![]() |
|
Our kids X1 - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Our kids X1 (/showthread.php?tid=25151) Pages:
1
2
|
Our kids X1 - Gzbaggy - 05-04-2022 Griffiths Wilson Fitzwater O'Shea Ferguson TGH Rogers Iroegbunam Field Roofe Wood Azaz/Brown / Sawyers/Berahino Quite a few playing at a good level RE: Our kids X1 - wba13 - 05-04-2022 Yes but Edwards, Leko and Harper were the next big things look where they are now, but lots were saying we should be playing them. RE: Our kids X1 - Duffers - 05-04-2022 Failing to see what the OP is getting at here. One of the “kids” is now 30 and has played for five different clubs since leaving us. RE: Our kids X1 - Gzbaggy - 05-05-2022 my point is we have produced some good players in the last few years, or decade far better than in the 1990s and 2000s and some of them we should have kept. We have signed some worse players in recent years than those abovr, mainly because they are more experienced RE: Our kids X1 - Duffers - 05-05-2022 (05-05-2022, 07:46 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: my point is we have produced some good players in the last few years, or decade far better than in the We can’t keep every kid on the basis that they might come good. There’s no guarantee that any of them would have developed the same way had they remained with us either. Players like Roofe and Wood left because at the time we were a PL club and there was no obvious to the first team. Players improve through regular game time, not hanging around out stiffs. Kane Wilson winning League 2 right back of the year does not necessarily mean he is or was good enough for what we needed when we let him go. Letting any of those players go was not a mistake IMO. Of the players listed only Wood has demonstrated he has what it takes to play in the PL regularly, and he would never have proven that staying with us. In fact, let’s take a look in more depth… Griffiths - still at the club Wilson - not good enough for a team with PL ambitions Fitzwater - see above O'Shea - still at the club Ferguson - poached by Palace TGH - still at the club Rogers - sold to City for a fair price at the time Iroegbunam - poached by Villa Field - fair argument for not letting go Roofe - not good enough for a PL side Wood - wanted first team football. Wasn’t going to get ahead of Long/Wingie/Fortune/etc. Azaz - not good enough Brown - poached by Chelsea Sawyers - still at the club Berahino - sold for £11m I’m not sure how many players mentioned were actually mistakes to let go, maybe Field at a push. Others we’ve lost to bigger clubs, some we sold for fair prices and others simply weren’t good enough. RE: Our kids X1 - baggiebloke - 05-05-2022 Tyler Roberts And George Thorne who should defo play for Stourbridge. RE: Our kids X1 - Swagbaggie - 05-05-2022 You could add Roberts and perhaps Danda to this list but it is such a nonsense argument. We got rid of Wood at a time when our strikers were top class. If we had developed as we should have he would never have got a game. Ditto Roofe and in fact most of the others. At the time they were released they were not good enough to be likely to get a regular start given the squad(s) we had. The fact that our lack of investment, Management and development has meant that we have now fallen to a level where they are now good enough again says much more about the people in charge of our club than what those guys are playing like. RE: Our kids X1 - Birdman1811 - 05-05-2022 Only mistake by the club in these lists so far is Field. Even that one, I can understand why it was done. RE: Our kids X1 - Lurker#3 - 05-06-2022 The only thing I can hold against the club is not going slightly bigger and braver in terms of considering some young players first teamers. Ferguson, Brown, Iroegbunam and Rogers were all good enough to be considered first team squad players at our level, and should have had contracts offered to them to reflect that. In which time we've paid wages to the likes of Wes Hoolahan, Gareth Barry, Tyrone Mears and Robert Snodgrass. This is where we are making mistakes. RE: Our kids X1 - Tom Joad - 05-06-2022 Lurker#3 Wrote:The only thing I can hold against the club is not going slightly bigger and braver in terms of considering some young players first teamers. Ferguson, Brown, Iroegbunam and Rogers were all good enough to be considered first team squad players at our level, and should have had contracts offered to them to reflect that. In which time we've paid wages to the likes of Wes Hoolahan, Gareth Barry, Tyrone Mears and Robert Snodgrass. This is where we are making mistakes. This. At best we see if they are potentially up to it and it gives them a lift. At worst, it puts some value on them should we try to sell them. |