Sam J
#71
(03-14-2022, 10:59 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 10:56 AM)Sliced Wrote: I wouldn't say he's a crap keeper, but he is massively overrated by our fanbase now, as he was underrated initially.

A good shot stopper but thats where it ends

Even his shot stopping is suspect at the moment though too, as evidenced on Friday.

As for not criticising because they're our players, does that extend to Zohore?

That's true. Even that has gone.

And no, it definitely doesn't extend to Zohore, or Livermore, or Reach.
Reply
#72
Thing is with Johnstone, he seems to really lack likeability.

He has been a very good keeper, but on the back of Foster he's had another fine pair of size 12s to fill.

Johnstone wears a miserable demeanour generally and just has never engaged well with the fans. I can imagine rubbing shoulders with the elite at Englands HQ can't have helped, as we've fallen so far as a club from the Albion of a few years ago.

He had a shocker on Friday and Bruce needs to sit him down and see where his head is at. His face wears: "What the fuck am I doing at this tin pot outfit" written in magic marker.

When he goes I shall watch his career with interest like any ex Albion, but I doubt he'll get much of a welcome back when he returns to the Hawthorns, that is a big if though unless we get back.
Reply
#73
(03-14-2022, 10:52 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 10:08 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 09:52 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-13-2022, 10:21 AM)wba13 Wrote: I’m not saying anyone isn’t a fan of the club, what I’m saying is the hatred in how you chose to say it. Johnstone is Wba player and he deserves more respect than being swore at.


Nixon of the sun Is saying the deal for Johnstone is a long way down the road, but nothing signed yet. Well nothing can be signed with a team in this country until 1 month before contract runs out. But if this is true could this be the reason of Sam’s loss of form as his head is elsewhere. 
I’ve no idea if true but ???
Why does he deserve respect? He didn't show any to you or I when he refused to play and then, very publicly, celebrated Preston's goal. Like I've said many times, I owe him nothing.

You telling me I know nothing about football was far more disrespectful, but, hey I'll take it on the chin. After watching Albion for 44 years, you may well be right.

As for the swearing, this is an adult forum and swearing is common place, as it is in everyday life.
Well I won’t change my mind about you knowing nothing about football, if you cannot see that Johnstone is an excellent goalkeeper, you must think that all the coaches and managers who also pick are also as you put it fucking useless as he has played for England.  Yes I agree he should not have thrown a hissy fit when being left out , but that still does make him a crap keeper. Also yes I would now leave him out and look to the future but in my eyes he is a top keeper.

If the fact that a coach picks a player means he's beyond criticism, then we may as well close the forum down ffs.
I can, however, forgive shit performances, and have done many times with regards Johnstone. What I won't accept, however, is his disrespect for our club.

You, on the other hand, seem to be horrified that a player, with no real passion or commitment to the club, who has shown public disdain and cannot wait to get out of the door, is being "disrespected", yet deem it ok to disrespect a fellow fan with 40 odd years of blood, sweat and tears invested in the Baggies. Strange attitude.

This is my last say on this subject with you Bob as we will always disagree, all I hear is you dislike Sam with a passion, that’s your choice and all I keep hearing is your 40 odd years well I top that and some. I don’t disrespect you as I don’t know you but I cannot and never will know why you have such hatred for a player. Do you hate Foster also.
Reply
#74
(03-14-2022, 11:14 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote: Thing is with Johnstone, he seems to really lack likeability.

He has been a very good keeper, but on the back of Foster he's had another fine pair of size 12s to fill.

Johnstone wears a miserable demeanour generally and just has never engaged well with the fans. I can imagine rubbing shoulders with the elite at Englands HQ can't have helped, as we've fallen so far as a club from the Albion of a few years ago.

He had a shocker on Friday and Bruce needs to sit him down and see where his head is at. His face wears: "What the fuck am I doing at this tin pot outfit" written in magic marker.

When he goes I shall watch his career with interest like any ex Albion, but I doubt he'll get much of a welcome back when he returns to the Hawthorns, that is a big if though unless we get back.

Think he's still got the smell of fish in his nostrils that's why he looks like that. A constipated rabbit in the headlights was my thought on Friday.
Reply
#75
(03-14-2022, 11:23 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 10:52 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 10:08 AM)wba13 Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 09:52 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote:
(03-13-2022, 10:21 AM)wba13 Wrote: I’m not saying anyone isn’t a fan of the club, what I’m saying is the hatred in how you chose to say it. Johnstone is Wba player and he deserves more respect than being swore at.


Nixon of the sun Is saying the deal for Johnstone is a long way down the road, but nothing signed yet. Well nothing can be signed with a team in this country until 1 month before contract runs out. But if this is true could this be the reason of Sam’s loss of form as his head is elsewhere. 
I’ve no idea if true but ???
Why does he deserve respect? He didn't show any to you or I when he refused to play and then, very publicly, celebrated Preston's goal. Like I've said many times, I owe him nothing.

You telling me I know nothing about football was far more disrespectful, but, hey I'll take it on the chin. After watching Albion for 44 years, you may well be right.

As for the swearing, this is an adult forum and swearing is common place, as it is in everyday life.
Well I won’t change my mind about you knowing nothing about football, if you cannot see that Johnstone is an excellent goalkeeper, you must think that all the coaches and managers who also pick are also as you put it fucking useless as he has played for England.  Yes I agree he should not have thrown a hissy fit when being left out , but that still does make him a crap keeper. Also yes I would now leave him out and look to the future but in my eyes he is a top keeper.

If the fact that a coach picks a player means he's beyond criticism, then we may as well close the forum down ffs.
I can, however, forgive shit performances, and have done many times with regards Johnstone. What I won't accept, however, is his disrespect for our club.

You, on the other hand, seem to be horrified that a player, with no real passion or commitment to the club, who has shown public disdain and cannot wait to get out of the door, is being "disrespected", yet deem it ok to disrespect a fellow fan with 40 odd years of blood, sweat and tears invested in the Baggies. Strange attitude.

This is my last say on this subject with you Bob as we will always disagree, all I hear is you dislike Sam with a passion, that’s your choice and all I keep hearing is your 40 odd years well I top that and some. I don’t disrespect you as I don’t know you but I cannot and never will know why you have such hatred for a player. Do you hate Foster also.
So "well, well, well what a fan you are" or claiming that I know nothing about football, on more than one occasion, is not disrespectful?

The reference to 40 odd years is not a reference to you, in fact I've said nothing personal against you throughout this exchange, I'm just making the point that my commitment to the club is long-standing and continuous, whereas Johnstone's will be fleeting, at best, yet you think he deserves more respect than I do when it comes to matters of our club.

Foster never publicly celebrated an opposition goal whilst he was employed by the club, as far as I am aware.
Reply
#76
(03-14-2022, 11:36 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: So "well, well, well what a fan you are" or claiming that I know nothing about football, on more than one occasion, is not disrespectful?

The reference to 40 odd years is not a reference to you, in fact I've said nothing personal against you throughout this exchange, I'm just making the point that my commitment to the club is long-standing and continuous, whereas Johnstone's will be fleeting, at best, yet you think he deserves more respect than I do when it comes to matters of our club.

Foster never publicly celebrated an opposition goal whilst he was employed by the club, as far as I am aware.
Off topic, but you don't really exist on here unless you're told your opinion is invalid, and /or facts are incorrect, have they told you football isn't really for you yet? Big Grin grab the salt cellar and take a large pinch of it fella.
Reply
#77
(03-14-2022, 11:38 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 11:36 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: So "well, well, well what a fan you are" or claiming that I know nothing about football, on more than one occasion, is not disrespectful?

The reference to 40 odd years is not a reference to you, in fact I've said nothing personal against you throughout this exchange, I'm just making the point that my commitment to the club is long-standing and continuous, whereas Johnstone's will be fleeting, at best, yet you think he deserves more respect than I do when it comes to matters of our club.

Foster never publicly celebrated an opposition goal whilst he was employed by the club, as far as I am aware.
Off topic, but you don't really exist on here unless you're told your opinion is invalid, and /or facts are incorrect, have they told you football isn't really for you yet? Big Grin grab the salt cellar and take a large pinch of it fella.

No but Foster Went on strike and he’s my all time favourite Baggies keeper.
Reply
#78
To be fair wba13, you don’t tend to handle any criticism of any aspect of the club particularly well.
Reply
#79
(03-14-2022, 10:42 AM)wba13 Wrote: Well unlike some when he leaves he goes with my best wishes.
Yes I would now leave him out but I don’t think Bruce will.

Bruce needs to focus his mind on doing well for us will mean he stays part of the England scene, that should be his incentive.  

He got caught in two minds the other night, mistakes happen.
Reply
#80
(03-14-2022, 11:53 AM)Duffers Wrote: To be fair wba13, you don’t tend to handle any criticism of any aspect of the club particularly well.

True I don’t, but my biggest concern is the hatred of some of our players, that very few of us know.big example Livermore gets untold abuse, yet I have never since he’s been here seen him give more than 100%. The only manager who hasn’t played him was Allardyce and he happened to bring in Maitland Niles and Yokoslu. Now all of a sudden we have to play Livermore because without him we’re worse.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: