Manager quandary
#11
Clubs need to have someone with a lot of experience and an excellent football brain to oversee things on the playing side. They need to make sure that the chosen methodology is applied consistently and with off-field support that helps it to work. They also need to oversee the scouting system and ensure that the players we target are ones that will suit the system we're employing. They also need to provide continuity as managers come and go so that we don't end up with a squad that doesn't suit our chosen system.

To attempt to run the club without any of the above is madness in my view.

I also think it's madness for fans to keep clamouring for managers to be sacked after 6 months. How anyone can expect us to get anywhere with such a short-termist approach is beyond me. It's not that long since fans were willing to put up with Pulis trying not to lose every game for 3 years, but now it's always has to be do it all straight away or go. I'm sure I was guilty of that with Allardyce bu, for me, his negative style of play and poor results were compounded by the feeling that I got that he never really cared what happened to us. It always seemed like he was just going throught the motions.

We're still in the play-off positions now and, at the start of the season, I doubt that anyone would regard automatic promotion as being the only acceptable outcome this season. Things have definitely gone distinctly pear-shaped of late, but fans need to consider their own role in that happening. All the booing (even during our unbeaten run at the start of the season), mounting derision and, now, unacceptable violence isn't going to help the players to perform on the pitch, so it's all rather become a self-fulfilling prophecy now.
Reply
#12
(01-31-2022, 11:14 AM)DemonicBaggie Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 10:46 AM)Bob Fossil Wrote: Without hope a football fan is just an empty shell, and that is where Val has put us. 

Are you by any chance a trilobite?
At the minute I am yes  Sad a football trilobite who has lost all hope. Cry
Reply
#13
(01-31-2022, 11:04 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 10:53 AM)MassDebater Wrote: A good, Ashworth style, DoF and we'd probably not be in this same situation. I think everyone realises how bad the behind the scenes stuff is, but we have no real direct influence on that, I guess we don't on the manager either, but empty seats and no ticket sales will probably say more to lai than any chants will.

As I've said elsewhere, it's all very well trying to plan for the future, but I honestly think that is a lot easier when you're a club with no parachutes, limited funds and very limited fan expectations, use Leeds as an example and the Bielsa project, much easier to buy into after several seasons in the wilderness. For me, promotion was needed this season, due to the finances, and if Six had achieved that (hey, he still could!! Big Grin Big Grin) then no-one would be calling for the sack. No plan survives enemy contact as they say.

If you put the wrong person in charge and it all goes tits up then no long term plan can ever be achieved. it is a catch 22, but tough decisions have to be made.

As for Pulis being worse, I honestly no longer think he was. I hated his football with a passion, but I honestly think that Six's version of it just sucks every ounce of enjoyment from the game, and at least Pulis was fighting to keep us up, rather than having one of the top squads in the division and really struggling to get us competing.
You've summed it up pretty well there.

We looked good for a couple of months, but there was restlessness at displays long before the wheels came off. The drudgery of dull wins over Blues and Hull were accepted and somehow many of us, myself included, thought he must have it on the right lines as we were up there, but just needed tweaking to make us more efficient.

Instead the wheels have come right off and we've all completely lost faith in him. More importantly it seems the players have too.

We do need to invest in a long-term project though and this is an aside from the current crisis. I would hope those in charge look for the best brains and clubs doing it the right way. If they don't they'll never see their £100m back.

IMO SGM should be our DoF - it's a real shame his knowledge and experience is not being utilized. With an assistant for a few years to do the day to day stuff and take over when SGM wants to take it easy. 
Obviously Ken who thinks he's our DoF hasn't got a clue. 
Players and Youngsters leaving for free. Contracts u/s or missing vital clauses 
And a 4 year managerial contact, when our managers don't last 2 seasons. enough said.
Reply
#14
(01-31-2022, 11:20 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: IMO SGM should be our DoF - it's a real shame his knowledge and experience is not being utilized. With an assistant for a few years to do the day to day stuff and take over when SGM wants to take it easy.

Really, when his idea of a scouting network extended to just his Dad?
Reply
#15
(01-31-2022, 11:20 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 11:04 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 10:53 AM)MassDebater Wrote: A good, Ashworth style, DoF and we'd probably not be in this same situation. I think everyone realises how bad the behind the scenes stuff is, but we have no real direct influence on that, I guess we don't on the manager either, but empty seats and no ticket sales will probably say more to lai than any chants will.

As I've said elsewhere, it's all very well trying to plan for the future, but I honestly think that is a lot easier when you're a club with no parachutes, limited funds and very limited fan expectations, use Leeds as an example and the Bielsa project, much easier to buy into after several seasons in the wilderness. For me, promotion was needed this season, due to the finances, and if Six had achieved that (hey, he still could!! Big Grin Big Grin) then no-one would be calling for the sack. No plan survives enemy contact as they say.

If you put the wrong person in charge and it all goes tits up then no long term plan can ever be achieved. it is a catch 22, but tough decisions have to be made.

As for Pulis being worse, I honestly no longer think he was. I hated his football with a passion, but I honestly think that Six's version of it just sucks every ounce of enjoyment from the game, and at least Pulis was fighting to keep us up, rather than having one of the top squads in the division and really struggling to get us competing.
You've summed it up pretty well there.

We looked good for a couple of months, but there was restlessness at displays long before the wheels came off. The drudgery of dull wins over Blues and Hull were accepted and somehow many of us, myself included, thought he must have it on the right lines as we were up there, but just needed tweaking to make us more efficient.

Instead the wheels have come right off and we've all completely lost faith in him. More importantly it seems the players have too.

We do need to invest in a long-term project though and this is an aside from the current crisis. I would hope those in charge look for the best brains and clubs doing it the right way. If they don't they'll never see their £100m back.

IMO SGM should be our DoF - it's a real shame his knowledge and experience is not being utilized. With an assistant for a few years to do the day to day stuff and take over when SGM wants to take it easy. 
Obviously Ken who thinks he's our DoF hasn't got a clue. 
Players and Youngsters leaving for free. Contracts u/s or missing vital clauses 
And a 4 year managerial contact, when our managers don't last 2 seasons. enough said.

I honestly could not see Ken / Lai getting on well enough with SGM for it to work.

Ashworth always seemed very tactful, that's one thing we know SGM really isn't. It's a totally different role to that of first team manager. In effect it needs to be someone who is happy doing the leg work, letting the manager get the plaudits, but behind the scenes they are making everyone happy and stopping the first team manager from pissing off the director(s) etc... I don't see SGM being the right person for that role.
Reply
#16
(01-31-2022, 11:27 AM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 11:20 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 11:04 AM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 10:53 AM)MassDebater Wrote: A good, Ashworth style, DoF and we'd probably not be in this same situation. I think everyone realises how bad the behind the scenes stuff is, but we have no real direct influence on that, I guess we don't on the manager either, but empty seats and no ticket sales will probably say more to lai than any chants will.

As I've said elsewhere, it's all very well trying to plan for the future, but I honestly think that is a lot easier when you're a club with no parachutes, limited funds and very limited fan expectations, use Leeds as an example and the Bielsa project, much easier to buy into after several seasons in the wilderness. For me, promotion was needed this season, due to the finances, and if Six had achieved that (hey, he still could!! Big Grin Big Grin) then no-one would be calling for the sack. No plan survives enemy contact as they say.

If you put the wrong person in charge and it all goes tits up then no long term plan can ever be achieved. it is a catch 22, but tough decisions have to be made.

As for Pulis being worse, I honestly no longer think he was. I hated his football with a passion, but I honestly think that Six's version of it just sucks every ounce of enjoyment from the game, and at least Pulis was fighting to keep us up, rather than having one of the top squads in the division and really struggling to get us competing.
You've summed it up pretty well there.

We looked good for a couple of months, but there was restlessness at displays long before the wheels came off. The drudgery of dull wins over Blues and Hull were accepted and somehow many of us, myself included, thought he must have it on the right lines as we were up there, but just needed tweaking to make us more efficient.

Instead the wheels have come right off and we've all completely lost faith in him. More importantly it seems the players have too.

We do need to invest in a long-term project though and this is an aside from the current crisis. I would hope those in charge look for the best brains and clubs doing it the right way. If they don't they'll never see their £100m back.

IMO SGM should be our DoF - it's a real shame his knowledge and experience is not being utilized. With an assistant for a few years to do the day to day stuff and take over when SGM wants to take it easy. 
Obviously Ken who thinks he's our DoF hasn't got a clue. 
Players and Youngsters leaving for free. Contracts u/s or missing vital clauses 
And a 4 year managerial contact, when our managers don't last 2 seasons. enough said.

I honestly could not see Ken / Lai getting on well enough with SGM for it to work.

Ashworth always seemed very tactful, that's one thing we know SGM really isn't. It's a totally different role to that of first team manager. In effect it needs to be someone who is happy doing the leg work, letting the manager get the plaudits, but behind the scenes they are making everyone happy and stopping the first team manager from pissing off the director(s) etc... I don't see SGM being the right person for that role.

A mistake in business is appointing someone to a role they haven't experience in. Just because Megson was a good coach doesn't mean he is director of football material.

There's plenty of clubs all over Europe to look at their model. That is how Peace built us up. He got us to visit similar sized successful clubs on the continent.

Now is the time to look again as it seems the knowledge and philosophy from the Peace era, when we were relatively successful seems to have left the club.
Reply
#17
"Giving people time" works both ways. Roy got time because the impact he had was instantaneous. I'm sure Forest will give Cooper time for the same reason.

If we want to give anyone - regardless of what his team produces - time, simply because they need to be judged over a longer period, we'd have kept Little and missed out on Megson and persisted with Di Matteo over Roy. Or we'd still be sat here hoping Burkinshaw and Talbot come good.

Fact is that we have been on a downward spiral since September.
Reply
#18
(01-31-2022, 11:39 AM)clem4england Wrote: "Giving people time" works both ways. Roy got time because the impact he had was instantaneous. I'm sure Forest will give Cooper time for the same reason.

If we want to give anyone - regardless of what his team produces - time, simply because they need to be judged over a longer period, we'd have kept Little and missed out on Megson and persisted with Di Matteo over Roy. Or we'd still be sat here hoping Burkinshaw and Talbot come good.

Fact is that we have been on a downward spiral since September.

Spot on.
Reply
#19
(01-31-2022, 11:25 AM)WorcsWBA Wrote:
(01-31-2022, 11:20 AM)Remi_Moses Wrote: IMO SGM should be our DoF - it's a real shame his knowledge and experience is not being utilized. With an assistant for a few years to do the day to day stuff and take over when SGM wants to take it easy.

Really, when his idea of a scouting network extended to just his Dad?

Hmm tot up how much we wasted under GM in players bought and then tot up how much we have wasted when we had a DoF model. Megson and his dad got a hell of a lot of recruitment right and without XG stats to help them. 

I take your point about GM not really suited to that model but systems only work when you have the best people in them. It’s not the system that achieves anything it’s the people operating in them.
Reply
#20
It's no secret that Megson was not popular with the players, a lot of the time, but he still managed to get them to buy into what he was doing, which is a skill that it appears Val is sadly lacking.
If the players are resisting, then it is Val's job to win them over and he just can't seem to do it. I would imagine every club in the league has players that disagree with tactics or formations etc. it's perfectly reasonable, it is, however, up to the manager to "manage" the situation. It's sort of in the job title.

In fairness though, we were Megson's "Barnsley". It was just a good fit at the right time and worked well for a while. He never replicated it elsewhere to the same degree, however.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)