WBAUnofficial
Priorities - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: Politics (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Thread: Priorities (/showthread.php?tid=25810)

Pages: 1 2 3


Priorities - Protheroe - 07-20-2022

I receive a few pelters on here each time I suggest that those with assets contribute more to their own social care in retirement.

If they did, then maybe my County Council, which spends over £250m annually on adult social care wouldn't be placing vulnerable kids in caravans in Lancashire.

We all know the dependency ratio is on the increase. We all know that this longevity is to be celebrated, but those who can afford it must contribute more to their care - or the priorities of the public authorities will remain as fucked up as illustrated here.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-62127523


RE: Priorities - baggy1 - 07-20-2022

Just so as I'm clear on what you're saying, the last 10 years of Austerity have caused a massive shortfall in funding for the local authorities which has resulted in this position. The premise of cutting services was to avoid people paying higher taxes in the 1st place but has resulted in them paying higher costs in the end - would it have not been easier to tax people in the 1st place so as to spread the cost and provide the services when needed. Is this just evidence that austerity has been a complete fuck up?


RE: Priorities - Protheroe - 07-20-2022

What I have said, consistently - is that the older asset rich need to make more direct provision for their care.

I think that is clear from the post.

The exponential growth in the adult social care budget is precisely the reason why cuts have been made elsewhere. I'm not aware that I'm paying less in Council Tax than I was in 2010. Far from it. Hence the title of the thread: Priorities.


RE: Priorities - baggy1 - 07-20-2022

All that approach will do is encourage people to spend their available funds, sell assets and dispose of cash that they have. There should be a state level of social care available which should reflect the actual cost of care, we already have as position where people have to sell their houses to fund, for example, dementia care and anything other than the basic 'sit them in the corner and feed them three times a day' care that is provided.

Years of austerity has led us to the position of having to pay for it anyway - I think we can call that a failed policy.


RE: Priorities - Logic1 - 07-20-2022

(07-20-2022, 12:18 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All that approach will do is encourage people to spend their available funds, sell assets and dispose of cash that they have. There should be a state level of social care available which should reflect the actual cost of care, we already have as position where people have to sell their houses to fund, for example, dementia care and anything other than the basic 'sit them in the corner and feed them three times a day' care that is provided.

Years of austerity has led us to the position of having to pay for it anyway - I think we can call that a failed policy.
This analysis is spot on. I'm trying to think of one single good policy we have had that has improved peoples lives over the last decade.


RE: Priorities - chasetownbaggie - 07-21-2022

(07-20-2022, 12:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote: What I have said, consistently - is that the older asset rich need to make more direct provision for their care.

I think that is clear from the post.

The exponential growth in the adult social care budget is precisely the reason why cuts have been made elsewhere. I'm not aware that I'm paying less in Council Tax than I was in 2010. Far from it. Hence the title of the thread: Priorities.

I agree a proper plan for social care should be prioritised but if you're going to ask asset rich people to pay for their own, where would you place the threshold?

I'm also well aware that currently people with assets over about £28k are obliged to pay (the mother-in-law lost nearly all her life's savings paying for her husband's care until he died).

Another relative spent a week in a private local care home recently at her own expense. I'm told it was £2k for the privilege. People's assets around here aren't going to last long if that is a representative rate.


RE: Priorities - Ossian - 07-21-2022

Longevity is another of those issues, like climate, like degradation of infrastructure, like so many others that we've known about, predicted, and - as is typical - failed to address.

And it goes beyond the financial burden: there is a social cost. If it becomes, if not yet routine, not exactly uncommon for people to live well into their nineties, that will mean that any offspring, should they have them, will likely be already of pensionable age and required to help with care and support. This is already beginning to happen and I know of many people who are having what should be their retirement years effectively stolen by having to confront responsibilities which no previous generation ever had to consider.


RE: Priorities - Protheroe - 07-21-2022

(07-20-2022, 12:18 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All that approach will do is encourage people to spend their available funds, sell assets and dispose of cash that they have. There should be a state level of social care available which should reflect the actual cost of care, we already have as position where people have to sell their houses to fund, for example, dementia care and anything other than the basic 'sit them in the corner and feed them three times a day' care that is provided.

Years of austerity has led us to the position of having to pay for it anyway - I think we can call that a failed policy.

It has nothing to do with "years of austerity" and everything to do with longevity (something to celebrate), the dependency ratio and the exceptionally generous tax treatment of retirees.

It's really quite odd that I seem to be the only one on here that doesn't think it's right that the state protects those who've gained the most in wholly unearned wealth.

(07-21-2022, 01:04 PM)Ossian Wrote: I know of many people who are having what should be their retirement years effectively stolen by having to confront responsibilities which no previous generation ever had to consider.

Christ you know a lot of narcissists then. I'd give anything to have to "confront the responsibilities" of looking after my late mother and father, as they looked after their parents.


RE: Priorities - baggy1 - 07-21-2022

(07-21-2022, 03:29 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-20-2022, 12:18 PM)baggy1 Wrote: All that approach will do is encourage people to spend their available funds, sell assets and dispose of cash that they have. There should be a state level of social care available which should reflect the actual cost of care, we already have as position where people have to sell their houses to fund, for example, dementia care and anything other than the basic 'sit them in the corner and feed them three times a day' care that is provided.

Years of austerity has led us to the position of having to pay for it anyway - I think we can call that a failed policy.

It has nothing to do with "years of austerity" and everything to do with longevity (something to celebrate), the dependency ratio and the exceptionally generous tax treatment of retirees.

It's really quite odd that I seem to be the only one on here that doesn't think it's right that the state protects those who've gained the most in wholly unearned wealth.

You keep banging on about it, we know. I'm just pointing out the real world scenario where people would just move their assets (as the rich have done for years) into trusts or offshore accounts.

And it has lots to do with years of austerity, we've stripped the provision back to the bones and now are looking for people to pay at source rather than during their lifetime of working. Direct taxation on the needy - a good Tory policy.


RE: Priorities - Protheroe - 07-21-2022

So you'd prefer the lowest paid to contribute via taxation to protecting the unearned inheritances on unearned wealth (and fun in retirement) for sons and daughters in the south of England.

I just find that whole concept breathtaking.