then you are being a bit naive.

Much simpler to close off the tax avoidance routes 1st and use those funds to increase tax revenue and fund better services.

So who pays? The user, or the ever shrinking labour pool on which they're becoming dependent?

This isn't a trick question. It's exactly the same issue that's at the heart of the housing debate.

If we don't start plugging the gaps of housing, social care, health and all other public services soon we will find that it will be untenable to run them for the most in need. We will end up with a two tier system of a) basic social care for all that isn't fit for purpose and b) a tier for those who can pay for it. The private tier will attract all of the good staff because they can afford it and the social group will just sink lower and lower. 13 years of Tory rule, austerity and staffing money in their mates direction has left the country woefully short of where it needs to be, we can continue down your path and end up with no social system to talk of or we can do something now.

You keep focussing on taxing the individual, lets start by taxing the offshore account holders (or making it hard for them to continue saving offshore) and the corporations that make the profits now. Lets see where we are then, short of a Logans run solution or your one generation solution of selling off the only assets the proles actually have now, lets look at longer term solutions.

Your policy would only work for the 1st generation, once that has been stripped away where will the asset growth that will fund your theory come from? People won't have the assets, 50 year mortgages and property prices that price most of our kids mean the majority will never own the assets to draw on in old age.

+1
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)