Russian attack !
Whichever way it goes Putin cannot go out of this without a 'win'. If that is to have international recognition of the Crimea and the two eastern Ukraine states as Russian then that would be job done for him I reckon. The problem being how to protect Ukraine going forward, Putin won't accept Ukraine having the opportunity to join NATO so that would be a red line for him, maybe there should be part of the agreement whereby Russian reparations are paid in exchange for Ukraine not joining NATO but having a hybrid status with training and munitions being made available.
Reply
(03-07-2022, 05:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Whichever way it goes Putin cannot go out of this without a 'win'. If that is to have international recognition of the Crimea and the two eastern Ukraine states as Russian then that would be job done for him I reckon. The problem being how to protect Ukraine going forward, Putin won't accept Ukraine having the opportunity to join NATO so that would be a red line for him, maybe there should be part of the agreement whereby Russian reparations are paid in exchange for Ukraine not joining NATO but having a hybrid status with training and munitions being made available.

That would be a "for now" situation.  Putin only wins if he is indulged.  If (a) the West weans itself off Russian oil and oligarchs' stables are cleaned out (yes, YOU Boris and co) and Russian Duma members' and poliitical functionaries' lucre and western travel etc curbed, (b) the interference by Russia via hacking, troll farms on social media etc is blocked and we could get a regime change that re-sets a lot of things. We have been at war with Russia for twenty years and we will still be at war if (hopefully when) the "hot war" stops in Ukraine.
Reply
hudds Wrote:
baggy1 Wrote:Whichever way it goes Putin cannot go out of this without a 'win'. If that is to have international recognition of the Crimea and the two eastern Ukraine states as Russian then that would be job done for him I reckon. The problem being how to protect Ukraine going forward, Putin won't accept Ukraine having the opportunity to join NATO so that would be a red line for him, maybe there should be part of the agreement whereby Russian reparations are paid in exchange for Ukraine not joining NATO but having a hybrid status with training and munitions being made available.

That would be a "for now" situation.  Putin only wins if he is indulged.  If the West weans itself off Russian oil and oligarchs' stables are cleaned out (yes, YOU Boris and co) and Russian Duma members' and poliitical functionaries' lucre and western travel etc curbed, we could get a regime change that re-sets a lot of things.
Yes, a regime change forced by sanctions would be a reasonable outcome for the rest of the world. But for now, surely we should be doing all we can to arm Ukraine to the hilt. No one would deny the Ukrainian spirit appears stronger than the confused and low paid Russian army, let's give them the weapons to protect their homes. As for Russia not accepting Ukraine's desire to join NATO or the EU, what right do they have to interfere?
Reply
Agree with both of those but the problem will be if the conflict continues then Russia will just shell the cities to rubble and occupy more and more territory. They might not have the spirit of the Ukrainians but they have the numbers to keep just throwing bodies at it until they win by having more men. There is no way Ukraine will chase Russia out of the country now, and they are unlikely to even push them back. 

They need to be looking at sort term wins now. Eventually they could play Putin at his own game and slowly become that embedded with Ukraine they are effectively a part of NATO in all but name.
Reply
(03-07-2022, 05:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Whichever way it goes Putin cannot go out of this without a 'win'. If that is to have international recognition of the Crimea and the two eastern Ukraine states as Russian then that would be job done for him I reckon. The problem being how to protect Ukraine going forward, Putin won't accept Ukraine having the opportunity to join NATO so that would be a red line for him, maybe there should be part of the agreement whereby Russian reparations are paid in exchange for Ukraine not joining NATO but having a hybrid status with training and munitions being made available.

Any kind of win for Russia would just embolden Putin (and maybe other countries) to do it again in the future. Therefore, I think it's imperative that it doesn't happen.

Also, the deliberate killing of civilians shouldn't be rewarded in any way.
Reply
(03-07-2022, 06:22 PM)Tom Joad Wrote:
hudds Wrote:
baggy1 Wrote:Whichever way it goes Putin cannot go out of this without a 'win'. If that is to have international recognition of the Crimea and the two eastern Ukraine states as Russian then that would be job done for him I reckon. The problem being how to protect Ukraine going forward, Putin won't accept Ukraine having the opportunity to join NATO so that would be a red line for him, maybe there should be part of the agreement whereby Russian reparations are paid in exchange for Ukraine not joining NATO but having a hybrid status with training and munitions being made available.

That would be a "for now" situation.  Putin only wins if he is indulged.  If the West weans itself off Russian oil and oligarchs' stables are cleaned out (yes, YOU Boris and co) and Russian Duma members' and poliitical functionaries' lucre and western travel etc curbed, we could get a regime change that re-sets a lot of things.
Yes, a regime change forced by sanctions would be a reasonable outcome for the rest of the world. But for now, surely we should be doing all we can to arm Ukraine to the hilt. No one would deny the Ukrainian spirit appears stronger than the confused and low paid Russian army, let's give them the weapons to protect their homes. As for Russia not accepting Ukraine's desire to join NATO or the EU, what right do they have to interfere?
They don't have any right to interfere at all but realpolitik prior to the Russion invasion meant NATO membership although theoretically an option was a non-starter.   It probably always will be for Putin.  If so, the point I think is how much suffering can be endured by the Ukraine civilian population whilst supporting the armed forces/irregulars but also to extricate the Russians out of Putin's mess to prevent escalation across Europe?

(03-07-2022, 06:31 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 05:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Whichever way it goes Putin cannot go out of this without a 'win'. If that is to have international recognition of the Crimea and the two eastern Ukraine states as Russian then that would be job done for him I reckon. The problem being how to protect Ukraine going forward, Putin won't accept Ukraine having the opportunity to join NATO so that would be a red line for him, maybe there should be part of the agreement whereby Russian reparations are paid in exchange for Ukraine not joining NATO but having a hybrid status with training and munitions being made available.

Any kind of win for Russia would just embolden Putin (and maybe other countries) to do it again in the future. Therefore, I think it's imperative that it doesn't happen.

Also, the deliberate killing of civilians shouldn't be rewarded in any way.
He doesn't win of we carry on the war economically and culturally etc and the regime crumbles.  Whatever, that must be the policy of the West.
Reply
The realpolitik has changed though, even 2014 pales in comparison to the last few months. Russia is now a direct threat to Ukraine's sovereignty and as such efforts need to be made to protect Ukrainian sovereignty, Russia being as aggressive as they've been is what has turned the rhetoric in Ukraine against their foreign policy aims. It's easier to pander to a loud nuisance than a direct threat.

Putin's put the theoretical nonstarter into a serious possibility to deter further action, and the best means to do that is supranational organisations like NATO and the EU. Let's not forget the whole of Europe, through people and goods, is affected by a destabilised Ukraine and will want to minimise that.

We started a war to stop a war happening

Jesus wept, surely the person writing that bullshit isn't stupid enough to believe it, surely.
Reply
(03-07-2022, 06:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The realpolitik has changed though, even 2014 pales in comparison to the last few months. Russia is now a direct threat to Ukraine's sovereignty and as such efforts need to be made to protect Ukrainian sovereignty, Russia being as aggressive as they've been is what has turned the rhetoric in Ukraine against their foreign policy aims. It's easier to pander to a loud nuisance than a direct threat.

Putin's put the theoretical nonstarter into a serious possibility to deter further action, and the best means to do that is supranational organisations like NATO and the EU. Let's not forget the whole of Europe, through people and goods, is affected by a destabilised Ukraine and will want to minimise that.
I don't disagree, but I am not sure the best way out of this is protecting sovereignty now by a means that risks obliteration.  I say "risks" because what do I know?  It's interesting to read media pundits' (and "experts'") differing views.  Some terrify me.
Reply
(03-07-2022, 06:31 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(03-07-2022, 05:24 PM)baggy1 Wrote: Whichever way it goes Putin cannot go out of this without a 'win'. If that is to have international recognition of the Crimea and the two eastern Ukraine states as Russian then that would be job done for him I reckon. The problem being how to protect Ukraine going forward, Putin won't accept Ukraine having the opportunity to join NATO so that would be a red line for him, maybe there should be part of the agreement whereby Russian reparations are paid in exchange for Ukraine not joining NATO but having a hybrid status with training and munitions being made available.

Any kind of win for Russia would just embolden Putin (and maybe other countries) to do it again in the future. Therefore, I think it's imperative that it doesn't happen.

Also, the deliberate killing of civilians shouldn't be rewarded in any way.

Problem being without the 'win' he will continue in the current vain which will do much more long term damage. Let him think he has a win but continue with the sanctions and prosecution as we are. There is no way he will back down and tell the Russian people he has been beaten back. The war crimes will be something that takes years to roll out and will almost certainly need a regime change in Russia othewise you will need to send the troops in to get him to stand in court,
Reply
(03-07-2022, 06:39 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: The realpolitik has changed though, even 2014 pales in comparison to the last few months. Russia is now a direct threat to Ukraine's sovereignty and as such efforts need to be made to protect Ukrainian sovereignty, Russia being as aggressive as they've been is what has turned the rhetoric in Ukraine against their foreign policy aims. It's easier to pander to a loud nuisance than a direct threat.

Putin's put the theoretical nonstarter into a serious possibility to deter further action, and the best means to do that is supranational organisations like NATO and the EU. Let's not forget the whole of Europe, through people and goods, is affected by a destabilised Ukraine and will want to minimise that.

We started a war to stop a war happening

Jesus wept, surely the person writing that bullshit isn't stupid enough to believe it, surely.

Not stupid.  Orwellian doublespeak write large.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)