Energy Prices
#21
Town centre flats……..the investment of choice for those who fancy a bit of negative equity
Reply
#22
I call land-banking land-banking, if you want anecdotes there's several plots in South Warks that have been sat on by developers. They have planning permission, they've gone through a government review, everything is signed off. The houses aren't being built. Why? This is in a high demand area, so that's not the reason.

And I do data analysis by trade, you look at the raw numbers to identify patterns and rates as a means to identify root causes. Double the number of houses are being granted planning permission per year - over multiple years - than are being built. Planning permission is quite obviously not the constraint as otherwise that pattern wouldn't exist, something else is. I might entertain had the rates been close but double is not close.

Also, why would the government lie about planning permission not being a problem to getting houses built when they wanted to relax planning permission regulations?
Reply
#23
Who is going to build them and with what?
Reply
#24
(05-04-2022, 07:31 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I call land-banking land-banking, if you want anecdotes there's several plots in South Warks that have been sat on by developers. They have planning permission, they've gone through a government review, everything is signed off. The houses aren't being built. Why? This is in a high demand area, so that's not the reason.

And I do data analysis by trade, you look at the raw numbers to identify patterns and rates as a means to identify root causes. Double the number of houses are being granted planning permission per year - over multiple years - than are being built. Planning permission is quite obviously not the constraint as otherwise that pattern wouldn't exist, something else is. I might entertain had the rates been close but double is not close.

Also, why would the government lie about planning permission not being a problem to getting houses built when they wanted to relax planning permission regulations?

You clearly don't understand how development works, that's OK - not many people do.

As for your latter point - are you for real? Your lot in Chesham & Amersham killed planning reform for another Parliament. Literal ROFL you raising that.
Reply
#25
(05-04-2022, 07:36 AM)TTM2 Wrote: Who is going to build them and with what?

Who is going to build it? I don't know, I've been talking about skills shortages as I accept that is a huge barrier. We could relax immigration restrictions though and put skills shortages onto the skills shortages list as a short term measure.

With what? Right now there's very little capacity but that deficit is a longstanding trend. Correct me if I'm wrong but the pressure of building supply was nowhere near what it is now 6 years ago yet the rate deficit was the same, so whilst there's no immediate term solution there may be capacity to wait out the demand surge.

(05-04-2022, 08:04 AM)Protheroe Wrote:
(05-04-2022, 07:31 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: I call land-banking land-banking, if you want anecdotes there's several plots in South Warks that have been sat on by developers. They have planning permission, they've gone through a government review, everything is signed off. The houses aren't being built. Why? This is in a high demand area, so that's not the reason.

And I do data analysis by trade, you look at the raw numbers to identify patterns and rates as a means to identify root causes. Double the number of houses are being granted planning permission per year - over multiple years - than are being built. Planning permission is quite obviously not the constraint as otherwise that pattern wouldn't exist, something else is. I might entertain had the rates been close but double is not close.

Also, why would the government lie about planning permission not being a problem to getting houses built when they wanted to relax planning permission regulations?

You clearly don't understand how development works, that's OK - not many people do.

As for your latter point - are you for real? Your lot in Chesham & Amersham killed planning reform for another Parliament. Literal ROFL you raising that.

You've not addressed whatsoever why the rate of planning permission being granted is double that of houses being built. If your assertion that planning permission was the major constraint was true that pattern wouldn't exist, would it? So why is the rate of planning permission being granted double the rate of houses being built?

As for C&A, last I checked my lot isn't the government, that report was well before the election and the Tories wanted to turn the entire area into a national park so no houses could be built there ever. Let's not forget that "your lot" scrapped the 10 garden cities that were due to start building they "my lot" proposed during the coalition, or did you forget that? Since "my lot" was in coalition the rate of social housing being built has dropped, a key factor in reducing speculation, is that my fault as well? But it's "my lot" that's the problem? I've literally been campaigning within the Lib Dems to undermine the NIMBY localist factions with the building communities position reform including support at the Lib Dem pressure group that came up with it.
Reply
#26
I've explained that the rate of planning permissions granted is wholly unrelated to the demand / need in the locations where people actually want to live, and for the type of properties they actually want to live in.

The simple laws of commerce dictate that developers will build the houses that are demanded in the locations of greatest demand - it's lunacy to suggest they wouldn't and are somehow "landbanking" - give me the commercial rationale for doing that, please.

The problem is that the planning system massively constrains where homes can be built and what homes can be built. If you can't understand that then there's no hope for you. It's the reason why developers are sitting on consents for swathes of Digbeth and the JQ - there simply isn't the demand to flood the market. Yet you'd sell the 100-odd houses up the road from me on Worcester Lane off-plan in a matter of weeks and a 1000 more if only you could get the consent.

My former lot are as much to blame as every other political party fawning over the selfishness of locals with a scrubby field nearby. I've cleaned up one of the rentals this morning and the Lib Dem candidate's leaflet was on the mat claiming he's "saved" a field at Foxcote. This is the kind of crap we're all up against. No one wants anything built anywhere near them.
Reply
#27
Developers want to optimise the sale value of housing, I think it's no coincidence that the developments in Warwick District - a high demand area as I'm sure you're aware - the greatest deficit between planning permission being granted and houses being built has been in properties designated to be sold at 20% below market value. 2,400 affordable houses in the authority have full planning permission but only 320 are actually being built. That is why I'm fundamentally against giving the large developers more power, they're just going to continue ignoring the deficit where it is needed and focus on the speculative market which is why our house prices are stupid to begin with. There's a development near me close to Common Lane where the only houses that haven't started construction are the ones earmarked as affordable, every other one is either under construction or sold. That is textbook land-banking and it's contributing to the deficit. It isn't as though that deficit is small and could easily be explained away by discrepancies in planning, it is double the rate.

The problem with the housing market is that there is a longstanding skills shortage in construction and too much attention has been paid to helping the speculative market over the last 45 years instead of the social market.

And I don't really care what individuals and local parties are saying, I had an argument with the Coventry Lib Dems over NIMBYism with regards to the Kings Hill development in 2019 (it isn't even in Coventry CC's jurisdiction). I care about the fact that there needs to be an incentive to change the focus to social and affordable housing away from the speculative market and that is where Conservative party policy and Conservative-run councils are well behind Labour and the Lib Dems
Reply
#28
You may think it's no coincidence, but have you ever built anything?

I've built several million square feet of office and warehouse space. Some to order, some speculatively. I've also worked to bring forward thousands of acres of land in planning plays lasting up to 7 or 8 years including some of the largest shed parks in the Midlands at Keresley, Birch Coppice & Hams Hall. You have no concept of the hoops a developer has to jump through for the planning authorities nor the financial challenges this presents.

There may be any number of reasons why a development may not have commenced. I had to wait 15 months for an HV supply at a cost of £750,000 for one of my sites before it was worthwhile breaking ground. The delay in the provision of other stat services, let alone highways works is similar. The interest financing costs on land for these delays are huge - so again I ask - why on Earth would a developer delay?

We would always negotiate to complete s106 and s278 works or contributions when we actually had some money coming in, not before. Housebuilders adopt the same dynamic with affordable housing, and who can blame them. It's not textbook landbanking, it's commercial reality when the price of land is so high because of the rationing of the planning system. The effects you describe are a consequence of the planning system.
Reply
#29
Developers want to optimise the sale value, that is why they would delay construction and that is the incentive to land bank. Whether that be through maximising the price of housing or taking advantage of the uplift of land value over time via the granting of planning permission, and thanks to the stupidity of our current speculation-driven housing market that's a viable means of profit. You're not really arguing that land-banking isn't a thing, you're justifying it as a symptom instead of a cause and therefore a necessity - your point about the lack of incentive to build affordable housing is testament to that.

Have you thought of looking outside the current box and engaging in civic housebuilding? Bypass the speculative market and do what was done pre-WW2. That was the point in the garden cities that were scrapped after the coalition, that's how we've enabled massive house building surges in the past.
Reply
#30
I just don't agree with the first line of your contention. It makes zero commercial sense in such a constrained market.

What you perceive to be malign "landbanking" is nothing of the sort. It's merely developers playing the awful hand they've been dealt the best way they can. I know, I was one.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)