O’shea
#31
Hardee Dean and Marc Roberts are ace. Take them both
Reply
#32
(07-13-2022, 05:56 PM)KRO Wrote: Hardee Dean and Marc Roberts are ace. Take them both

What's that big lump Gallagher at the back doing these days  Big Grin
Reply
#33
(07-13-2022, 06:17 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(07-13-2022, 05:56 PM)KRO Wrote: Hardee Dean and Marc Roberts are ace. Take them both

What's that big lump Gallagher at the back doing these days  Big Grin

I see Ivan Šunjić has gone to Hertha Berlin on loan. A shame as he looked a tidy player.
Reply
#34
(07-13-2022, 10:31 PM)Squid Wrote:
(07-13-2022, 06:17 PM)Woodman scoreboard Wrote:
(07-13-2022, 05:56 PM)KRO Wrote: Hardee Dean and Marc Roberts are ace. Take them both

What's that big lump Gallagher at the back doing these days  Big Grin

I see Ivan Šunjić has gone to Hertha Berlin on loan. A shame as he looked a tidy player.

We'll find out a week on Sat.
Reply
#35
I find some of the posts on this thread a bit depressing. It's become the fashion to diss Dara O'Shea for some reason. He was a huge success story until he got injured, now he's just a disposable asset.

What if he's the next Craig Dawson? Will we wake up one day and find he's finished in the top eight of the Premier League while we've finished outside the Championship play-offs? Where would we be if Tony Brown, Bobby Hope, Len Canteĺlo or Ally Robertson had been sold off at age 23? And does anyone really think that Matt Clarke is a better player than Dara?

It's a Black Country thing to under-value our own. No-one likes the blind adulation that fans of some clubs heap upon their players, but we Baggies struggle to appreciate what we've got. So Matt Clarke was our best defender after one game. Branislav Ivanovic was our best header of the ball before he even played for us. Okay Yokuslu is our best midfielder on the basis of 11 games in a failed relegation battle 2 years ago. Daryl Dike is our best goalscorer until around the sixth game of his non-scoring run in the league.

Come on guys, we've seen Dara play, we know he's talented and versatile. He should play 400 games for the Albion, with most of them in the Premier League. Sell him to buy the elderly Yokuslu, the ordinary Clarke or the obviously dysfunctional Choudary? No feckin' way!!
Reply
#36
(07-13-2022, 11:57 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I find some of the posts on this thread a bit depressing. It's become the fashion to diss Dara O'Shea for some reason. He was a huge success story until he got injured, now he's just a disposable asset.

What if he's the next Craig Dawson? Will we wake up one day and find he's finished in the top eight of the Premier League while we've finished outside the Championship play-offs? Where would we be if Tony Brown, Bobby Hope, Len Canteĺlo or Ally Robertson had been sold off at age 23? And does anyone really think that Matt Clarke is a better player than Dara?

It's a Black Country thing to under-value our own. No-one likes the blind adulation that fans of some clubs heap upon their players, but we Baggies struggle to appreciate what we've got. So Matt Clarke was our best defender after one game. Branislav Ivanovic was our best header of the ball before he even played for us. Okay Yokuslu is our best midfielder on the basis of 11 games in a failed relegation battle 2 years ago. Daryl Dike is our best goalscorer until around the sixth game of his non-scoring run in the league.

Come on guys, we've seen Dara play, we know he's talented and versatile. He should play 400 games for the Albion, with most of them in the Premier League. Sell him to buy the elderly Yokuslu, the ordinary Clarke or the obviously dysfunctional Choudary? No feckin' way!!
With respect, you are missing the point - in my humble opinion.

Burnley have 3 years of parachutes. They may be able to offer him a better contract than us because of this.

If that's the case he should take it, and we should cash in. Should we invest that cash in Okay and a year "shit or bust' run at promotion? Different argument.
Reply
#37
(07-13-2022, 11:57 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I find some of the posts on this thread a bit depressing. It's become the fashion to diss Dara O'Shea for some reason. He was a huge success story until he got injured, now he's just a disposable asset.

What if he's the next Craig Dawson? Will we wake up one day and find he's finished in the top eight of the Premier League while we've finished outside the Championship play-offs? Where would we be if Tony Brown, Bobby Hope, Len Canteĺlo or Ally Robertson had been sold off at age 23? And does anyone really think that Matt Clarke is a better player than Dara?

It's a Black Country thing to under-value our own. No-one likes the blind adulation that fans of some clubs heap upon their players, but we Baggies struggle to appreciate what we've got. So Matt Clarke was our best defender after one game. Branislav Ivanovic was our best header of the ball before he even played for us. Okay Yokuslu is our best midfielder on the basis of 11 games in a failed relegation battle 2 years ago. Daryl Dike is our best goalscorer until around the sixth game of his non-scoring run in the league.

Come on guys, we've seen Dara play, we know he's talented and versatile. He should play 400 games for the Albion, with most of them in the Premier League. Sell him to buy the elderly Yokuslu, the ordinary Clarke or the obviously dysfunctional Choudary? No feckin' way!!

He's been offered a new contract and won't sign it. We've been down this road before. If he won't sign a new contract then we need to get some money for him now, while we can.
Reply
#38
(07-14-2022, 01:15 AM)Squid Wrote:
(07-13-2022, 11:57 PM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote: I find some of the posts on this thread a bit depressing. It's become the fashion to diss Dara O'Shea for some reason. He was a huge success story until he got injured, now he's just a disposable asset.

What if he's the next Craig Dawson? Will we wake up one day and find he's finished in the top eight of the Premier League while we've finished outside the Championship play-offs? Where would we be if Tony Brown, Bobby Hope, Len Canteĺlo or Ally Robertson had been sold off at age 23? And does anyone really think that Matt Clarke is a better player than Dara?

It's a Black Country thing to under-value our own. No-one likes the blind adulation that fans of some clubs heap upon their players, but we Baggies struggle to appreciate what we've got. So Matt Clarke was our best defender after one game. Branislav Ivanovic was our best header of the ball before he even played for us. Okay Yokuslu is our best midfielder on the basis of 11 games in a failed relegation battle 2 years ago. Daryl Dike is our best goalscorer until around the sixth game of his non-scoring run in the league.

Come on guys, we've seen Dara play, we know he's talented and versatile. He should play 400 games for the Albion, with most of them in the Premier League. Sell him to buy the elderly Yokuslu, the ordinary Clarke or the obviously dysfunctional Choudary? No feckin' way!!

He's been offered a new contract and won't sign it. We've been down this road before. If he won't sign a new contract then we need to get some money for him now, while we can.

While he declines the offer of a new contract, it becomes a business decision. We are definitely going to lose him. It's a question of do we lose him now for £5M or next season for nothing. The heart And football reasons sadly don't count for much these days.
Basically we can lose Dara to cover the cost of Lai propping up one of his companies within his empire.
Reply
#39
(07-13-2022, 02:53 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote:
(07-13-2022, 02:51 PM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(07-13-2022, 02:49 PM)albion_pigeon Wrote: We'd be mad to let him go.
Great player who can cover multiple positions?

But if he won't sign, we have another SJ situation next summer.

I'm all for keeping our best players. I'm sure if we can make a deal with him we will 

This calling for our best players to be sold is utter bollocks.

He has to agree to the contract and we have to be able to afford his demands. If either side won’t / can’t / don’t want to then the only sensible thing to do is sell the player.
Reply
#40
While we're picking up free agents like Wallace and Swift due to them running their contracts down we can't get too upset if our players want to operate in the same way. If somebody wants to pay a fee for him we should accept it. It's a business decision if he won't sign a new contract.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: