(05-05-2022, 07:46 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: my point is we have produced some good players in the last few years, or decade far better than in the
1990s and 2000s and some of them we should have kept. We have signed some worse players in recent years than those abovr, mainly
because they are more experienced
We can’t keep every kid on the basis that they might come good. There’s no guarantee that any of them would have developed the same way had they remained with us either. Players like Roofe and Wood left because at the time we were a PL club and there was no obvious to the first team. Players improve through regular game time, not hanging around out stiffs. Kane Wilson winning League 2 right back of the year does not necessarily mean he is or was good enough for what we needed when we let him go.
Letting any of those players go was not a mistake IMO. Of the players listed only Wood has demonstrated he has what it takes to play in the PL regularly, and he would never have proven that staying with us.
In fact, let’s take a look in more depth…
Griffiths - still at the club
Wilson - not good enough for a team with PL ambitions
Fitzwater - see above
O'Shea - still at the club
Ferguson - poached by Palace
TGH - still at the club
Rogers - sold to City for a fair price at the time
Iroegbunam - poached by Villa
Field - fair argument for not letting go
Roofe - not good enough for a PL side
Wood - wanted first team football. Wasn’t going to get ahead of Long/Wingie/Fortune/etc.
Azaz - not good enough
Brown - poached by Chelsea
Sawyers - still at the club
Berahino - sold for £11m
I’m not sure how many players mentioned were actually mistakes to let go, maybe Field at a push. Others we’ve lost to bigger clubs, some we sold for fair prices and others simply weren’t good enough.