Posts: 7,971
Threads: 254
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
Difficult watch tonight after that fat knacker got sent off. Plenty of effort and attempted passing using AC as the fulcrum. What is scary is the lack of quality around the box in terms of shots and end product. SU get in and know how to put their foot through it. Marks
SJ 8. Some outstanding saves in that 5 min spell when they put us under. Came for some crosses 2 half
Furlong. 6 steady enough defensively. Dreadful final ball yet again
Townsend 7. One of his better recent games. Tried to link with KG - but undermined by poor crossing yet again
Clarke 7. Did ok and brave enough in competing. Lack of pace exposed at times. Really should of done better with a header
Semi 6. Pace and strength got him out of trouble but regular mistakes and beaten too easily for 2nd
Mowatt. 5.5. Miles off early season. Stupid booking and no composure or intent on the ball.
Jake 1. Started the game as the pick of a poor midfield. Tonight is totally on him. Ridiculous number of reds now
Reach 3. Utter crap. Can’t run control or pass it. He really wasn’t this bad at SW
Grady 4. Started ok but took a heavy tackle and an appalling miss. He is the one bit of quality left from 2 years ago and playing at 40%
Grant. 5. Plenty of energy but no touch or brains. Had loads of 2 on 1s on the left and did nothing with it. Worth about a quarter of what we paid.
AC 8. Our best outfield player by a mile. Won countless headers and laid the ball off. All to witless team mates
Molumby 7.5. Right sub as we needed legs with the 10 men. Just not enough going forward
CR 6. Tried to put his foot on it. another who should of read a flick on for a chance
Dara. 6.5. Not on long but minutes should help. Plenty of effort
Posts: 3,396
Threads: 176
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
9
(02-09-2022, 10:34 PM)MancBaggie Wrote: Difficult watch tonight after that fat knacker got sent off. Plenty of effort and attempted passing using AC as the fulcrum. What is scary is the lack of quality around the box in terms of shots and end product. SU get in and know how to put their foot through it. Marks
SJ 8. Some outstanding saves in that 5 min spell when they put us under. Came for some crosses 2 half
Furlong. 6 steady enough defensively. Dreadful final ball yet again
Townsend 7. One of his better recent games. Tried to link with KG - but undermined by poor crossing yet again
Clarke 7. Did ok and brave enough in competing. Lack of pace exposed at times. Really should of done better with a header
Semi 6. Pace and strength got him out of trouble but regular mistakes and beaten too easily for 2nd
Mowatt. 5.5. Miles off early season. Stupid booking and no composure or intent on the ball.
Jake 1. Started the game as the pick of a poor midfield. Tonight is totally on him. Ridiculous number of reds now
Reach 3. Utter crap. Can’t run control or pass it. He really wasn’t this bad at SW
Grady 4. Started ok but took a heavy tackle and an appalling miss. He is the one bit of quality left from 2 years ago and playing at 40%
Grant. 5. Plenty of energy but no touch or brains. Had loads of 2 on 1s on the left and did nothing with it. Worth about a quarter of what we paid.
AC 8. Our best outfield player by a mile. Won countless headers and laid the ball off. All to witless team mates
Molumby 7.5. Right sub as we needed legs with the 10 men. Just not enough going forward
CR 6. Tried to put his foot on it. another who should of read a flick on for a chance
Dara. 6.5. Not on long but minutes should help. Plenty of effort
Says it all when AC is by far and away our best outfield player
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
02-09-2022, 10:54 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-09-2022, 10:54 PM by Lurker#3.)
SJ, 8... top saves
Furlong, 5... whats happened to him?
Ajayi, 5... pace and power is great defensively but never looks "set" or comfortable in or around the posession.
Clarke, 5... poor man's Jonas. Turning out to be a dissapinting signing.
Townsend, 7... Much better from him.
Jake, 1... oh dear Jake.
Mowatt, 5... he looks so slow and off the pace compared to his all action displays earlier in the year.
Grady, 6... Only one to look threatening. And gets hooked at HT.
Reach, 3... Really? Playing as a 10? Come off it.
Grant, 6... worked hard, tried to make stuff happen. Won't be successful playing as left midfielder though needs to be closer to Carroll.
Carroll, 7... Good hold up play, nice lay offs, looks fit. Promising.
Subs:
Molumby, 5... Nope still can't see the point.
Robbo, 6... found some space and tried to get us moving. Might be worth a start in the 10 slot? I don't know.
Dara... Great to see him back.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
SJ 8 - top saves
DF 6 - defending passable, terrible on the ball
SA 5 - head was still at Afcon methinks
MC 6 - okay, caught out a few times
CT 6 - as DF
JL 1 - brainless
AM 6 - ran around a lot
AR 4 - not a central midfielder
GD 6 - promising start, got clobbered, disappeared
AC 7 - Won headers, shithoused, held it up, no one around him
KG 6 - frustratingly unable to pass to a teammate
JM 6 - filled the hole left by the brainless one
CR 5 - no real time
DOS 6 - good to see him back
Posts: 13,017
Threads: 1,260
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
6
(02-09-2022, 11:09 PM)MrFizz Wrote: SJ 8 - top saves
DF 6 - defending passable, terrible on the ball
SA 5 - head was still at Afcon methinks
MC 6 - okay, caught out a few times
CT 6 - as DF
JL 1 - brainless
AM 6 - ran around a lot
AR 4 - not a central midfielder
GD 6 - promising start, got clobbered, disappeared
AC 7 - Won headers, shithoused, held it up, no one around him
KG 6 - frustratingly unable to pass to a teammate
JM 6 - filled the hole left by the brainless one
CR 5 - no real time
DOS 6 - good to see him back
CR got more time than DOS (and did more in those few mins than Reach or Grant did the whole time both were on the pitch)
Posts: 8,080
Threads: 201
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
55
02-09-2022, 11:28 PM
(This post was last modified: 02-09-2022, 11:32 PM by HawkingsHalfpint.)
Sam’s Johnson - 9. Some worldies.
Furby - 6. Largely as summarised above. Not great, not shite. Just meh with the ball. A better manager should get more from him.
Semillion - 5. Played like he’d been smoking A J first half, sured-up a bit second, but a fringe player for me with a fully fit roster.
Clarkson - 6. Shiny and bald. Meh.
Townsend Toresen - 7. Improved. Will find it harder to get forward in a new formation, but still tried well. Another I hope to see vast improvement from under someone who knows what the fuck they’re doing.
Papa don’t Reach - 4.5. Worked hard enough and always showed feet, just not to the ball when it came to him. If he’d have been Zoumba, that cat would have been fine yesterday.
Lovely Loving Lovermore - I’m just not going to bother.
Why don’t you make like a lawn, and Mowatt - 5. Pretty unimpressive, but his job wasn’t made any easier by the steamboat directly above. Maybe he’d have grown into a different game, probably done enough to be in contention for Blackberk next Monday.
Princess Diangana - 5.5. Started brightly, faded, should have equalised. Another I hope Bruce can get the best out of, having stagnated quite so much. There’s still a decent player in there but needs some belief.
Oh Carroll - 8. Played the best he could have I felt. Got nothing from the tosser in green.
Carloan - 5. Like a hamster on a wheel tonight. Ran his legs a lot but ultimately to no avail. I’d switch him for Robbo next week, assuming Robbo hasn’t pissed in everyone’s Vimto or whatever he seems to have done to fall from favour since August.
Subs - can’t be bothered to mark them but all OK, great to see Dara back.
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
(02-09-2022, 11:25 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: (02-09-2022, 11:09 PM)MrFizz Wrote: SJ 8 - top saves
DF 6 - defending passable, terrible on the ball
SA 5 - head was still at Afcon methinks
MC 6 - okay, caught out a few times
CT 6 - as DF
JL 1 - brainless
AM 6 - ran around a lot
AR 4 - not a central midfielder
GD 6 - promising start, got clobbered, disappeared
AC 7 - Won headers, shithoused, held it up, no one around him
KG 6 - frustratingly unable to pass to a teammate
JM 6 - filled the hole left by the brainless one
CR 5 - no real time
DOS 6 - good to see him back
CR got more time than DOS (and did more in those few mins than Reach or Grant did the whole time both were on the pitch)
I just remember CR trying to play a pass to nobody through two pairs of Sheff Utd legs. But i'd kinda lost interest by then.
Posts: 1,906
Threads: 31
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
14
SJ deserves a mark more and Ajayi a mark less for me there Manc. That ball Ajayi let bounce over his head in the first half was proper Sunday league stuff.
Johnstone, though, was sensational tonight. Dreadful shame he won’t be here next season but that’s where we are as a club unfortunately.
Posts: 4,002
Threads: 162
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
25
Had Jake not done what he did then Reach would have been hooked, surely? Terrible performance and I didn’t think Grant was much better.
Strange game, we were their equals, often on top and yet had we have lost 4 or 5 we couldn’t have complained.
Not for the sending off but the ref was a real Homer, some of the found given against Caroll, stopping play needlessly, pedantic when we were taking throw ins, just constant decisions all night.
I’m strangely more optimistic after tonight’s game, despite the result, that we may turn the season around.
We’re not a top 2 side but we’re certainly better than some of those sides either now above us or will be before we next play. Bruce can, and I think will, at least put that right.
Thanks Lai and thanks Val for ducking up the first of 2 chances to get promoted, it’s going to get harder each season…
Trump is a Cunt
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
02-10-2022, 08:21 AM
(This post was last modified: 02-10-2022, 08:22 AM by Lurker#3.)
(02-10-2022, 08:17 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: Had Jake not done what he did then Reach would have been hooked, surely? Terrible performance and I didn’t think Grant was much better.
Strange game, we were their equals, often on top and yet had we have lost 4 or 5 we couldn’t have complained.
Not for the sending off but the ref was a real Homer, some of the found given against Caroll, stopping play needlessly, pedantic when we were taking throw ins, just constant decisions all night.
I’m strangely more optimistic after tonight’s game, despite the result, that we may turn the season around.
We’re not a top 2 side but we’re certainly better than some of those sides either now above us or will be before we next play. Bruce can, and I think will, at least put that right.
Thanks Lai and thanks Val for ducking up the first of 2 chances to get promoted, it’s going to get harder each season…
I love your optimism CA.
I am the polar opposite. I saw a return to middling, aimless, football. Back to a low block for long periods, large gaps between the lines and aimless passing.
I hope everybody enjoys the shorter passing though, and we get some results on the way for us all. Gonna be boring though.
"IMO of course..."
|