Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
(03-23-2022, 09:28 AM)Sliced Wrote: Oh God we're here again.
So we were top of the league playing this system in the under 23s and in the playoffs playing this system in the first team. Now we're getting pumped in the under 23s and are what....12th with the first team? But there's still absolutely no merit whatsoever in the manager or the system. When we were winning it was what? luck?
Also if you exclude the best 90% of his managerial career then his record isn't very good. Yeah ok....
Come off it Slice, not one first team player improved under Val, and by the time he left we were on a horrendous run of form. Just because we were 5th completely ignored what was happening at the time. It’s like saying we weren’t in the relegation places when Pulis or Irvine were asked to leave, we all know the direction of travel was and it wasn’t to anywhere nice.
As for the U23s, if we are trying to produce / coach players to be the best they can be for the first team / selling, training them in a formulaic system just to get results isn’t necessarily the way forward, particularly when at first team level the same tactics arguably saw a dip in almost every players form.
No one knows if we would be faring better at any level if Val was still at the club abs tbh it’s a moot point anyway.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(03-23-2022, 09:46 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-23-2022, 09:28 AM)Sliced Wrote: Oh God we're here again.
So we were top of the league playing this system in the under 23s and in the playoffs playing this system in the first team. Now we're getting pumped in the under 23s and are what....12th with the first team? But there's still absolutely no merit whatsoever in the manager or the system. When we were winning it was what? luck?
Also if you exclude the best 90% of his managerial career then his record isn't very good. Yeah ok....
Come off it Slice, not one first team player improved under Val, and by the time he left we were on a horrendous run of form. Just because we were 5th completely ignored what was happening at the time. It’s like saying we weren’t in the relegation places when Pulis or Irvine were asked to leave, we all know the direction of travel was and it wasn’t to anywhere nice.
As for the U23s, if we are trying to produce / coach players to be the best they can be for the first team / selling, training them in a formulaic system just to get results isn’t necessarily the way forward, particularly when at first team level the same tactics arguably saw a dip in almost every players form.
No one knows if we would be faring better at any level if Val was still at the club abs tbh it’s a moot point anyway.
Oh my God why are we still doing this?!
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(03-23-2022, 09:46 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (03-23-2022, 09:28 AM)Sliced Wrote: Oh God we're here again.
So we were top of the league playing this system in the under 23s and in the playoffs playing this system in the first team. Now we're getting pumped in the under 23s and are what....12th with the first team? But there's still absolutely no merit whatsoever in the manager or the system. When we were winning it was what? luck?
Also if you exclude the best 90% of his managerial career then his record isn't very good. Yeah ok....
Come off it Slice, not one first team player improved under Val, and by the time he left we were on a horrendous run of form. Just because we were 5th completely ignored what was happening at the time. It’s like saying we weren’t in the relegation places when Pulis or Irvine were asked to leave, we all know the direction of travel was and it wasn’t to anywhere nice.
As for the U23s, if we are trying to produce / coach players to be the best they can be for the first team / selling, training them in a formulaic system just to get results isn’t necessarily the way forward, particularly when at first team level the same tactics arguably saw a dip in almost every players form.
No one knows if we would be faring better at any level if Val was still at the club abs tbh it’s a moot point anyway.
In general, I don't disagree. However, our squad is wafer thin. This is not a debate on quality, but you'd have to agree that it's thin. Look at our bench in the last game in terms of options. The reason we were playing the same formation and style of football in the under 23s was presumably so that if we needed to use a youngster they would already be completely aware of the system. And it clearly worked to some extent because TGH came in and hit the ground running.
We're not Chelsea, we don't have a massive squad and, lets face it, most of our talents get poached anyway. We may as well try and get the youngsters to a place where they can more comfortably contribute to the first team if needed.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(03-23-2022, 08:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The U23s is about developing players that can play in the first team and I would have thought the ambition is at Prem level for a club such as ours. It’s not finding a formula for winning a meaningless competition under the mantra of continuity into the first team. If we slavishly ask players to play in what was a very particular style is that really developing a players all round ability?
All successful academy clubs have a set style of play throughout that matches the first team.
Posts: 239
Threads: 40
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation:
0
Is Derek an idiot
Successful Clubs have a policy of having a brand of football throughout the club Senior, U23, U18 and further down
Posts: 3,808
Threads: 49
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
3
(03-23-2022, 10:17 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: Is Derek an idiot
Successful Clubs have a policy of having a brand of football throughout the club Senior, U23, U18 and further down
Can only add that my nephew, a massive Baggies fan, ( me and our kid saw to that !) was a youth team player at Crewe in the 90`s, their first team had Savage, Danny Murphy, Dele Adebola etc. He would play on a Sunday for the Under 15s or whatever, said the coach insisted that all age group sides played the same way as the first team. Dario Gradi, yes, I know, it`s since come to light about abuse by some staff there, used to give up Sundays to check up on how the teams were doing.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
The point was, if we are choosing a style of football that runs throughout the club for years, then that should ensure that the style makes young players better, not simply get better results in a meaningless competition.
I don’t believe Val’s style of football was an ideal style to do that. It didn’t improve one player at first team level and results at U23 should be secondary to improving players.
Posts: 13,261
Threads: 468
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
45
(03-23-2022, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The point was, if we are choosing a style of football that runs throughout the club for years, then that should ensure that the style makes young players better, not simply get better results in a meaningless competition.
I don’t believe Val’s style of football was an ideal style to do that. It didn’t improve one player at first team level and results at U23 should be secondary to improving players.
This isn't true either. Furlong, Grant, Kipre all improved. TGH's step up this season into the first team has been incredible. Arguably Robinson improved too given that he and Grant had the highest combined number of assists/goals in the league. Until this season most were convinced Grant wasn't a footballer.
We aren't the Man City of the championship with amazing players that are going to boss the league.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
03-23-2022, 11:22 AM
(This post was last modified: 03-23-2022, 11:23 AM by Birdman1811.)
(03-23-2022, 11:06 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The point was, if we are choosing a style of football that runs throughout the club for years, then that should ensure that the style makes young players better, not simply get better results in a meaningless competition.
I don’t believe Val’s style of football was an ideal style to do that. It didn’t improve one player at first team level and results at U23 should be secondary to improving players.
It certainly seemed to improve the u23's.
They were still getting a well rounded coaching schedule, it's key to keeping academy status, but they learnt the positions needed to play in the first team.
As far as not improving any first team players, I beg to differ. When the while squad buy in was there, early. Grant, O'Shea, Furlong and Townsend all improved, it was when he tried to modify things to counter other teams countering us it fell apart. Even Johnstone added being a sweeping keeper to his game well, something that impressed Southgate.
I've said before, Val made a couple of big, and chronic mistakes. First off was modifying the style rather than formation, dropping a forward and adding a midfielder would have helped a lot. Would have stopped teams overwhelming us in the middle then, and as we've seen, paired together, Grant and Robinson are a capable partnership.
Second big mistake was his fall out with Johnstone, that turned the squad against him, and the rest is history.
There is nothing wrong essentially with his style and ideals, they make sense when looking to play above resources available, however his implementation and man management here fell short.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(03-23-2022, 09:14 AM)Cuzer Wrote: (03-23-2022, 08:42 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (03-23-2022, 01:39 AM)Cuzer Wrote: (03-22-2022, 04:14 PM)baggie_ray Wrote: (03-22-2022, 12:53 PM)Cuzer Wrote: Any comment on how Val's system would work against superior opposition,for example WBA in the Prem
Just have a look at how his Barnsley side faired against Chelsea last season
Cuzer
Lost 6-0 and 1-0
Arf
I was alluding to the 1-0 when Chelsea struggled to get out of their half due to Barnsley intensity, remember watching that thinking how good Barnsley looked
Cuzer
Remind me how we did under Bilic and BFS against Chelsea in a normal Premiership encounter.... now compare that to how Barnsley did in the cup.... Cuzer, your logic is flawed beyond belief there lad!
Behave, it's to do with a plan for the season, not a one off game
Look, Ismail got thie four year gig based on how we would fare in the Premiership as underdogs against the bigger sides, could we have our own identity and play to our strengths to make a fist of stopping up, the board, wrongly, thought promotion without investment would be a walk in the park this season and the eyes were all on next season in the promised land
Both Val and Bruce have shown the walk in the park for promotion it's certainly not, I still feel and will continue to feel long term we would have been better served having some bloody patience, clearly Bruce hasn't been the answer and Val was getting more out of the players than he probably was warranted to do
Cuzer
(03-23-2022, 08:51 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: The U23s is about developing players that can play in the first team and I would have thought the ambition is at Prem level for a club such as ours. It’s not finding a formula for winning a meaningless competition under the mantra of continuity into the first team. If we slavishly ask players to play in what was a very particular style is that really developing a players all round ability?
So not having one system running through a football club is wrong? Please, when you put your faith in a manager for four years and then pull the plug after 7 months the knock on effect is huge, as we're seeing in the U18's and U23's performances
Back the horse or get off it, we got off and now we've lost our fucking saddle at the same time
Cuzer
If it's not about a one off game then why did you bring in a one off (even more so than league games) to try and back up your point?? Eh?? FA Cup games are never a good guide to how well teams will do if they get promoted. My response was a more direct comparison of how we did against the same team that you're suggesting that Barnsley did well against... only we did ten times better than Barnsley did....
|