Targeted Help With Cost Of Living
#11
Just for clarity, it wasn't energy companies I had in mind when I was referring to the laxity of our collection régime when it comes to certain sectors.

Edit: And maybe a transaction tax at the point of sale is the better solution for those I did have in mind.
Reply
#12
(05-24-2022, 03:38 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: They aren't investing, they actively do not want to invest with or without a windfall tax. That is the problem, normally I'd point to tax on business being a deterrent to investment as well but that just simply isn't happening here and hasn't happened for years despite consistent profits.

A windfall tax simply isn't going to deter any investment (the people in the O+G industry are literally spelling that bit out), it doesn't introduce any level of uncertainty due to it being a realignment of the market, it doesn't affect debt servicing, what is the argument against it exactly?

Investment hasn't happened for years because oil prices (excepting fleeting spikes) have largely been becalmed sub $70 / barrel for the best end of 40 years - and there's been no shortage - as your video shows.

Just at the point (actually beyond the point) you need them to invest you'd rather tax them. It doesn't make any sense.

EDIT: Oh, and it'll raise fuck all as well if you follow Labour's plans. It's just optics. Again.
Reply
#13
Investment hasn't happened in years because the big oil and gas companies are deterred to extract more oil and gas and don't actively want to diversify into green technologies because they face competition from disruptive technologies they're worried they won't compete with. It has fuck all to do with the price of oil and gas, BP have made a profit in all but one quarter over the last decade (invested fuck all of that profit over the last 10 years) and that was caused by market dumping in Q2 2020. You're not going to get them to invest into black projects because there is zero profit incentive to do so, and they're too scared to invest in green projects and - let's be honest here - they wouldn't be investing in them unless they were strongarmed into doing so.

Tax breaks aren't going to do shit because tax rates are not the bottleneck on investment, that's why the Chief Executive of BP said that a windfall tax wouldn't affect investment strategy. That's why I keep saying that deterrence to investment is a red herring. Even the government have given up on that bullshit excuse and are leading with it on principle being "un-Conservative" and briefing against the Treasury which has changed tact and is now in support of it.

And Labour's windfall tax is a rush job, the other, FULLY COSTED, proposal was projected to raise £5bn before things got even more stupid, and the revenues generated would be targeted into the Warm Homes Discount scheme and insulation scheme to help the worst off as a priority and help people hold off long term by reducing energy used for heating where it's more difficult to decouple from gas.
Reply
#14
£400 untargeted help for all of us then. Including second home owners.

Warped logic
Reply
#15
The Vatican are looking into this as a potential miracle that this package has appeared from nowhere only 24 hours after the Sue Gray report.

And it appears from Rishi’s interviews that he had invented something called ‘investment relief’. If only this had been thought of before, the man’s a genius
Reply
#16
When you try to be popular then you’re going end up compromising your own beliefs and ideologies. You can’t please your Drax and still try and please John from Hartlepool.
Reply
#17
(05-27-2022, 08:40 AM)Protheroe Wrote: £400 untargeted help for all of us then. Including second home owners.

Warped logic

So that's £800 for second home owners  and so on.

That aside these measures are to be welcomed as bringing short term relief to the UK populus.

It makes me reminisce about my youth, the days when you could elect a Conservative Govt and still get Social Democrat economic policy.
Reply
#18
(05-27-2022, 09:18 AM)baggy1 Wrote: The Vatican are looking into this as a potential miracle that this package has appeared from nowhere only 24 hours after the Sue Gray report.

And it appears from Rishi’s interviews that he had invented something called ‘investment relief’. If only this had been thought of before, the man’s a genius

Truly remarkable, but also exceptionally foolish. My mate is going to get £1,200 quid for his own house, and his holiday homes in Salcombe and Aldeburgh. He's also going to get his Winter Fuel Allowance.

For a huge swathe of the British public energy prices are like a wasp buzzing about. An annoyance but hardly a major trauma.

A far better use of this "discretionary" £400 / household would be to insulate the coldest homes in the country. And I'm upset that it took Rachel Reeves nasal drone to make this point, rather than any sentient Tory MP (that is, if any remain).

(05-27-2022, 09:40 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: When you try to be popular then you’re going end up compromising your own beliefs and ideologies. You can’t please your Drax and still try and please John from Hartlepool.

[Image: b816a665392d583171c57ac72be14fd6.jpg]
Reply
#19
I did think Rachel came across as particularly Brummie this morning for someone who appears to have been nowhere near here in her life for any extended period.
Reply
#20
Two commendable government announcements this week:

1. Henry Dimbleby's paternalistic bollocks which would increase the cost of junk food kicked into touch.

2. Scrapping the middle-class subsidy for poorly built Teslas.

That's more like it.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)