Posts: 7,409
Threads: 458
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(04-23-2022, 04:46 PM)Sliced Wrote: 2 shots on target. One of our best returns in the last 15 games.
Viva La Bruce Ball! Bring on the rebuild
Thought I it was three, 2 from Grant 1 from Clarke still crap whatever. Better 2nd Half than 1st but overall rubbish. We definitely need some pace.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(04-23-2022, 06:26 PM)Sliced Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:06 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (04-23-2022, 05:59 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (04-23-2022, 05:57 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I'd hope there would be an improvement next season if we actually bring in some creative midfielders which this squad desperately lacks as the last manager saw no need for them!
So without creative midfielders, why not use the width more, get the ball forward quicker, put pressure on the opposition far quicker, that's how you deal with that. Not just sit there and go, well, got no creativity, so play at a snails pace guys.
But isn't that essentially Valball? And opposition teams worked it out quickly.
Our success in this division in previous years was mostly due to a very good midfield. This is one of the worst we've ever had.
Yes, it is Valball, and I'm not as convinced as others about "Other teams worked it out." Because any tactic can be worked out by other teams. Pulis was an expert at stopping possession-based, attacking football, that's how tactics work. What happened was in a few games we didn't do the job very well because the players aren't suited to it (This squad isn't suited to anything.) Players' heads dropped and they did it less and less. Val, wrongly, IMO, tried to modify it to use the midfield more, but that broke what his entire game was built on. He'd have been better being more stubborn, and dropping players who didn't buy in for young players that had bought into it.
Give me any tactic, and I'll tell you how you stop it, all tactics are one-dimensional unless you have extremely intelligent players who can change on the fly. Liverpool are ridiculously simple to stop in theory, just they are so good at it, teams can't actually execute it well enough. Remember for Klopps first couple of years Liverpool were very soft and people saying Gegenpress wasn't all it was cracked up to be. Over time he got the squad and the whole club working how he wanted, and now look.
I said before, Val was the absolutely wrong choice if we wanted an instant return, but if we were actually on for a rebuild project, then you give him time and the resources, losing Dike so early killed him off sadly here, then losing the players due to his fallout with Johnstone was just the final straw, players wanted him gone, downed tools, knowing fans didn't want him either, so anger would be at the manager, and well, look where we are now.
Good post. As far as "teams worked us out" I don't get that either. We couldn't finish for shit. I'm pretty sure the oppositions strategy wasn't "let them have 25 shots" and they won't score. Tactically we were fine, the number of chances created for and against showed that.
The issue was confidence. Undoubtedly that was partially down to Val so I'm not absolving him of blame. However, a few more of those missed sitters going in and I think we'd be looking at a very different season.
Right now we seem to have no idea of tactics, no way of playing and our performances for the most part are getting worse. We're attacking less, defending more and just generally are a complete mess.
Valball will never win awards for being easy on the eye, it's direct, it's chaotic even. But it has a simple purpose, keep play in the opposition third, maximise the chances created and concede very few chances. You don't get to see much pretty passing, very little skill unless it's very close to the opposition goal. Fans will always have limited patience with it. If we had finished more chances, and had a striker who could lead the line properly, it would have wielded better results, but fans would be moaning about the style.
Posts: 4,733
Threads: 105
Joined: May 2019
Reputation:
3
(04-23-2022, 07:14 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:26 PM)Sliced Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:06 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (04-23-2022, 05:59 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: So without creative midfielders, why not use the width more, get the ball forward quicker, put pressure on the opposition far quicker, that's how you deal with that. Not just sit there and go, well, got no creativity, so play at a snails pace guys.
But isn't that essentially Valball? And opposition teams worked it out quickly.
Our success in this division in previous years was mostly due to a very good midfield. This is one of the worst we've ever had.
Yes, it is Valball, and I'm not as convinced as others about "Other teams worked it out." Because any tactic can be worked out by other teams. Pulis was an expert at stopping possession-based, attacking football, that's how tactics work. What happened was in a few games we didn't do the job very well because the players aren't suited to it (This squad isn't suited to anything.) Players' heads dropped and they did it less and less. Val, wrongly, IMO, tried to modify it to use the midfield more, but that broke what his entire game was built on. He'd have been better being more stubborn, and dropping players who didn't buy in for young players that had bought into it.
Give me any tactic, and I'll tell you how you stop it, all tactics are one-dimensional unless you have extremely intelligent players who can change on the fly. Liverpool are ridiculously simple to stop in theory, just they are so good at it, teams can't actually execute it well enough. Remember for Klopps first couple of years Liverpool were very soft and people saying Gegenpress wasn't all it was cracked up to be. Over time he got the squad and the whole club working how he wanted, and now look.
I said before, Val was the absolutely wrong choice if we wanted an instant return, but if we were actually on for a rebuild project, then you give him time and the resources, losing Dike so early killed him off sadly here, then losing the players due to his fallout with Johnstone was just the final straw, players wanted him gone, downed tools, knowing fans didn't want him either, so anger would be at the manager, and well, look where we are now.
Good post. As far as "teams worked us out" I don't get that either. We couldn't finish for shit. I'm pretty sure the oppositions strategy wasn't "let them have 25 shots" and they won't score. Tactically we were fine, the number of chances created for and against showed that.
The issue was confidence. Undoubtedly that was partially down to Val so I'm not absolving him of blame. However, a few more of those missed sitters going in and I think we'd be looking at a very different season.
Right now we seem to have no idea of tactics, no way of playing and our performances for the most part are getting worse. We're attacking less, defending more and just generally are a complete mess.
Valball will never win awards for being easy on the eye, it's direct, it's chaotic even. But it has a simple purpose, keep play in the opposition third, maximise the chances created and concede very few chances. You don't get to see much pretty passing, very little skill unless it's very close to the opposition goal. Fans will always have limited patience with it. If we had finished more chances, and had a striker who could lead the line properly, it would have wielded better results, but fans would be moaning about the style.
Our fanbase are a lot more tolerable towards managers who play football thats easy on the eye even if it doesn't get results. It's why we wore Mowbray masks at Blackburn while he got us relegated and told Pulis his football was shit away at Bournemouth while we were mid table in the Premier League. It's no surprise that the fans turned on Val quickly. I recall Mowbray after the Blackburn game saying that our fans wouldn't put up with that style of play. It wasn't the right appointment for us and we weren't the right club for Val.
Posts: 5,201
Threads: 197
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
(04-23-2022, 05:38 PM)Sliced Wrote: (04-23-2022, 05:26 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: We were such a great team before Brucey arrived. All that great football we played and all those goals we scored. Those signings Val made really improved us and took us to the next level.
The thread is about Bruce, no one mentioned Val.
But seeing as you did:
Less goals scored per game since Bruce has arrived
More goals conceded per game
Less points in Bruce's first 15 games than Ismael's last 15 games
Less shots per game in that same time period
Less shots on target per game in that same time period
More shots against per game in that time period
More shots on target against per game in that time period
Less possession in that time period.
In Val's tenure we failed to score in 11 out of 29 games (about 1 in 3) in Bruce's it's been 7 out of 15 (about 1 in 2).
Other than that he's been a massive improvement. Can't wait for next season. The future's bright.
I’m sure Big Daddy Cool is either Ron or Alex Bruce
Cuzer
Fisheatingdeludedsealwankers
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(04-23-2022, 07:39 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (04-23-2022, 07:14 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:26 PM)Sliced Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:06 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: But isn't that essentially Valball? And opposition teams worked it out quickly.
Our success in this division in previous years was mostly due to a very good midfield. This is one of the worst we've ever had.
Yes, it is Valball, and I'm not as convinced as others about "Other teams worked it out." Because any tactic can be worked out by other teams. Pulis was an expert at stopping possession-based, attacking football, that's how tactics work. What happened was in a few games we didn't do the job very well because the players aren't suited to it (This squad isn't suited to anything.) Players' heads dropped and they did it less and less. Val, wrongly, IMO, tried to modify it to use the midfield more, but that broke what his entire game was built on. He'd have been better being more stubborn, and dropping players who didn't buy in for young players that had bought into it.
Give me any tactic, and I'll tell you how you stop it, all tactics are one-dimensional unless you have extremely intelligent players who can change on the fly. Liverpool are ridiculously simple to stop in theory, just they are so good at it, teams can't actually execute it well enough. Remember for Klopps first couple of years Liverpool were very soft and people saying Gegenpress wasn't all it was cracked up to be. Over time he got the squad and the whole club working how he wanted, and now look.
I said before, Val was the absolutely wrong choice if we wanted an instant return, but if we were actually on for a rebuild project, then you give him time and the resources, losing Dike so early killed him off sadly here, then losing the players due to his fallout with Johnstone was just the final straw, players wanted him gone, downed tools, knowing fans didn't want him either, so anger would be at the manager, and well, look where we are now.
Good post. As far as "teams worked us out" I don't get that either. We couldn't finish for shit. I'm pretty sure the oppositions strategy wasn't "let them have 25 shots" and they won't score. Tactically we were fine, the number of chances created for and against showed that.
The issue was confidence. Undoubtedly that was partially down to Val so I'm not absolving him of blame. However, a few more of those missed sitters going in and I think we'd be looking at a very different season.
Right now we seem to have no idea of tactics, no way of playing and our performances for the most part are getting worse. We're attacking less, defending more and just generally are a complete mess.
Valball will never win awards for being easy on the eye, it's direct, it's chaotic even. But it has a simple purpose, keep play in the opposition third, maximise the chances created and concede very few chances. You don't get to see much pretty passing, very little skill unless it's very close to the opposition goal. Fans will always have limited patience with it. If we had finished more chances, and had a striker who could lead the line properly, it would have wielded better results, but fans would be moaning about the style.
Our fanbase are a lot more tolerable towards managers who play football thats easy on the eye even if it doesn't get results. It's why we wore Mowbray masks at Blackburn while he got us relegated and told Pulis his football was shit away at Bournemouth while we were mid table in the Premier League. It's no surprise that the fans turned on Val quickly. I recall Mowbray after the Blackburn game saying that our fans wouldn't put up with that style of play. It wasn't the right appointment for us and we weren't the right club for Val.
Why I get so frustrated with our fans.
It's a sport, results are all that matter, I hated the abuse of Pulis while he was keeping us midtable in the Prem.
Posts: 2,941
Threads: 57
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
25
(04-23-2022, 05:38 PM)Sliced Wrote: Less goals scored per game since Bruce has arrived
More goals conceded per game
Less points in Bruce's first 15 games than Ismael's last 15 games
Less shots per game in that same time period
Less shots on target per game in that same time period
More shots against per game in that time period
More shots on target against per game in that time period
Less possession in that time period.
In Val's tenure we failed to score in 11 out of 29 games (about 1 in 3) in Bruce's it's been 7 out of 15 (about 1 in 2).
Other than that he's been a massive improvement. Can't wait for next season. The future's bright.
Unfortunately, some believe that stats, performances and results have been irrelevant since Bruce arrived, so are happy to give him a free ride despite the fact that he's not done what he himself, with his vast experience, readily accepted as being the target when he was first appointed.
Worse still is that Gourlay is also willing to give him a free ride, despite the immense failure illustrated by what you've pointed out above.
Posts: 10,272
Threads: 694
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(04-23-2022, 06:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:06 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (04-23-2022, 05:59 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (04-23-2022, 05:57 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (04-23-2022, 05:38 PM)Sliced Wrote: The thread is about Bruce, no one mentioned Val.
But seeing as you did:
Less goals scored per game since Bruce has arrived
More goals conceded per game
Less points in Bruce's first 15 games than Ismael's last 15 games
Less shots per game in that same time period
Less shots on target per game in that same time period
More shots against per game in that time period
More shots on target against per game in that time period
Less possession in that time period.
In Val's tenure we failed to score in 11 out of 29 games (about 1 in 3) in Bruce's it's been 7 out of 15 (about 1 in 2).
Other than that he's been a massive improvement. Can't wait for next season. The future's bright.
I'd hope there would be an improvement next season if we actually bring in some creative midfielders which this squad desperately lacks as the last manager saw no need for them!
So without creative midfielders, why not use the width more, get the ball forward quicker, put pressure on the opposition far quicker, that's how you deal with that. Not just sit there and go, well, got no creativity, so play at a snails pace guys.
But isn't that essentially Valball? And opposition teams worked it out quickly.
Our success in this division in previous years was mostly due to a very good midfield. This is one of the worst we've ever had.
Yes, it is Valball, and I'm not as convinced as others about "Other teams worked it out." Because any tactic can be worked out by other teams. Pulis was an expert at stopping possession-based, attacking football, that's how tactics work. What happened was in a few games we didn't do the job very well because the players aren't suited to it (This squad isn't suited to anything.) Players' heads dropped and they did it less and less. Val, wrongly, IMO, tried to modify it to use the midfield more, but that broke what his entire game was built on. He'd have been better being more stubborn, and dropping players who didn't buy in for young players that had bought into it.
Give me any tactic, and I'll tell you how you stop it, all tactics are one-dimensional unless you have extremely intelligent players who can change on the fly. Liverpool are ridiculously simple to stop in theory, just they are so good at it, teams can't actually execute it well enough. Remember for Klopps first couple of years Liverpool were very soft and people saying Gegenpress wasn't all it was cracked up to be. Over time he got the squad and the whole club working how he wanted, and now look.
I said before, Val was the absolutely wrong choice if we wanted an instant return, but if we were actually on for a rebuild project, then you give him time and the resources, losing Dike so early killed him off sadly here, then losing the players due to his fallout with Johnstone was just the final straw, players wanted him gone, downed tools, knowing fans didn't want him either, so anger would be at the manager, and well, look where we are now. A perfect summary of where we are. The Ishmael experiment succinctly wrapped up and presented. Now can the ones still somehow talking about us being 5th in the league and how he was going to turn it around be quiet.
Bruce is doing poorly, but don't underestimate the mess he inherited.
Posts: 1,060
Threads: 13
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
1
Yes he inherited a mess and he’s managed to make it worse. I fear for our future if he gets to chance to bring in ‘his’ players and we sack him half way through next season’s relegation battle.
Posts: 3,884
Threads: 161
Joined: Mar 2022
(04-23-2022, 05:38 PM)Sliced Wrote: (04-23-2022, 05:26 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: We were such a great team before Brucey arrived. All that great football we played and all those goals we scored. Those signings Val made really improved us and took us to the next level.
The thread is about Bruce, no one mentioned Val.
But seeing as you did:
Less goals scored per game since Bruce has arrived
More goals conceded per game
Less points in Bruce's first 15 games than Ismael's last 15 games
Less shots per game in that same time period
Less shots on target per game in that same time period
More shots against per game in that time period
More shots on target against per game in that time period
Less possession in that time period.
In Val's tenure we failed to score in 11 out of 29 games (about 1 in 3) in Bruce's it's been 7 out of 15 (about 1 in 2).
Other than that he's been a massive improvement. Can't wait for next season. The future's bright. Just turn the laptop off you won't have to endure it .
Posts: 612
Threads: 53
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
(04-23-2022, 09:31 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:13 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (04-23-2022, 06:06 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: (04-23-2022, 05:59 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: (04-23-2022, 05:57 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: I'd hope there would be an improvement next season if we actually bring in some creative midfielders which this squad desperately lacks as the last manager saw no need for them!
So without creative midfielders, why not use the width more, get the ball forward quicker, put pressure on the opposition far quicker, that's how you deal with that. Not just sit there and go, well, got no creativity, so play at a snails pace guys.
But isn't that essentially Valball? And opposition teams worked it out quickly.
Our success in this division in previous years was mostly due to a very good midfield. This is one of the worst we've ever had.
Yes, it is Valball, and I'm not as convinced as others about "Other teams worked it out." Because any tactic can be worked out by other teams. Pulis was an expert at stopping possession-based, attacking football, that's how tactics work. What happened was in a few games we didn't do the job very well because the players aren't suited to it (This squad isn't suited to anything.) Players' heads dropped and they did it less and less. Val, wrongly, IMO, tried to modify it to use the midfield more, but that broke what his entire game was built on. He'd have been better being more stubborn, and dropping players who didn't buy in for young players that had bought into it.
Give me any tactic, and I'll tell you how you stop it, all tactics are one-dimensional unless you have extremely intelligent players who can change on the fly. Liverpool are ridiculously simple to stop in theory, just they are so good at it, teams can't actually execute it well enough. Remember for Klopps first couple of years Liverpool were very soft and people saying Gegenpress wasn't all it was cracked up to be. Over time he got the squad and the whole club working how he wanted, and now look.
I said before, Val was the absolutely wrong choice if we wanted an instant return, but if we were actually on for a rebuild project, then you give him time and the resources, losing Dike so early killed him off sadly here, then losing the players due to his fallout with Johnstone was just the final straw, players wanted him gone, downed tools, knowing fans didn't want him either, so anger would be at the manager, and well, look where we are now. A perfect summary of where we are. The Ishmael experiment succinctly wrapped up and presented. Now can the ones still somehow talking about us being 5th in the league and how he was going to turn it around be quiet.
Bruce is doing poorly, but don't underestimate the mess he inherited. Come on now,you can’t keep trying to defend the indefensible.Any half decent coach would of got this team in the playoffs,we weren’t playing Tottenham or Liverpool every week you know.A good coach sets up the team,he gets the players believing,he gets a happy training ground,he knows the opposition strengths and weaknesses and set pieces are worked on.
|