How do we, and when do we (political)
#71
Blair was my biggest disappointment ever.

Started with such promise and hope.

Turns out he was a liar in a way that makes even Boris Johnson look like a saint.
Reply
#72
(06-07-2022, 03:10 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 02:41 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 12:11 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: FAO Kratos . First, Starmer was not at a party, 2nd, the plod decided it wasn't worth investigating originally. They were forced into the investigation by tories trying to muddy the waters. (Which has succeeded). Third, Starmer has said he will resign should he penalised for it. It doesn't compare on any level.
Further (whoever mentioned Brexit). The referendum was a means thought up by Cameron to retain power. By agreeing to the referendum he stopped UKIP taking tory votes. Labour did not read that room and it cost them. When selecting candidates for the worst ever PM, Cameron is a very strong contender.

Fair post. I assume the photo of him drinking beers and having a takeaway with colleagues was a photoshop job, then! 

It breached rules and government advice at the time. But we know ALL politicians are above their own rules. 

As per my post, both Johnson and Starmer are as bad as each other. Lying, hypocritical, posh boys that don't have the best interests of the public at heart!

Has there ever been a popular PM?

Again, try not to believe everything you read or are told, check it out for yourself. At the time there was an exemption if "the gathering is reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election".

Now, was it reasonable to get together to discuss the days campaigning and give the local feedback to the party leader - possibly / possibly not, but it definitely was within the rules and government advice because of the word 'reasonably'.

What it also definitely was not was a leaving party for a colleague (against the rules and government advice), a celebration of getting rid of a co-worker with drinks and karaoke (against the rules and government advice), or a weekly get together (wine Friday) to let off steam because it has been stressful (the NHS would have had to open bars if that were the case).

So try to understand what you say and not just be taken in by the media.

I don't believe any political meeting was reasonable, especially with the Zoom culture. But that's personal opinion, I guess. I can see why people would prefer face-to-face meetings, but the government should be leading by example. 'Don't go into the office, look, we're not. We're conducting our business via Zoom meeting, so can you' kind of thing. 

As for information. I get my info from the BBC, I should know better than to trust that lot. So maybe that's on me!

(06-07-2022, 03:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 02:50 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 02:41 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote: Has there ever been a popular PM?

I don't think Churchill was super popular, but probably the closest ever? Although I liked early years Blair.

Churchill was loathed by many in his own Party, and particularly the protectionist / peacenik idiot Neville Chamberlain. He was exactly what Britain needed during the war, despite several monumental fuck ups like abandoning highly successful North African Latino-bashing for a futile adventure in Greece in 1941 ("optics" mattered even then). He was unceremoniously booted by the war-weary electorate in 1945. 

Blair was genuinely popular. Election Night 1997 was a genuinely historical moment. Labour could've used its power for fundamental reform (particularly of the NHS), but ultimately reverted to ©onservatism not long into its second term.

These two scenarios sum politics up in a good way. 

People get bored of the same old, vote someone new in, nothing changes. People get bored/fed up and even angry, vote someone new in. Rinse and repeat.

Eventually Labour will get into power, sooner rather than later, because of the shit show Tories have been. But Labour won't be any different, they'll be as much of a shit show. The country will get fed up, and eventually vote in Tories. 

It's a merry go round, but nothing ever changes, does it? Not really.
Clarnet v2.0
Reply
#73
(06-07-2022, 03:17 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 03:10 PM)baggy1 Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 02:41 PM)KratosBaggie Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 12:11 PM)Tom Joad Wrote: FAO Kratos . First, Starmer was not at a party, 2nd, the plod decided it wasn't worth investigating originally. They were forced into the investigation by tories trying to muddy the waters. (Which has succeeded). Third, Starmer has said he will resign should he penalised for it. It doesn't compare on any level.
Further (whoever mentioned Brexit). The referendum was a means thought up by Cameron to retain power. By agreeing to the referendum he stopped UKIP taking tory votes. Labour did not read that room and it cost them. When selecting candidates for the worst ever PM, Cameron is a very strong contender.

Fair post. I assume the photo of him drinking beers and having a takeaway with colleagues was a photoshop job, then! 

It breached rules and government advice at the time. But we know ALL politicians are above their own rules. 

As per my post, both Johnson and Starmer are as bad as each other. Lying, hypocritical, posh boys that don't have the best interests of the public at heart!

Again, try not to believe everything you read or are told, check it out for yourself. At the time there was an exemption if "the gathering is reasonably necessary for the purposes of campaigning in an election".

Now, was it reasonable to get together to discuss the days campaigning and give the local feedback to the party leader - possibly / possibly not, but it definitely was within the rules and government advice because of the word 'reasonably'.

What it also definitely was not was a leaving party for a colleague (against the rules and government advice), a celebration of getting rid of a co-worker with drinks and karaoke (against the rules and government advice), or a weekly get together (wine Friday) to let off steam because it has been stressful (the NHS would have had to open bars if that were the case).

So try to understand what you say and not just be taken in by the media.

I don't believe any political meeting was reasonable, especially with the Zoom culture. But that's personal opinion, I guess. I can see why people would prefer face-to-face meetings, but the government should be leading by example. 'Don't go into the office, look, we're not. We're conducting our business via Zoom meeting, so can you' kind of thing. 

As for information. I get my info from the BBC, I should know better than to trust that lot. So maybe that's on me!

And again you are getting confused - the law isn't what you deem as reasonable, it is what the courts (or the police in bringing it to court) deem as reasonable. Reasonable is such a vague word it can be interpreted / misinterpreted as the individual likes. They were campaigning at the time - try doing door to door campaigning via zoom - and this was the wrap up for when everyone has finished. It was within the rules whether you like it or not I'm afraid.

And ultimately that wasn't the issue for either Starmer or Johnson, the issue was lying to parliament about it which is misleading parliament and therefore (before Johnson came along) a resignable matter.

And this was from the BBC links - go to the BBC, type in Starmer and Beer and check the facts they present.

And one final point, if you think Starmer is posh you really need to do some research. Compare his family background and career to Johnsons - you might see a subtle difference.
Reply
#74
The reality is that things do change and drastically - I've seen that in my lifetime. You just can't compare the politics now to those when I was a boy (and no, this isn't a trans debate). The problem is that it happens in small degrees that often escape notice at the time.

I could list countless 'small' decisions that turned out to be the shape of things to come. If I was going to start BJ bashing I would point to trying to change the ethical standards system as a perfect example.

As an aside, I watched GB News last night for the first time to get an alternative viewpoint. It was awful and wrong on so many levels. Having said that, the reason why I did it was because I was watching the BBCNews. Am I only the left leaning viewer of the BBC that feels it's biased against the Government? Admittedly, it must be difficult when there so many areas of the Government you can poke at...but even so.

Fuzzbox's viewing recommendation is Bloomberg Analysis or, if you're feeling you want an overview, amazingly I'd go for SkyNews.

But I should come clean, I find Lord Rees Mogg hugely watchable. He's like a cross between Darth Vader and Walter the Softy. He's compulsive viewing. If they tell me he's coming on next I'm on tenterhooks.
Reply
#75
(06-07-2022, 03:14 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: Blair was my biggest disappointment ever.

Started with such promise and hope.

Turns out he was a liar in a way that makes even Boris Johnson look like a saint.

I think Blair was more a victim of the messiah complex he cultivated following the second landslide than by any innate predisposition to lie. He was warned by sources on both sides of the Atlantic that Bush was in the clutches of Cheney, Rumsfeld and others of similar inclination, but persisted with the idea that he could moderate Bush's instincts when the opportunity presented itself. Blair genuinely believed that nobody was immune to his charms and - given the right words, at the right time * - he could persuade just about anybody of just about anything. It was obviously a delusion as history has shown.

Jack Straw, who was surprisingly well regarded by senior officials in the Bush administration, was asked to act as a conduit and persuade Blair to accept the inevitable. He never could; Blair was too infatuated with his own charm and powers of persuasion and the outcome is etched into history. Pity, because he was a brilliant political analyst (still is!), knew exactly what was needed to win and - all too briefly - allowed me to live in a country where Social Democracy had returned from the brink of extinction. 

* Shamelessly borrowed from Tracy Chapman
Reply
#76
(06-07-2022, 03:57 PM)Ossian Wrote:
(06-07-2022, 03:14 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: Blair was my biggest disappointment ever.

Started with such promise and hope.

Turns out he was a liar in a way that makes even Boris Johnson look like a saint.

I think Blair was more a victim of the messiah complex he cultivated following the second landslide than by any innate predisposition to lie. He was warned by sources on both sides of the Atlantic that Bush was in the clutches of Cheney, Rumsfeld and others of similar inclination, but persisted with the idea that he could moderate Bush's instincts when the opportunity presented itself. Blair genuinely believed that nobody was immune to his charms and - given the right words, at the right time * - he could persuade just about anybody of just about anything. It was obviously a delusion as history has shown.

Jack Straw, who was surprisingly well regarded by senior officials in the Bush administration, was asked to act as a conduit and persuade Blair to accept the inevitable. He never could; Blair was too infatuated with his own charm and powers of persuasion and the outcome is etched into history. Pity, because he was a brilliant political analyst (still is!), knew exactly what was needed to win and - all too briefly - allowed me to live in a country where Social Democracy had returned from the brink of extinction. 

* Shamelessly borrowed from Tracy Chapman

I think you're absolutely right. However, you can't get away from the fact he chose to release a questionable dossier which launched a war. I've tried to rationalise it away - he was under pressure, he didn't know, it was for the greater good etc. - but I just can't.

Chapman - Is it the one that starts with 'I'm sorry?' and 'Forgive me' . Very subtle Mr Ossian....
Reply
#77
Yes, Baby can I hold you; that's the song title by the way, not a proposition.

The duet with Pavarotti is a thing of beauty.
Reply
#78
(06-07-2022, 03:43 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: Am I only the left leaning viewer of the BBC that feels it's biased against the Government?

It's not necessarily the bias, it's often the crass and inane questions. I have no idea who it was interviewing Dominic Raab on BBC Breakfast this morning, but she came across as so fuckwitted it was actually painful to watch. I'd love BBC TV to be far more constructively critical of government policy - like the awful awful housing policy which I fear is about to get even worse, or the handing out of £400 to every man and his dog who don't need it whilst ignoring the very real pain caused by inflation on the few. 

But, no. Let's ask stupid questions about fluff, optics and personalities. Still at least there's Radio 4 eh?

(06-07-2022, 04:09 PM)Ossian Wrote: Yes, Baby can I hold you; that's the song title by the way, not a proposition.

The duet with Pavarotti is a thing of beauty.

Sanchez did it better
Reply
#79
(06-07-2022, 04:09 PM)Ossian Wrote: Yes, Baby can I hold you; that's the song title by the way, not a proposition.

The duet with Pavarotti is a thing of beauty.

That was a nice surprise - I didn't realise that on the same video/album/concert there was the Pavarotti duet with Skunk Anansie - follow me down. I always wondered where it was lifted from.
Reply
#80
(06-07-2022, 04:02 PM)fuzzbox Wrote: I think you're absolutely right. However, you can't get away from the fact he chose to release a questionable dossier which launched a war. I've tried to rationalise it away - he was under pressure, he didn't know, it was for the greater good etc. - but I just can't.

Chapman - Is it the one that starts with 'I'm sorry?' and 'Forgive me' . Very subtle Mr Ossian....

The dodgy dossier wasn't behind the decision to launch a war, it was a public-facing PR fluff piece to deflect difficult questions to instead of facing any level of accountability.

We were going to war regardless as we were blindly following US policy to appease the US authorities.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)