Rishi's Spring Mini-Budget
#11
(03-24-2022, 09:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The tax 'cut' in 2024 will come after 4 years of fiscal drag. lt's dishonest and meaningless.

The rise in NI threshold is to be welcomed, but NI should also apply earning pensioners. This just adds to the massive intergenerational unfairness (particularly hammering those paying student 'debt' whilst in lower paid work)

I agree on the NI application to pensioners. I never understood why they were exempt.

Inflation is a big worry. This will lead to interest rate rises, and impact on all with a mortgage (which isn't the Tory grandees). Then follows house price inflation, and takes first homes away from most struggling to take a step on the housing ladder.

We have the solutions. There is oil and gas in Scotland (which the SNP are now trying to politicise). It is radical, but we do not have to be bound by market prices when the solution is in our own back yard.
Reply
#12
(03-24-2022, 11:41 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 09:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The tax 'cut' in 2024 will come after 4 years of fiscal drag. lt's dishonest and meaningless.

The rise in NI threshold is to be welcomed, but NI should also apply earning pensioners. This just adds to the massive intergenerational unfairness (particularly hammering those paying student 'debt' whilst in lower paid work)

I agree on the NI application to pensioners. I never understood why they were exempt.

Inflation is a big worry. This will lead to interest rate rises, and impact on all with a mortgage (which isn't the Tory grandees). Then follows house price inflation, and takes first homes away from most struggling to take a step on the housing ladder.

We have the solutions. There is oil and gas in Scotland (which the SNP are now trying to politicise). It is radical, but we do not have to be bound by market prices when the solution is in our own back yard.

We try and close off our gas from the market and we're quickly shut out of global gas markets, we do not have the throughout to supply on domestic gas production and are fucked if we lose out on Norwegian North Sea gas, that's ignoring the problems with crude.
Reply
#13
(03-24-2022, 11:45 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 11:41 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 09:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The tax 'cut' in 2024 will come after 4 years of fiscal drag. lt's dishonest and meaningless.

The rise in NI threshold is to be welcomed, but NI should also apply earning pensioners. This just adds to the massive intergenerational unfairness (particularly hammering those paying student 'debt' whilst in lower paid work)

I agree on the NI application to pensioners. I never understood why they were exempt.

Inflation is a big worry. This will lead to interest rate rises, and impact on all with a mortgage (which isn't the Tory grandees). Then follows house price inflation, and takes first homes away from most struggling to take a step on the housing ladder.

We have the solutions. There is oil and gas in Scotland (which the SNP are now trying to politicise). It is radical, but we do not have to be bound by market prices when the solution is in our own back yard.

We try and close off our gas from the market and we're quickly shut out of global gas markets, we do not have the throughout to supply on domestic gas production and are fucked if we lose out on Norwegian North Sea gas, that's ignoring the problems with crude.

Just simply "pause" the carbon neutral argument by 2050 (as India and China have done) harvest the gas and oil fields, which are now economic to do given the market prices, and flood the market with what we have. Or alternatively, behave like OPEC and maximise the return.
Reply
#14
(03-24-2022, 11:41 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 09:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The tax 'cut' in 2024 will come after 4 years of fiscal drag. lt's dishonest and meaningless.

The rise in NI threshold is to be welcomed, but NI should also apply earning pensioners. This just adds to the massive intergenerational unfairness (particularly hammering those paying student 'debt' whilst in lower paid work)

I agree on the NI application to pensioners. I never understood why they were exempt.

Inflation is a big worry. This will lead to interest rate rises, and impact on all with a mortgage (which isn't the Tory grandees). Then follows house price inflation, and takes first homes away from most struggling to take a step on the housing ladder.

We have the solutions. There is oil and gas in Scotland (which the SNP are now trying to politicise). It is radical, but we do not have to be bound by market prices when the solution is in our own back yard.

When the inevitable interest rate rises come, doesn’t that lead to a likely drop in house prices as people can’t afford to move up the ladder and supply outstrips demand? I thought it was the low rates which was pushing house prices up and up? Or am I misunderstanding? (I’m certainly no expert on this).
Reply
#15
(03-24-2022, 11:41 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote: I agree on the NI application to pensioners. I never understood why they were exempt.

It's because they've "worked all their lives" and are therefore entitled. I wish I had a grand for every time I've heard the bit in quotes.

It's possibly because, as a demographic, they vote in big numbers; I wouldn't know.
Reply
#16
(03-24-2022, 11:55 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 11:45 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 11:41 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 09:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The tax 'cut' in 2024 will come after 4 years of fiscal drag. lt's dishonest and meaningless.

The rise in NI threshold is to be welcomed, but NI should also apply earning pensioners. This just adds to the massive intergenerational unfairness (particularly hammering those paying student 'debt' whilst in lower paid work)

I agree on the NI application to pensioners. I never understood why they were exempt.

Inflation is a big worry. This will lead to interest rate rises, and impact on all with a mortgage (which isn't the Tory grandees). Then follows house price inflation, and takes first homes away from most struggling to take a step on the housing ladder.

We have the solutions. There is oil and gas in Scotland (which the SNP are now trying to politicise). It is radical, but we do not have to be bound by market prices when the solution is in our own back yard.

We try and close off our gas from the market and we're quickly shut out of global gas markets, we do not have the throughout to supply on domestic gas production and are fucked if we lose out on Norwegian North Sea gas, that's ignoring the problems with crude.

Just simply "pause" the carbon neutral argument by 2050 (as India and China have done) harvest the gas and oil fields, which are now economic to do given the market prices, and flood the market with what we have. Or alternatively, behave like OPEC and maximise the return.

And exasperate the issue of energy security for the West by decoupling from imports and simultaneously allow the climate change issue to continue snowballing? Climate change isn't going away, we can't pause it. Even China is investing heavily in nuclear, renewables and energy storage to transition away from fossil fuels, with energy security being pushed as the justification. I also would like to reiterate, decoupling our price of gas from the global market will screw us over regarding North Sea gas supply from Norway, we won't ever have the throughout from gas fields in our EEZ to cover usage.


Then there's the fact that CCGT prices are so insane at the moment the LCOE for them is currently higher than nuclear. The economic solution would be to relax planning restrictions for onshore wind.

What we need to do is build nuclear to the point where it covers 20GWe output minimum and blend the grid with renewables. Complete energy independence without the risk of global meltdown posed by coal and gas. Extract as much gas from the North Sea as possible up to 2030, sure, but not decouple ourselves from the West over it.
Reply
#17
(03-24-2022, 12:14 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 11:55 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 11:45 AM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 11:41 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 09:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The tax 'cut' in 2024 will come after 4 years of fiscal drag. lt's dishonest and meaningless.

The rise in NI threshold is to be welcomed, but NI should also apply earning pensioners. This just adds to the massive intergenerational unfairness (particularly hammering those paying student 'debt' whilst in lower paid work)

I agree on the NI application to pensioners. I never understood why they were exempt.

Inflation is a big worry. This will lead to interest rate rises, and impact on all with a mortgage (which isn't the Tory grandees). Then follows house price inflation, and takes first homes away from most struggling to take a step on the housing ladder.

We have the solutions. There is oil and gas in Scotland (which the SNP are now trying to politicise). It is radical, but we do not have to be bound by market prices when the solution is in our own back yard.

We try and close off our gas from the market and we're quickly shut out of global gas markets, we do not have the throughout to supply on domestic gas production and are fucked if we lose out on Norwegian North Sea gas, that's ignoring the problems with crude.

Just simply "pause" the carbon neutral argument by 2050 (as India and China have done) harvest the gas and oil fields, which are now economic to do given the market prices, and flood the market with what we have. Or alternatively, behave like OPEC and maximise the return.

And exasperate the issue of energy security for the West by decoupling from imports and simultaneously allow the climate change issue to continue snowballing? Climate change isn't going away, we can't pause it. Even China is investing heavily in nuclear, renewables and energy storage to transition away from fossil fuels, with energy security being pushed as the justification. I also would like to reiterate, decoupling our price of gas from the global market will screw us over regarding North Sea gas supply from Norway, we won't ever have the throughout from gas fields in our EEZ to cover usage.


Then there's the fact that CCGT prices are so insane at the moment the LCOE for them is currently higher than nuclear. The economic solution would be to relax planning restrictions for onshore wind.

What we need to do is build nuclear to the point where it covers 20GWe output minimum and blend the grid with renewables. Complete energy independence without the risk of global meltdown posed by coal and gas. Extract as much gas from the North Sea as possible up to 2030, sure, but not decouple ourselves from the West over it.

Agree.

(03-24-2022, 11:55 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 11:41 AM)Kit Kat Chunky Wrote:
(03-24-2022, 09:53 AM)Protheroe Wrote: The tax 'cut' in 2024 will come after 4 years of fiscal drag. lt's dishonest and meaningless.

The rise in NI threshold is to be welcomed, but NI should also apply earning pensioners. This just adds to the massive intergenerational unfairness (particularly hammering those paying student 'debt' whilst in lower paid work)

I agree on the NI application to pensioners. I never understood why they were exempt.

Inflation is a big worry. This will lead to interest rate rises, and impact on all with a mortgage (which isn't the Tory grandees). Then follows house price inflation, and takes first homes away from most struggling to take a step on the housing ladder.

We have the solutions. There is oil and gas in Scotland (which the SNP are now trying to politicise). It is radical, but we do not have to be bound by market prices when the solution is in our own back yard.

When the inevitable interest rate rises come, doesn’t that lead to a likely drop in house prices as people can’t afford to move up the ladder and supply outstrips demand? I thought it was the low rates which was pushing house prices up and up? Or am I misunderstanding? (I’m certainly no expert on this).

High inflation means high wage rises. This enhances affordability of mortgages (doesn't help with finding the deposit though, which is the big obstacle for first time buyers). High inflation has historically been linked with high rises in house prices.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)