Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Why when whole sale gas prices have fallen back to levels seen 2 years ago are prices still increasing.
Electricity power stations are powered by gas, wind power gets cheaper every day, solar power hasn't gone up.
We have no shortage of Oil or Gas. And before the old "The market rates determine the price we pay is shouted"
Why are the Arab countries paying pennies for a litre of petrol. Lets not kid ourselves it's a government decision to charge the UK public the inflated market price.
EDF have been price capped to a 4% price cap in France and are happy to subsidise losses in France with profits from the UK.
What does everyone else think.
Posts: 4,258
Threads: 263
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
We sold our infrastructure to foreign interests, because the mantra has been "let the market decide" ever since 1979.
The notion of pricing consumers out of using fossil fuels has the interesting side-effect of increasing the tax revenue.
Posts: 8,079
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
05-25-2022, 10:08 PM
(This post was last modified: 05-25-2022, 10:46 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
From someone quite connected (excuse the pun) to the industry, it’s a for few reasons this is happening. And some are little short of a sham; others run deeper.
Privatisation of virtually everything connected to energy supply (it is tiered since, now, so that being one thing - profit isn’t centralised anymore) being the primary issue. Their shares are seen as safe bets.
But this has consequences many don’t see. There is a lack of common investment policy that hurts energy industries at play. So common interest plays a clear second place. I’ve worked, engineered and latterly sold solutions to the energy industry, since I graduated in engineering in 2002. Without doubt, there’s no coincidence in the disparity between stakeholder/consumer benefit in cost per kW generated/sold, between nationalised versus privatised energy economies. Naturally the latter were quicker on the uptake because the former - previously - had always been faster to adopt new technologies that enabled them to evolve and dictate a market that would guarantee continued the investment* to do so (I’ll come back to that). However the former had always far more to gain. And bear in mind what we do for the industry, as a whole, is minimal.
The third is that for some reasons mentioned above, larger, richer economies have a stranglehold on technology. And want to pay for more R&D through profitability. But it doesn’t help realise benefits for consumers, OR (would you believe) utilities. Fragmenting GEs service and OEM service sectors had exactly that impact. But it had to do so in the impact of ‘free market competition’ for what risked becoming a bloated service sector.
Fourthly, higher energy prices benefits (and subsequently PFI stakeholdership within) projects that may not be commercially viable previously. Sizewell C, Hinckley C are evidence of that, as are many wind farm projects post feed-in tariffs. All of which don’t stand up when we’re paying low prices, but are nonetheless necessary because of so many drains and no common policy towards collective investment. The government are having to subsidise what they sold off, but not properly. Because their consumers and voters lose otherwise, when energy supply can never truly be private unless you have the ability to choose which plug or gas main to connect to (in very loose terms).
Finally, combined cycle gas turbine plants (which now typically generate energy at a very respectable 60% thermal efficiently) make up for a lot of western economies’ ‘spare capacity’. They are easy to switch on and off when needed. And that’s been no more apparent recently, when the wind didn’t blow.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(05-25-2022, 10:08 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: From someone quite connected (excuse the pun) to the industry, it’s a for few reasons this is happening. And some are little short of a sham; others run deeper.
Privatisation of virtually everything connected to energy supply (it is tiered since, now, so that being one thing - profit isn’t centralised anymore) being the primary issue. Their shares are seen as safe bets.
But this has consequences many don’t see. There is a lack of common investment policy that hurts energy industries at play. So common interest plays a clear second place. I’ve worked, engineered and latterly sold solutions to the energy industry, since I graduated in engineering in 2002. Without doubt, there’s no coincidence in the disparity between stakeholder/consumer benefit in cost per kW generated/sold, between nationalised versus privatised energy economies. Naturally the latter were quicker on the uptake because the former - previously - had always been faster to adopt new technologies that enabled them to evolve and dictate a market that would guarantee continued the investment* to do so (I’ll come back to that). However the former had always far more to gain. And bear in mind what we do for the industry, as a whole, is minimal.
The third is that for some reasons mentioned above, larger, richer economies have a stranglehold on technology. And want to pay for more R&D through profitability. But it doesn’t help realise benefits for consumers, OR (would you believe) utilities. Fragmenting GEs service and OEM service sectors had exactly that impact. But it had to do so in the impact of ‘free market competition’ for what risked becoming a bloated service sector.
Fourthly, higher energy prices benefits (and subsequently PFI stakeholdership within) projects that may not be commercially viable previously. Sizewell C, Hinckley C are evidence of that, as are many wind farm projects post feed-in tariffs. All of which don’t stand up when we’re paying low prices, but are nonetheless necessary because of so many drains and no common policy towards collective investment. The government are having to subsidise what they sold off, but not properly. Because their consumers and voters lose otherwise, when energy supply can never truly be private unless you have the ability to choose which plug or gas main to connect to (in very loose terms).
Finally, combined cycle gas turbine plants (which now typically generate energy at a very respectable 60% thermal efficiently) make up for a lot of western economies’ ‘spare capacity’. They are easy to switch on and off when needed. And that’s been no more apparent recently, when the wind didn’t blow.
So it's all the super MCW stocks and shares type people wanting their profits? Whodda ever thunked it?
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
Excellent behind the scenes information, all of which is interesting. However politics is playing a massive part in the prices we pay. We are actually selling our gas to Europe at the moment (and electricity) and making vast profits to help subsidise the shortfalls. These are helping to keep the market value up or down depending on how you view stabilization of availability. and enhancing the profit margins. We actually have a glut of gas. Nobody in Europe has any large storage capacity as Russian plentiful supply had deemed storage unnecessary.
Rather then increasing price caps, looking into windfall tax rebates. IMO the government should stop price hikes completely. The public need to be made aware what is happening to why they are being ripped off.
.
Posts: 11,311
Threads: 419
Joined: Feb 2020
Reputation:
18
05-26-2022, 07:40 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-26-2022, 07:42 AM by Protheroe.)
(05-26-2022, 06:56 AM)MassDebater Wrote: So it's anyone with an occupational pension fund or drawing their pension wanting their profits? Whodda ever thunked it?
I've corrected that for you.
(05-26-2022, 07:13 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: IMO the government should stop price hikes completely.
Who exactly, will pay the difference this winter then?
Posts: 10,436
Threads: 427
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
16
05-26-2022, 08:13 AM
(This post was last modified: 05-26-2022, 08:14 AM by Remi_Moses.)
Protheroe Wrote:MassDebater Wrote:So it's anyone with an occupational pension fund or drawing their pension wanting their profits? Whodda ever thunked it?
I've corrected that for you.
Remi_Moses Wrote:IMO the government should stop price hikes completely.
Who exactly, will pay the difference this winter then?
Difference, what difference the price we pay is being held artificially high. Why should we pay extra because Germany is short of gas.
Posts: 6,454
Threads: 192
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
26
Renationslise all the utilities. That'll please Proth.
Posts: 18,398
Threads: 256
Joined: Jan 2019
(05-26-2022, 06:56 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (05-25-2022, 10:08 PM)HawkingsHalfpint Wrote: From someone quite connected (excuse the pun) to the industry, it’s a for few reasons this is happening. And some are little short of a sham; others run deeper.
Privatisation of virtually everything connected to energy supply (it is tiered since, now, so that being one thing - profit isn’t centralised anymore) being the primary issue. Their shares are seen as safe bets.
But this has consequences many don’t see. There is a lack of common investment policy that hurts energy industries at play. So common interest plays a clear second place. I’ve worked, engineered and latterly sold solutions to the energy industry, since I graduated in engineering in 2002. Without doubt, there’s no coincidence in the disparity between stakeholder/consumer benefit in cost per kW generated/sold, between nationalised versus privatised energy economies. Naturally the latter were quicker on the uptake because the former - previously - had always been faster to adopt new technologies that enabled them to evolve and dictate a market that would guarantee continued the investment* to do so (I’ll come back to that). However the former had always far more to gain. And bear in mind what we do for the industry, as a whole, is minimal.
The third is that for some reasons mentioned above, larger, richer economies have a stranglehold on technology. And want to pay for more R&D through profitability. But it doesn’t help realise benefits for consumers, OR (would you believe) utilities. Fragmenting GEs service and OEM service sectors had exactly that impact. But it had to do so in the impact of ‘free market competition’ for what risked becoming a bloated service sector.
Fourthly, higher energy prices benefits (and subsequently PFI stakeholdership within) projects that may not be commercially viable previously. Sizewell C, Hinckley C are evidence of that, as are many wind farm projects post feed-in tariffs. All of which don’t stand up when we’re paying low prices, but are nonetheless necessary because of so many drains and no common policy towards collective investment. The government are having to subsidise what they sold off, but not properly. Because their consumers and voters lose otherwise, when energy supply can never truly be private unless you have the ability to choose which plug or gas main to connect to (in very loose terms).
Finally, combined cycle gas turbine plants (which now typically generate energy at a very respectable 60% thermal efficiently) make up for a lot of western economies’ ‘spare capacity’. They are easy to switch on and off when needed. And that’s been no more apparent recently, when the wind didn’t blow.
So it's all the super MCW stocks and shares type people wanting their profits? Whodda ever thunked it?
Was always thus. I was lending money to the RECs and water companies in the 90's. Even then, shareholder return was the only single thing that mattered to them. They weren't interested in inward investment.
|