Communism...
#21
(02-25-2022, 08:03 PM)hudds Wrote:
(02-25-2022, 06:39 PM)Offside Wrote: Read 

Animal Farm.

Sums it up. 

Well, it's often used as a parable of communism but really it's a satire on the Russian Revolution and Stalinism, which publishers knew would offend Stalin and the "power-worshipping left wing (ie Communist) intelligentsia, hence it not being accepted by the "usual" houses.  You can try to pick out which animal is who and the Russian policy changes from the twenties to the end of the war.  It's in many ways a piece of its time and experiences, particularly after Orwell's expereinces in Spain (Homage To Catalonia mainly but of course in his many essays).

Orwell saw Marx as being essentially correct, as he says a couple of times at least (to paraphrase) that he saw through capitalism and that all moral codes etc are supertructures built over property relations hence the moralists and millionaires, priests, judges etc hate him so much (eg As I Please, Tribune  25 Feb 1944).

But he has very different opinions on Communism as a tool of Soviet foreign policy.

Orwell was a socialist but anti-tankie.
Reply
#22
karl marks said you can only aford socialism with a little bit of capitalism
he sent his children to a private school with help from a rich benefactore
who supported him and his ideals
did karl marks ever do a days hard graft
Reply
#23
(02-25-2022, 10:23 PM)keef Wrote: karl marks said you can only aford socialism with  a little bit of capitalism
he sent his children to a private school with help from a rich benefactore
who supported him  and his  ideals
did karl marks  ever do a days hard graft

I think you mean Karl Marx FFS!

Ignorance is bliss.
Reply
#24
(02-26-2022, 12:42 AM)Solihull Throstle Wrote:
(02-25-2022, 10:23 PM)keef Wrote: karl marks said you can only aford socialism with  a little bit of capitalism
he sent his children to a private school with help from a rich benefactore
who supported him  and his  ideals
did karl marks  ever do a days hard graft

I think you mean Karl Marx FFS!

Ignorance is bliss.

Regardless of how you spell his name, the man lived his life sponging off a factory owner and it is always valid to criticise someone for wanting for others what they wouldn't want for themselves.
Reply
#25
Because the pages of History shows Communism is Evil. 

To throw my tuppence in, Communism clearly can not work without Capitalism. For all of Communism's socialist and socialism ideals, the movement is extremely negative, in that it hampers personal growth, it's a dictatorship, there's no personal freedom, no freedom of speech, there's little financial freedom, unless you live on a gas field. 

The Soviet Communism model is now so Capitalistic driven, it can hardly be called Communism anymore, it's nothing short of a dictatorship with some kind of Etonian rules for the elite in the power circle of control, ruling by fear.

Thems me onions.
Reply
#26
(02-26-2022, 07:19 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Because the pages of History shows Communism is Evil. 

To throw my tuppence in, Communism clearly can not work without Capitalism. For all of Communism's socialist and socialism ideals, the movement is extremely negative, in that it hampers personal growth, it's a dictatorship, there's no personal freedom, no freedom of speech, there's little financial freedom, unless you live on a gas field. 

The Soviet Communism model is now so Capitalistic driven, it can hardly be called Communism anymore, it's nothing short of a dictatorship with some kind of Etonian rules for the elite in the power circle of control, ruling by fear.

Thems me onions.

Why do you mention the "Soviet Communism Model" as if it still exists. The Soviet Union is long dead and Russia is one of the most capitalist countries on earth.
As for the merits of socialism (or communism....which is a different thing in my opinion as a lifelong socialist) and capitalism; does capitalism really work for most? Built on greed and injustice.
Reply
#27
Russia is a Mafia run state nowadays.
Reply
#28
People discuss and advocate for Marksism every day of year, in every country of the world. To dismiss him as 'never done a day's graft' really elevates the role of sheet metal workers of the world.
Reply
#29
(02-26-2022, 07:19 AM)SausEggBaton Wrote: Because the pages of History shows Communism is Evil. 

To throw my tuppence in, Communism clearly can not work without Capitalism. For all of Communism's socialist and socialism ideals, the movement is extremely negative, in that it hampers personal growth, it's a dictatorship, there's no personal freedom, no freedom of speech, there's little financial freedom, unless you live on a gas field. 

The Soviet Communism model is now so Capitalistic driven, it can hardly be called Communism anymore, it's nothing short of a dictatorship with some kind of Etonian rules for the elite in the power circle of control, ruling by fear.

Thems me onions.

Why are you still going on about Communism then? Russia hasn’t been communist for decades. Also communism was a result of a feudal system that saw people eek out a living as a serf to a dictatorship that dressed itself up as royalty. Democracy not rampant / unfettered capitalism is the only defence against the abuse of power and it’s fragile and easily be corrupted as we have seen in the US and here to a lesser extent.
Reply
#30
(02-26-2022, 09:58 AM)SophLad Wrote: People discuss and advocate for Marksism every day of year, in every country of the world. To dismiss him as 'never done a day's graft' really elevates the role of sheet metal workers of the world.

I’m a sheet metal worker!  Smile
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)