Should they stay or should they go
#1
List of players who in an Ideal world would you keep or not 


Goalkeepers

Johnstone - Wants to go & out of Contract
Button - Keep would be handy as keeper next season IMO
Palmer - A good back up keep him 

Left Back

Townsend - Poor this year, But we not going to get much for him so keep him
Reach - Release him

Right Back

Furlong - Has been poor for months, Bin him

Centre Backs

Kipre - Out of favour, We should get a decent price for him. Bin Him
Bartley - Over the hill lets cut our losses and bin him
Clarke - Wouldn't sign him again we need to move on from that
Ajayi - Clumsy on the ball, Would hope that Norwich are keen Bin Him
O'Shea - Make him Captain (Keep him)
Bryan - Injury prone so release him 

Midfield

Livermore - Thanks for the service, But get him Binned
Sawyers - Stoke should come with any offer and its enough Bin him
Moloumby  I would sign him like what been rumoured in the press
Mowatt - Keep as a squad Player
Phillips- Get him out, Over the hill 
Gardner-Hickman -  Obviously keep him 


Forwards

Robinson - Offers nothing- Get him binned
Grant - I would keep, Top Scorer
Carroll - Would offer him a new contract
Diagnana - Wants to leave and we should not stop him....Bin Him
Dyke - Keep him obviously

So in conclusion, We need a massive revamp & you can see the squad in not balanced 

Button, Palmer, O'Shea, Townsend, Moloumby, Mowatt, Taylor-Hickman, Carroll, Grant & Dyke  Plus Castro, Tulloch, Taylor, Ashworth etc 

We would need 8-9 players in the summer, its what's needed really
Reply
#2
But who is going to take these players off us, i am afraid we will be stuck with the majority of them come August
Reply
#3
Fuck’em all off.
Reply
#4
Keepers
Johnstone will go. If Palmer or Griffiths have anything about them I'd like to see one of them claim the #1 shirt for next season.

Defenders
I would sign Clarke if offered the chance. Left footed and has been one of our better defenders this season, the first season (until recently) in a while where we've looked solid at the back. We wont lose Bartley but I would sell Ajayi if someone offered the cash. O'Shea agree would make a good captain and I'm struggling to see why he's not in the team. I would also look to keep Kipre who had done nothing to deserve being dropped either. Furlong and Townsend will both stay, but I would like to see us sign reinforcements in both positions or the promotion of Ingram from the U23s if he's ready.

Midfield
Is a mess. Livermore and Mowatt will definitely stay. Sawyers I'd love to think we can still get a tune out of him but I think it might be best for all if he were to move on. Molumby I would sign for the reported fee as it's just nice to have a midfielder who can run. The big hope here is TGH, and the big worry is that Bruce decides he's a wing back. A couple of additions definitely needed. I've still no idea whether Castro is a footballer, let alone whether he's any good. Can't be asking too much from him at this stage.

Forwards
Despite playing about 80 minutes for us Dike is the big hope. Carroll has shown enough to deserve a new deal and some minutes off the bench. Grant scores all our goals but I can never quite tell if having him in the team makes us better or worse, which is weird considering we'd be fucked without his goals. Robinson and Diangana go into the Sawyers bracket for me, I'd like to see them turn it around but I think their ship has sailed. Is Cleary good enough? Ironically, having started the season with no strikers and loads of wingers, if we could resign Carroll and move on Diangana and Robinson it would be wingers we need.

Biggest change for me would/should be in the dugout.
Reply
#5
(03-14-2022, 09:02 AM)Noibla Wrote: But who is going to take these players off us, i am afraid we will be stuck with the majority of them come August

Spot on.  We’d be virtually giving these players away to get rid of them, and having to pay off their contracts.  The financial ramifications are enormous. 

SJ is obviously going.  Apart from Bartley and Clarke (end of loan) I wouldn’t get rid of any of our defence.  That’s not where the problems lie and it’s perfectly adequate for this division.  I’d want a better RB than Furlong though - ideally one who can cross a ball. 

Midfield is the big issue.  Reach must go. Two more CMs needed for sure. Phillips I can’t make up my kind about, but ideally we need an upgrade, so look to sell him too. 

Robinson should be sold, and we should test the water re Diangana but I think we’d have to take a massive loss.   Sign Carroll. Pay off Zahore.
Reply
#6
(03-14-2022, 09:31 AM)Pragmatist Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 09:02 AM)Noibla Wrote: But who is going to take these players off us, i am afraid we will be stuck with the majority of them come August

Spot on.  We’d be virtually giving these players away to get rid of them, and having to pay off their contracts.  The financial ramifications are enormous. 

SJ is obviously going.  Apart from Bartley and Clarke (end of loan) I wouldn’t get rid of any of our defence.  That’s not where the problems lie and it’s perfectly adequate for this division.  I’d want a better RB than Furlong though - ideally one who can cross a ball. 

Midfield is the big issue.  Reach must go. Two more CMs needed for sure. Phillips I can’t make up my kind about, but ideally we need an upgrade, so look to sell him too. 

Robinson should be sold, and we should test the water re Diangana but I think we’d have to take a massive loss.   Sign Carroll. Pay off Zahore.

It's not an ideal world, so it's a pointless exercise. Reach is left-back/left-side cover - despite my doubts about Ajayi and Bartley we probably only need cover or replacement for Furlong in the back line (FWIW I don't think TGH is much good at full back and has much more to offer elsewhere on the park). Wouldn't sign Clarke.

Midfield is the huge problem. Two centre midfielders needed at least. Bruce needs to grow a pair and drop Livermore. Mowatt isn't the future at this level. We're probably OK for wide options if we can win the ball in the middle (for a change) and use it well.

Offer Carroll a contract and get Dike fit. If that means Robinson has to go, so be it. Get Zohore off the books, whatever it takes. Unbelievable situation with him.
Reply
#7
(03-14-2022, 09:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: Fuck’em all off.

Utter tripe.

I have no words for your clear use of profanities towards human beings?
Reply
#8
(03-14-2022, 09:56 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 09:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: Fuck’em all off.

Utter tripe.

I have no words for your clear use of profanities towards human beings?

Starts timer on you being called a cunt.
Reply
#9
(03-14-2022, 09:56 AM)Super_Slav Wrote:
(03-14-2022, 09:05 AM)Duffers Wrote: Fuck’em all off.

Utter tripe.

I have no words for your clear use of profanities towards human beings?

Someone didn’t get much attention over the weekend.
Reply
#10
(03-14-2022, 08:55 AM)BoingBoing2022 Wrote: List of players who in an Ideal world would you keep or not 


Goalkeepers

Johnstone - Wants to go & out of Contract
Button - Keep would be handy as keeper next season IMO
Palmer - A good back up keep him 

Left Back

Townsend - Poor this year, But we not going to get much for him so keep him
Reach - Release him

Right Back

Furlong - Has been poor for months, Bin him

Centre Backs

Kipre - Out of favour, We should get a decent price for him. Bin Him
Bartley - Over the hill lets cut our losses and bin him
Clarke - Wouldn't sign him again we need to move on from that
Ajayi - Clumsy on the ball, Would hope that Norwich are keen Bin Him
O'Shea - Make him Captain (Keep him)
Bryan - Injury prone so release him 

Midfield

Livermore - Thanks for the service, But get him Binned
Sawyers - Stoke should come with any offer and its enough Bin him
Moloumby  I would sign him like what been rumoured in the press
Mowatt - Keep as a squad Player
Phillips- Get him out, Over the hill 
Gardner-Hickman -  Obviously keep him 


Forwards

Robinson - Offers nothing- Get him binned
Grant - I would keep, Top Scorer
Carroll - Would offer him a new contract
Diagnana - Wants to leave and we should not stop him....Bin Him
Dyke - Keep him obviously

So in conclusion, We need a massive revamp & you can see the squad in not balanced 

Button, Palmer, O'Shea, Townsend, Moloumby, Mowatt, Taylor-Hickman, Carroll, Grant & Dyke  Plus Castro, Tulloch, Taylor, Ashworth etc 

We would need 8-9 players in the summer, its what's needed really

It's DIKE.  We are not going to get rid of 13 players some of whom have two years left on a lucrative contract.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: