Optimism
#1
As someone who has never had time for Johnson and always sensed that a man sacked twice for lying would eventually be undone by his web of lies, I'm overjoyed by his demise.

Joy aside though, I can't help but feel some optimism for the future. I know some people will be thinking "bring on the next c***" but, for me, this past 3 years (arguably 6 years if we go back to the Brexit referendum) has represented the absolute nadir of our politics. Tribalism, lying charlatans, distrust, corruption. It really has been a period unparalleled in British history, IMO.

We may well be teetering on the edge of a recession, but am I the only person thinking things can't get any worse and the only way is up?
Reply
#2
(07-10-2022, 10:49 AM)chasetownbaggie Wrote: As someone who has never had time for Johnson and always sensed that a man sacked twice for lying would eventually be undone by his web of lies, I'm overjoyed by his demise.

Joy aside though, I can't help but feel some optimism for the future. I know some people will be thinking "bring on the next c***" but, for me, this past 3 years (arguably 6 years if we go back to the Brexit referendum) has represented the absolute nadir of our politics. Tribalism, lying charlatans, distrust, corruption. It really has been a period unparalleled in British history, IMO.

We may well be teetering on the edge of a recession, but am I the only person thinking things can't get any worse and the only way is up?

I think things will get worse, don’t fall for the trick that by getting a new leader this current Conservative party has changed. It will still be on the side of shareholders and large business and their owners, it will still obey the will of the right wing press barons and it will still try and use populist tactics and blame anyone but itself right up and through the next election.
Reply
#3
(07-10-2022, 11:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:  It will still be on the side of shareholders and large business and their owners

The Tory party has demonstrably not been on the side of shareholders of and large businesses and their owners over the last few years:

Corporation Tax Up
Dividend Tax Up
Employer NI Up
Zero Reform of Business Rates
Zero assistance to energy intensive businesses

I do wonder what planet you actually inhabit.
Reply
#4
Sadly, the increase in energy prices in October, will hit a lot of people very hard.

So no I don't see any reason for short term optimism.
Reply
#5
(07-10-2022, 12:06 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: Sadly, the increase in energy prices in October, will hit a lot of people very hard.

So no I don't see any reason for short term optimism.

+1
Reply
#6
(07-10-2022, 12:00 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-10-2022, 11:25 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:  It will still be on the side of shareholders and large business and their owners

The Tory party has demonstrably not been on the side of shareholders of and large businesses and their owners over the last few years:

Corporation Tax Up
Dividend Tax Up
Employer NI Up
Zero Reform of Business Rates
Zero assistance to energy intensive businesses

I do wonder what planet you actually inhabit.

Ignores record profits of fuel, water, online retailers (until recently). 
Ignores the richest people getting disproportionately richer than anyone else 
Ignores bankers bonuses getting closer to if not past previous bonuses and wages and government rumoured to be look at lessening restrictions on them
Ignores the billionaire owners of the numerous right wing press outlets who no longer live here, pay little tax here but think they should decide who, what and how the country is run

With regards to the above, you campaigned for a party that said it would level up the country and get Brexit done. The first can’t happen without state funded support and the latter has cost us billions. Own the mess you helped create.
Reply
#7
So not shareholders (we all are), not large businesses (but a few maybe) and possibly some of their owners. That's why it's not good to make blanket statements.

Energy companies making large profits in an inflationary market is hardly their fault. Did you shed tears for them when oil was briefly worthless early in the pandemic? Do you shed tears for the miners in the inevitable busts that follow every boom? If you tax online goods more, then who do think pays for that - clue it's not the online retailers! I admit you have a point on the water cos.

Yes, the asset rich have got disproportionately richer - precisely due to low interest rates. I've never heard you call for higher interest rates.

Yawn. The Bankers. If asset price inflation means bankers make a lot of money then what's the problem? When asset prices fall they won't make so much money and you can be happy again that other people are slightly less rich than they might otherwise have been.

If you have problem with media owners, don't forget The Guardians perfectly legal massive avoidance when selling Auto Trader to evil private equity. What's sauce for the goose etc.

The only businesses that have really benefitted in 14 years are those who shouldn't be in business at all. Hopefully interest rate rises and a good old fashioned recession will see the back of them.

Perhaps one of the runners and riders might sort out the mess our economy is in. Though I doubt you'd support any of the prescriptions. Let's be honest, anyone with a pension or equity in a home who's also squealing like a bitch about this government, or the last one or the one before that or the one before that doesn't know they're born. I'm wondering if any of the riders for the Tory leadership are going to argue properly for less tax and a smaller state - Kemi has got close this weekend....
Reply
#8
(07-10-2022, 06:24 PM)Protheroe Wrote: So not shareholders (we all are), not large businesses (but a few maybe) and possibly some of their owners. That's why it's not good to make blanket statements.

Energy companies making large profits in an inflationary market is hardly their fault. Did you shed tears for them when oil was briefly worthless early in the pandemic? Do you shed tears for the miners in the inevitable busts that follow every boom? If you tax online goods more, then who do think pays for that - clue it's not the online retailers! I admit you have a point on the water cos.

Yes, the asset rich have got disproportionately richer - precisely due to low interest rates. I've never heard you call for higher interest rates.

Yawn. The Bankers. If asset price inflation means bankers make a lot of money then what's the problem? When asset prices fall they won't make so much money and you can be happy again that other people are slightly less rich than they might otherwise have been.

If you have problem with media owners, don't forget The Guardians perfectly legal massive avoidance when selling Auto Trader to evil private equity. What's sauce for the goose etc.

The only businesses that have really benefitted in 14 years are those who shouldn't be in business at all. Hopefully interest rate rises and a good old fashioned recession will see the back of them.

Perhaps one of the runners and riders might sort out the mess our economy is in. Though I doubt you'd support any of the prescriptions. Let's be honest, anyone with a pension or equity in a home who's also squealing like a bitch about this government, or the last one or the one before that or the one before that doesn't know they're born. I'm wondering if any of the riders for the Tory leadership are going to argue properly for less tax and a smaller state - Kemi has got close this weekend....

You say yawn and yet the only solution you ever come up with is less tax, small state. It’s not a solution it’s a religious mantra and falls apart when reality confronts it.
Reply
#9
Less tax and a smaller state while bringing in competencies from the EU that the state need to run, increased red tape that needs to be costed for and an increased defence budget and state pension.

Can someone run the maths because that doesn't add up for me. Fed up with this populist nonsense, only Tugendhat and Sunak gave been remotely honest about spending needs, every other candidate is full of shit.
Reply
#10
On the contrary BB & Dekka. Less tax smaller state is what we ought to be aiming for long term, however more tax / smaller state / higher interest rates = recession is the short term prescription we need (and will probably get despite the protestations of Oceans 11). All Tug & Rishi promise is yet more of the same - you can only kick the can so far down the road.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)