Johnson v Corbyn
#1
Seems to be a lot of debate as to who would have been the biggest disaster as PM, we will never know and it's not the point of the thread.

My opinion is that it is a false argument, Corby was never going to be able to wield power in the way Johnson did. For 2 reasons.

1 it was highly improbable that Labour were ever going to win an outright majority at the 2019 GE. The best Labour could hope for was to be the biggest party in Parliament. And govern with the support of other parties.
They would have acted as a break on Corbyn, they may have even only supported a Labour led government on the basis that Corbyn was not the Prime minister. There was a lot of Labour MPs who would have been only too happy to agree to that.
Which brings me to the second reason.
2 Corbyn had less control over Labour than Johnson did over the Conservatives. Johnson was far more ruthless in getting rid of internal critics.Even people like Philip Hammond, no tory wet by any means, was removed as a threat to Johnson. Corbyn didn't succeed,  to be fair never really tried, to get rid of his internal party critics, people such as Yvette Cooper. 
In the unlikely event Labour had won a majority in 2019, Corbyn could only govern with the consent of his own MPs, the majority of whom were not on the same page as he was.
Reply
#2
Before this thread descends into the inevitable shitfest that these things always do it needs saying that when you compare the two men, what they stand for and what they have done in their political careers I simply don't understand how it's even a close run thing.

There are a good few on Labour benches who need to take a long look at themselves as they are complicit in this Govt receiving the mandate it did with their proven undermining. The opposition at present are a joke.
Reply
#3
(07-07-2022, 09:33 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Before this thread descends into the inevitable shitfest that these things always do it needs saying that when you compare the two men, what they stand for and what they have done in their political careers I simply don't understand how it's even a close run thing.

There are a good few on Labour benches who need to take a long look at themselves as they are complicit in this Govt receiving the mandate it did with their proven undermining. The opposition at present are a joke.

And this is the crux of the problem, this government are in no way shape or form fit for purpose and unfortunately the opposition are barely that and don't inspire much confidence either and have not done so for years ,hence the clusterfuck we are now in. Politics in this country is broken, how we fix it god only knows.
Reply
#4
(07-07-2022, 01:48 PM)TETLEY74 Wrote: Politics in this country is broken, how we fix it god only knows.

It can't be fixed until we ditch FPTP in favour of something as close to proportional as is feasible. The last proposal (AV) would have been nowhere near the solution.
Reply
#5
(07-07-2022, 09:29 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: My opinion is that it is a false argument

You're right, it is. But as I posted on another thread:

The only other realistic option was a weapons-grade anti semitic lunatic propped up by the Nats who'd have demanded a secession referendum in return for propping him up. Public debt would be even worse than it is now, inflation would be even worse than it is now, the flight of capital would only have been stemmed by exchange controls that even McDonnell admitted would be necessary. I dread to think how the fringe antivax movement would have influenced Corbyn as PM, and I can only imagine him calling for restraint "on all sides" in Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
Reply
#6
(07-07-2022, 05:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-07-2022, 09:29 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: My opinion is that it is a false argument

You're right, it is. But as I posted on another thread:

The only other realistic option was a weapons-grade anti semitic lunatic propped up by the Nats who'd have demanded a secession referendum in return for propping him up. Public debt would be even worse than it is now, inflation would be even worse than it is now, the flight of capital would only have been stemmed by exchange controls that even McDonnell admitted would be necessary. I dread to think how the fringe antivax movement would have influenced Corbyn as PM, and I can only imagine him calling for restraint "on all sides" in Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

But that's my point , what you describe above,wasn't the realistic option.

As this week has demonstrated, we vote for parliament, and it is parliament that selects the Prime minister.

The electorate do know in advance who are the likely candidates to be Prime minister and that may well be a factor in how they vote.

But ultimately parliament has to have confidence in the prime minister,  and they can and will remove a Prime minister without reference to the electorate.

It is possible that Corbyn could have become Prime minister in 2019, but even he would have acted in a way that parliament would support.
Reply
#7
(07-08-2022, 12:58 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It is possible that Corbyn could have become Prime minister in 2019, but even he would have acted in a way that parliament would support.

Thankfully enough people who consider this to be the remotest of remote possibilities came out and voted for another party.

Corbyn couldn't even carry his own party, let alone Parliament.
Reply
#8
(07-08-2022, 04:12 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-08-2022, 12:58 PM)Shabby Russian Wrote: It is possible that Corbyn could have become Prime minister in 2019, but even he would have acted in a way that parliament would support.

Thankfully enough people who consider this to be the remotest of remote possibilities came out and voted for another party.

Corbyn couldn't even carry his own party, let alone Parliament.
Is that you trying to justify blowjob Johnson's tenure?
Reply
#9
I don’t know why I bother. Derek responds to my posts before I’ve even written them. Most of the rest of you just don’t read them.
Reply
#10
(07-07-2022, 05:20 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(07-07-2022, 09:29 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: My opinion is that it is a false argument

You're right, it is. But as I posted on another thread:

The only other realistic option was a weapons-grade anti semitic lunatic propped up by the Nats who'd have demanded a secession referendum in return for propping him up. Public debt would be even worse than it is now, inflation would be even worse than it is now, the flight of capital would only have been stemmed by exchange controls that even McDonnell admitted would be necessary. I dread to think how the fringe antivax movement would have influenced Corbyn as PM, and I can only imagine him calling for restraint "on all sides" in Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Corbyn isn't an anti-Semite, he's anti-Zionist. There's a difference. That said, he didn't handle the anti-Semitism claims in his party very well at all and was part of the reason I didn't vote Labour in 2019.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: