The cost of living crisis
#81
(02-11-2022, 05:17 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-11-2022, 04:34 PM)Protheroe Wrote: It also appears Jack Monroe wasn't exactly comparing like for like the other week.

That isn't how this works and I'm disappointed that you still don't know what a control variable is. I would brush up on your GCSE science before your kids get to that stage so you can help them.

No BB, the control variable was removed from the store entirely so Jack cited a different product - and then claimed the price had increased by 344%.
Reply
#82
On one thread you talk of your prediction of inflation and here you claim it isn't happening. You are unique in your ability to argue both sides at once sir
Reply
#83
No, that's not how control variables work. The control variable is the same. The dependant variable is the price, the independent variable is the point at which the prices are recorded.
Reply
#84
(02-12-2022, 01:19 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, that's not how control variables work. The control variable is the same. The dependant variable is the price, the independent variable is the point at which the prices are recorded.

You would think that by now Proth would realise that he is dealing with someone who kinda knows what they are talking about.
Reply
#85
(02-12-2022, 01:19 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, that's not how control variables work. The control variable is the same. The dependant variable is the price, the independent variable is the point at which the prices are recorded.

Jesus wept. The product was no longer stocked so there is no DIRECT comparable.

(02-12-2022, 01:17 PM)baggy1 Wrote: On one thread you talk of your prediction of inflation and here you claim it isn't happening. You are unique in your ability to argue both sides at once sir

The ONS is your friend on the contribution of different markets to inflation. I'm not arguing both sides, I never have.
Reply
#86
(02-12-2022, 06:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-12-2022, 01:19 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, that's not how control variables work. The control variable is the same. The dependant variable is the price, the independent variable is the point at which the prices are recorded.

Jesus wept. The product was no longer stocked so there is no DIRECT comparable.

Err, you're saying that Asda don't stock rice any longer?

The control variable is the cheapest item of a given food-type at Asda which is like-for-like, again I don't think you understand how control variables work. Jesus wept indeed.

(02-12-2022, 06:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The ONS is your friend on the contribution of different markets to inflation. I'm not arguing both sides, I never have.

CPI and RPI are an inflationary measure based on a selection of goods and their effective weightings, it isn't a be-all-and-end-all and it isn't applicable for all scenarios. It is reflective of an average inflationary measure for tens of millions of people. By virtue of being an aggregate it is affected by some items going up and some going down, and as it is designed to be reflective of an average some people's goes up higher than it and some lower.
Reply
#87
(02-12-2022, 06:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-12-2022, 06:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-12-2022, 01:19 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, that's not how control variables work. The control variable is the same. The dependant variable is the price, the independent variable is the point at which the prices are recorded.

Jesus wept. The product was no longer stocked so there is no DIRECT comparable.

Err, you're saying that Asda don't stock rice any longer?

The control variable is the cheapest item of a given food-type at Asda which is like-for-like, again I don't think you understand how control variables work. Jesus wept indeed.


(02-12-2022, 06:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote: The ONS is your friend on the contribution of different markets to inflation. I'm not arguing both sides, I never have.

CPI and RPI are an inflationary measure based on a selection of goods and their effective weightings, it isn't a be-all-and-end-all and it isn't applicable for all scenarios. It is reflective of an average inflationary measure for tens of millions of people. By virtue of being an aggregate it is affected by some items going up and some going down, and as it is designed to be reflective of an average some people's goes up higher than it and some lower.
The cheapest rice available online on that day was 45p for a Kg bag and Pasta was 29p for 500g and those prices are still the same today. Can’t be arsed to check the rest.

Surely that suggests that, in those cases, it is more of a supply problem than an inflation problem. However there is no doubt that prices have increased.

I believe Asda have now said they will now stock the cheapest items in most, if not all, their stores.
So I assume  next time next time rice and pasta are bought at the prices quoted today we will get an article on how much prices have reduced   Cool Big Grin
Reply
#88
(02-12-2022, 06:50 PM)strawman Wrote: The cheapest rice available online on that day was 45p for a Kg bag and Pasta was 29p for 500g and those prices are still the same today. Can’t be arsed to check the rest.

Surely that suggests that, in those cases, it is more of a supply problem than an inflation problem. However there is no doubt that prices have increased.

I believe Asda have now said they will now stock the cheapest items in most, if not all, their stores.
So I assume  next time next time rice and pasta are bought at the prices quoted today we will get an article on how much prices have reduced   Cool Big Grin

Not from Asda it wasn't, and if you negate that then the measure falls apart as the control variable has been changed. As per Jack Monroe's records the choice of store is a key component in the operational control variable (based on cost and distance to get to said store) and therefore changing stores would break that as you wouldn't be measuring like-for-like. The prices of those foodstuffs going down to what they were last year would outline a deflationary effect on foodstuffs with the control variable the same as of right now, but this contradicts other modes of inflation (which, again, reinforces my point that inflation isn't experienced equally).

To be honest, the two reasons I posted the thread was a) to point out the issues with the rising cost of living as per a respected writer on cost of living for those towards the bottom and b) highlight to Proth how inflationary effects aren't just represented by the ONS figures (which he has completely failed to grasp somehow for reasons completely unknown to me, decided to try and argue something irrelevant instead of engage with the point and then show he doesn't understand or doesn't want to understand how statistics works), the ONS is applied to a specific use case for a specific purpose that isn't applicable to all scenarios.

I'd also point out that supply feeds into inflation as one of many variables, too much supply and prices deflate and restricted supply and prices inflate.
Reply
#89
(02-12-2022, 06:37 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote:
(02-12-2022, 06:04 PM)Protheroe Wrote:
(02-12-2022, 01:19 PM)Borin' Baggie Wrote: No, that's not how control variables work. The control variable is the same. The dependant variable is the price, the independent variable is the point at which the prices are recorded.

Jesus wept. The product was no longer stocked so there is no DIRECT comparable.

Err, you're saying that Asda don't stock rice any longer?

The control variable is the cheapest item of a given food-type at Asda which is like-for-like, again I don't think you understand how control variables work. Jesus wept indeed.

Asda stopped stocking the SPECIFIC product. If you check her Twitter feed they are now stocking that SPECIFIC product at the same price as it was last year, and all the other SPECIFIC products she cited at the same price as last year.

So BB. Has the price of rice increased 344%, or not?
Reply
#90
(02-10-2022, 10:50 AM)backsidebaggie Wrote:
(02-10-2022, 10:34 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:
(02-04-2022, 04:01 PM)baggy1 Wrote: By 2019 it had to morph itself into the Brexit party to win votes, that's pretty far right as far as I can see. The nationalism and popularism that was spouted at around that time has led us to this point directly where your theories have been destroyed and shown to be unworkable. Economic and social liberalism in simple terms is I'll do what I like with my money and my life and suffer the consequences in theory, but the reality is that people don't want to suffer the consequences so it's an unworkable theory. Your economic theories have failed because they ultimately need the state to bail us all out, as has been proven beyond doubt over the last couple of years.

We are a spoilt generation that had to learn this the hard way and some still don't see it, our parents / grandparents had to rely on the state because otherwise we would have been under Nazi rule and once that enemy was defeated there was a realisation that we needed to build for the greater protection of our society. We are at a similar point now and can either realise that we need to build a better safety net or throw it all to the wind in the name of social and economic liberalism. Your view that you will look after your family is fine, until you can't.

Great post. Sadly Proth will never admit he’s wrong or take responsibility for helping the worst government this country has had to endure in living memory. Like a naughty school boy getting caught, he’s now casually walking away trying to pretend it has nothing to do with him.

The current inflation increase is nothing to do with brexit or this government particularly (and I’m a remainer and not a Tory voter) though DH. It’s worldwide. People are really barking up the wrong tree if they think it’s a national issue. Just look around the world. The same is happening in America, Europe, Canada, Oz, everywhere.

Proth, you may be right about CPI, but that in itself is a very conservative measure of true inflation. I really think it’s going to spiral.

I agree we are in for a serious spiral on inflation. There’s already a price war brewing for employees, with over a million jobs vacant nationwide.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: