Andy Carroll
#41
(04-07-2022, 08:04 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: I always used to regard him as a chavvy thuggish knobhead, but his professionalism and determination and quality have made the rest of our squad look amateur. Another 12 months of this AC yes please, still would have concerns that he is due another injury though.

Pretty much where I was and am Midge.

Even if he's not performing to the best of his ability, he gives his all. Not something that you can level at too many of our forward players.
Reply
#42
(04-07-2022, 04:44 PM)ElbowGrease1973 Wrote:
(04-07-2022, 08:04 AM)Midget In A Pinstripe Suit Wrote: I always used to regard him as a chavvy thuggish knobhead, but his professionalism and determination and quality have made the rest of our squad look amateur. Another 12 months of this AC yes please, still would have concerns that he is due another injury though.

Pretty much where I was and am Midge.

Even if he's not performing to the best of his ability, he gives his all. Not something that you can level at too many of our forward players.

Provided we don't do anything stupid like £30k for 3 years! it's a no brainer. Great player to have around the first team. As we've seen with Dike, all players are susceptible to injury and at this moment Carrol looks fit and hungry.
Reply
#43
(04-07-2022, 07:35 AM)lesley Wrote:
(04-06-2022, 10:17 PM)wba13 Wrote: I would try to sign him now before some bottom 6 premiership side come in for him. He has been great for us and stayed fit. Also not afraid to give anyone a bollocking when they need it.

Agreed.
I was very worried that we had done “an Albion” when news broke that we had signed him in January! A player coming towards the end of his playing career just picking up his pay and not being too bothered.

But AC has gone up in my estimation since then. MOTM in many games, always trying, a handful to defences,vocal on the pitch and very useful in defence too. Add to that the fact that he seems to have kept himself fit and well and really seems to care. His past injury record is not great,but I would be very happy keeping him here for another 12 months.
give him another year  and i would make him captain for me 
he plays like one and cares  like a captain should do
i never thought i would be saying this about Andy Carroll
Reply
#44
No brainer to keep him, just hope that he keeps it up when rewarded with another contract.

Also, decent it’s competition for Dike (as well as having the option to play them both of course). Everyone should have to compete for a place, it’s no coincidence that players who don’t lose form.
Reply
#45
Seems like Andy would love to stay on.


https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/sport/f...t-23622274
Reply
#46
On his form and commitment it's a no brainer,but although he shouldn't need the money it will be down to who offers the most and the length of the deal .He is a real old school type of forward and just shows that trying to play Grant ,Robbo n Phillips in that role adds nothing to the team ,sign him up and even if he only plays half a season he will play more than the like of Phillips /Zahore etc.
Reply
#47
Of course we should keep he for a couple of seasons.
Reply
#48
I really want him to stay.

The other wankers can certainly learn from him.
Reply
#49
One year deal. No brainer.
Reply
#50
It is a no brainer really from the clubs perspective if he stays fit to end of season. There's footballers holibobs in the middle and then pre-season, and depends if a in need promoted club goes knocking on his door. The thing in our favour is Brucey, as he has commented before he likes the way Brucey works, and thats if he stays. But it's completely up to Carroll, so we'd need to make it worth his while.

If I was in the Recruitment Department I'd certainly be trying to get is signature on paper before he goes on holibobs, whatever our situation come the end of the season.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: