The "it will take ages to undo the damage done by val" argument...
#91
(02-15-2022, 12:41 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 12:37 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Then let Bruce head up the "project" and rebuild, yes he's English and unfashionable but is 10 times the manager Val is, or ever will be. It's also a safer bet then taking another punt on a young upcoming, but unproven, manager.
If people genuinely want a long term plan then Bruce is the perfect fit. I can't think of anyone I would rather kick off next season in the Championship with. Yes the squad needs an overhaul, but, again, Bruce knows the division and the type of player required to get out of it. Shit or bust tilt at play offs for the rest of this season, albeit, it looks unlikely, then reset in summer with him still in charge.

In other words, give Bruce a level of fan tolerance that Val never came close to being afforded. Younger managers need that tolerance much more than experienced ones of course.

I'm not sure that Bruce is interested in a longer term project but, regardless of that, our project shouldn't be giving jobs to as many 60+ year-old managers as we can.
It should be giving the project to the best person available, regardless of age. Roy is 74 but many would have him back in a heartbeat.

As for the fans, they will tolerate what they are prepared to tolerate, your sanctimony will have no effect on that. Val's results nor performances warranted tolerance as he didn't react or show any sign that he had a way of turning it around. He got what he deserved.
The key indicator for any manager should be, get results. Val didn't so he went, if Bruce doesn't, he will go. 
Based on the CV's of both, I expect Bruce to do better, that's all. Time will tell.
Reply
#92
(02-15-2022, 12:53 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It should be giving the project to the best person available, regardless of age. Roy is 74 but many would have him back in a heartbeat.

As for the fans, they will tolerate what they are prepared to tolerate, your sanctimony will have no effect on that. Val's results nor performances warranted tolerance as he didn't react or show any sign that he had a way of turning it around. He got what he deserved.
The key indicator for any manager should be, get results. Val didn't so he went, if Bruce doesn't, he will go. 
Based on the CV's of both, I expect Bruce to do better, that's all. Time will tell.

Many would have had Roy back I'm sure, but I wouldn't have.

Fans were already turning on Val when we'd lost just 4 games out of 23, in fact some had already started doing so during our 10 game unbeaten run at the start of the season, so results weren't an explanation for the disenchantment which became increasingly contagious once the players started to down tools.
Reply
#93
(02-15-2022, 01:09 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 12:53 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It should be giving the project to the best person available, regardless of age. Roy is 74 but many would have him back in a heartbeat.

As for the fans, they will tolerate what they are prepared to tolerate, your sanctimony will have no effect on that. Val's results nor performances warranted tolerance as he didn't react or show any sign that he had a way of turning it around. He got what he deserved.
The key indicator for any manager should be, get results. Val didn't so he went, if Bruce doesn't, he will go. 
Based on the CV's of both, I expect Bruce to do better, that's all. Time will tell.

Many would have had Roy back I'm sure, but I wouldn't have.

Fans were already turning on Val when we'd lost just 4 games out of 23, in fact some had already started doing so during our 10 game unbeaten run at the start of the season, so results weren't an explanation for the disenchantment which became increasingly contagious once the players started to down tools.

'The fans' is always a massive generalisation- when most quietly sit there hope for the best and grumble a bit when things aren't going well. It's also where you sit in the ground.

Thankfully despite its geriatric label the Halfords has some of the best fans.

FWIW, I think most fans were behind Ismael nearly all the way, but the final weeks were pure torture. I don't think most fans are bemoaning who is in the dugout- it was Ishmael's lack of flexibility that cost him his job- nothing to do with his CV.

Ishmael has seen us perform at our worst level for over 20 years, where we've been uncompetitive against sides we'd have dispatched even on a bad day in our many forays in the Champ- no manager would get away with that.
Reply
#94
(02-15-2022, 01:09 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 12:53 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It should be giving the project to the best person available, regardless of age. Roy is 74 but many would have him back in a heartbeat.

As for the fans, they will tolerate what they are prepared to tolerate, your sanctimony will have no effect on that. Val's results nor performances warranted tolerance as he didn't react or show any sign that he had a way of turning it around. He got what he deserved.
The key indicator for any manager should be, get results. Val didn't so he went, if Bruce doesn't, he will go. 
Based on the CV's of both, I expect Bruce to do better, that's all. Time will tell.

Many would have had Roy back I'm sure, but I wouldn't have.

Fans were already turning on Val when we'd lost just 4 games out of 23, in fact some had already started doing so during our 10 game unbeaten run at the start of the season, so results weren't an explanation for the disenchantment which became increasingly contagious once the players started to down tools.
It really seems like you hold the fans more culpable for the demise than Val himself, which is simply absurd and, quite frankly, insulting.
I've been going 40 odd years so my opinion is valid, as is that of anyone else on here or in the ground, whether you agree with it or not, you are not a superfan. 

Most fans I know, stuck with Val until it reached a point where results were deteriorating, performances were deteriorating and he was not coming up with any answers, just sticking with the same fruitless system. I don't know any that turned during the 10 game run that you keep alluding to. Yes there were concerns about the football, but that is a valid discussion in it's own right and goes on after every game around the country.

There's a difference between disagreeing, and belittling the opinions of your fellow fans.
Reply
#95
(02-15-2022, 02:06 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It really seems like you hold the fans more culpable for the demise than Val himself, which is simply absurd and, quite frankly, insulting.
I've been going 40 odd years so my opinion is valid, as is that of anyone else on here or in the ground, whether you agree with it or not, you are not a superfan.

I've never claimed to be a superfan, I don't believe there is such a thing. I've just expressed my opinion on what I think happened. My opinion is also as valid as yours and anyone else's, and I've managed to make my points without calling those of a differing view "absurd" or anything like that.
Reply
#96
(02-15-2022, 03:51 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 02:06 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It really seems like you hold the fans more culpable for the demise than Val himself, which is simply absurd and, quite frankly, insulting.
I've been going 40 odd years so my opinion is valid, as is that of anyone else on here or in the ground, whether you agree with it or not, you are not a superfan.

I've never claimed to be a superfan, I don't believe there is such a thing. I've just expressed my opinion on what I think happened. My opinion is also as valid as yours and anyone else's, and I've managed to make my points without calling those of a differing view "absurd" or anything like that.
So you don't think it absurd to hold the fans more responsible than the manager, which is what I actually said?

There is a theme through your posts that defends Val and suggests that the fans were too impatient, is that not true?
Reply
#97
(02-15-2022, 01:09 PM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 12:53 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: It should be giving the project to the best person available, regardless of age. Roy is 74 but many would have him back in a heartbeat.

As for the fans, they will tolerate what they are prepared to tolerate, your sanctimony will have no effect on that. Val's results nor performances warranted tolerance as he didn't react or show any sign that he had a way of turning it around. He got what he deserved.
The key indicator for any manager should be, get results. Val didn't so he went, if Bruce doesn't, he will go. 
Based on the CV's of both, I expect Bruce to do better, that's all. Time will tell.

Many would have had Roy back I'm sure, but I wouldn't have.

Fans were already turning on Val when we'd lost just 4 games out of 23, in fact some had already started doing so during our 10 game unbeaten run at the start of the season, so results weren't an explanation for the disenchantment which became increasingly contagious once the players started to down tools.
So you don't rate Pulis or Roy but were willing to give Ismael all the time in the world because of the fantastic unbeaten home record? Wow.
Reply
#98
(02-15-2022, 04:21 PM)Bob Fossil Wrote: So you don't think it absurd to hold the fans more responsible than the manager, which is what I actually said?

There is a theme through your posts that defends Val and suggests that the fans were too impatient, is that not true?

Yes, I believe that the majority of fans were too impatient and too many didn't give him a fair chance.

(02-15-2022, 04:22 PM)clem4england Wrote: So you don't rate Pulis or Roy but were willing to give Ismael all the time in the world because of the fantastic unbeaten home record? Wow.

I would never rate Pulis anytime ever, I dislike him more than any other manager. Where did I say I didn't rate Roy, I just wouldn't have him back now?

As for Ismael, I never said I'd give him all the time in the world, but I'd certainly have given him more than 7 months out of a 4 year contract if the playing field had been level. I've explained why I think he didn't get a level playing field.
Reply
#99
(02-15-2022, 09:08 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Lurker, don't waste your breathe.

It's a sign of football fans weirdness that they really think the manager is the be all and end all, if its going wrong, sack him and get a new one. If then results don't improve, well that one is shit too.

Never players fault, never look for bigger issues, just sack and hire managers. Might get lucky at some point and one does a miracle job short term.
Well, three attacks on the majority of Albion fans - they're not worth wasting your breathe on, are weird and can't discern when a manager is "screwing up"  Without a shadow of doubt VI was the worst managager for 22 years by a country mile and there's been getting near to 25 of them choose from. It was apparent from the end of October last year that he was becoming intransigent,  misguided, predictable and players weren't buying into it. How can you blame the players, pick on one or two OK, but surely a managers job is to control them, lead them and mold them into a promotion winning side and he is the be all and end all.

I won't be blaming Bruce if things go tits up - the job is too difficult now
Reply
(02-16-2022, 08:40 AM)Pontificator Wrote:
(02-15-2022, 09:08 AM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Lurker, don't waste your breathe.

It's a sign of football fans weirdness that they really think the manager is the be all and end all, if its going wrong, sack him and get a new one. If then results don't improve, well that one is shit too.

Never players fault, never look for bigger issues, just sack and hire managers. Might get lucky at some point and one does a miracle job short term.
Well, three attacks on the majority of Albion fans - they're not worth wasting your breathe on, are weird and can't discern when a manager is "screwing up"  Without a shadow of doubt VI was the worst managager for 22 years by a country mile and there's been getting near to 25 of them choose from. It was apparent from the end of October last year that he was becoming intransigent,  misguided, predictable and players weren't buying into it. How can you blame the players, pick on one or two OK, but surely a managers job is to control them, lead them and mold them into a promotion winning side and he is the be all and end all.

I won't be blaming Bruce if things go tits up - the job is too difficult now

Bold #1 - AFI, Pardew, come on mate... And that's just 2 theres a few more that are far more incompetent!

Bold #2 - They have downed tools many time over a number of years, for a number of managers.

Bold #3 - No chance. The squad is fundamentally flawed, both in terms of ability and personality. I wont doubt their character as they all seem like "decent" people, but they lack real drive and balls.

P.s. I dont think anybody will blame Brucey to be honest. Because there are those who think Val is the devil, and the rest of us who know it isnt the managers fault full stop. It wont stop some of us being dismayed at another sort term, boring, predictable appointment, which will lead to boring, predictable, old fashioned football.
"IMO of course..."
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)