A question of principle
#1
When a country's economic and social integrity is threatened by an international agreement, is it correct to set it aside?
Reply
#2
If you are referring to the NI protocol, this is what you get by trying to square a circle.
Reply
#3
(05-19-2022, 05:18 PM)Protheroe Wrote: When a country's economic and social integrity is threatened by an international agreement, is it correct to set it aside?

The country’s economic and social integrity being threatened was a known quantity and likely outcome of the Brexit decision but we decided it was a risk worth taking obviously. It’s a bit ripe when the people who made the decision that led to this country’s economic and social integrity being threatened have decided that the best outcome is to make the situation worse rather than reverse the original poor decision.
Reply
#4
I was referring to Germany paying for Russian gas in Roubles.
Reply
#5
Same answer then, that's what you get by trying to square the circle just with respect to asinine energy policy.
Reply
#6
(05-19-2022, 06:41 PM)Protheroe Wrote: I was referring to Germany paying for Russian gas in Roubles.

I'd be interested in how the social integrity of Germany would be threatened if the Germans stuck by their contract and paid in Euros, you can see how the economic integrity would be threatened obviously but I don't see that this would lead to a break up of the society as they know it (in the same way that the Brexit decision has led to Northern Ireland being a de facto part of the EU).

Germany could risk taking the hit of being cut off as their supplies will last for a few months, and any subsequent hardships in the way of industry and restriction of gas use would, i'd imagine, be supported by the vast majority of the population because of the alternative (supporting the Russian regime).
Reply
#7
Here's a bigger question of principle. Does NATO standby and watch Russia slowly grind out their apparent end game now which looks like controlling the whole of the coast of Ukraine resulting in Russia controlling the export of grain and other keys products to the west, or does it place some warships in the western Black Sea to protect the trade lines and allow Ukraine to start exporting safely.
Reply
#8
(05-19-2022, 06:49 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: Same answer then, that's what you get by trying to square the circle just with respect to asinine energy policy.

So it's not correct to set it aside then?

OK, at least your consistent. Most won't be I'm sure.
Reply
#9
What is correct for Germany is to reopen as many of the recently decommissioned nuclear power plants and postpone the decommissioning of the nuclear power plants due by the end of 2022 and 2023 while utilising the summer gas demand drop to stockpile provisions for next winter.

Ultimately they're in the position they are in because of the inherent unworkable contradictions with respect to their asinine energy policy.
Reply
#10
It's only the principle I'm interested in BB. That's all.

If the UK was considering breaking international agreements on sanctions I'm sure there'd be an outcry similar to the controversy over the NI protocol where an international agreement is not being broken, but (potentially) being suspended using a provision inserted for precisely the same economic and social ends Germany has in mind as Putin's bitch.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: