Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate
#11
We have more in common with Huddersfield a couple of years back. Initially one of the promotion favourites, a lot of money spent in the PL but when you look at what they spent it on you realise why they nearly got relegated twice in a row. The only reason we were one of the promotion favourites is because we were in the PL last season. If we weren't, I'm sure the general consensus would be "playoffs at best". It doesn't excuse Val, but the players have been poor for a long time now.
Reply
#12
(01-30-2022, 01:06 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 12:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: It’s not one or the other.

The players are not that great. Andy Carroll wouldn’t walk into the starting 11 of any other team in the top half of the table, and Matt Phillips up front is something that can probably extended to the bottom half. However, they are better than our recent form and it doesn’t look like it’s going to turn around. That’s the managers fault

Agreed.
The squad is about 6th-8th in quality but not much behind those in the 3rd - 5th range.
A good manager gets us comfortably in the play off perhaps having a go at the 2nd place.
A poor one like Val gets us in the 8th - 10th mark and well out of contention.

Put the discussion about the 'talent' of this group to one side, as a squad is made up of much more than this. It has to be resolute and resilient. It has to be solid and dependable and play as a team.

This lot have not done this for anyone since Bilic left and he had other issues. It's questionable that they are a 'squad' at all and there are not many of them playing for the shirt. Self interest seems to be the driver. They are certainly lily livered.
I am surprised at how few did not suspect this would be the case based on their record tbh. 

Val might have an epiphany and change everything about his style and tactics. 
He shows no evidence of doing this and the performances are 100% at his feet.

Other than Fulham and possibly Bournemouth i don't see greater quality elsewhere. That's not to say this isn't the poorest Albion side for 20 years. But the standard in the Championship at present is truly dreadful.

(01-30-2022, 01:07 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: We have more in common with Huddersfield a couple of years back. Initially one of the promotion favourites, a lot of money spent in the PL but when you look at what they spent it on you realise why they nearly got relegated twice in a row. The only reason we were one of the promotion favourites is because we were in the PL last season. If we weren't, I'm sure the general consensus would be "playoffs at best". It doesn't excuse Val, but the players have been poor for a long time now.

Not really. Hudds got promoted finishing 6th with a negative goal difference. This set of players finished 2nd two years ago.
Reply
#13
(01-30-2022, 01:08 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 01:06 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 12:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: It’s not one or the other.

The players are not that great. Andy Carroll wouldn’t walk into the starting 11 of any other team in the top half of the table, and Matt Phillips up front is something that can probably extended to the bottom half. However, they are better than our recent form and it doesn’t look like it’s going to turn around. That’s the managers fault

Agreed.
The squad is about 6th-8th in quality but not much behind those in the 3rd - 5th range.
A good manager gets us comfortably in the play off perhaps having a go at the 2nd place.
A poor one like Val gets us in the 8th - 10th mark and well out of contention.

Put the discussion about the 'talent' of this group to one side, as a squad is made up of much more than this. It has to be resolute and resilient. It has to be solid and dependable and play as a team.

This lot have not done this for anyone since Bilic left and he had other issues. It's questionable that they are a 'squad' at all and there are not many of them playing for the shirt. Self interest seems to be the driver. They are certainly lily livered.
I am surprised at how few did not suspect this would be the case based on their record tbh. 

Val might have an epiphany and change everything about his style and tactics. 
He shows no evidence of doing this and the performances are 100% at his feet.

Other than Fulham and possibly Bournemouth i don't see greater quality elsewhere. That's not to say this isn't the poorest Albion side for 20 years. But the standard in the Championship at present is truly dreadful.

(01-30-2022, 01:07 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: We have more in common with Huddersfield a couple of years back. Initially one of the promotion favourites, a lot of money spent in the PL but when you look at what they spent it on you realise why they nearly got relegated twice in a row. The only reason we were one of the promotion favourites is because we were in the PL last season. If we weren't, I'm sure the general consensus would be "playoffs at best". It doesn't excuse Val, but the players have been poor for a long time now.

Not really. Hudds got promoted finishing 6th with a negative goal difference. This set of players finished 2nd two years ago.

Err CIM - half of them, the others have gone.
Unfortunately every player who has come in has been worse in talent and determination and that's a big factor in our general performance.
Reply
#14
(01-30-2022, 01:08 PM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 01:06 PM)Swagbaggie Wrote:
(01-30-2022, 12:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: It’s not one or the other.

The players are not that great. Andy Carroll wouldn’t walk into the starting 11 of any other team in the top half of the table, and Matt Phillips up front is something that can probably extended to the bottom half. However, they are better than our recent form and it doesn’t look like it’s going to turn around. That’s the managers fault

Agreed.
The squad is about 6th-8th in quality but not much behind those in the 3rd - 5th range.
A good manager gets us comfortably in the play off perhaps having a go at the 2nd place.
A poor one like Val gets us in the 8th - 10th mark and well out of contention.

Put the discussion about the 'talent' of this group to one side, as a squad is made up of much more than this. It has to be resolute and resilient. It has to be solid and dependable and play as a team.

This lot have not done this for anyone since Bilic left and he had other issues. It's questionable that they are a 'squad' at all and there are not many of them playing for the shirt. Self interest seems to be the driver. They are certainly lily livered.
I am surprised at how few did not suspect this would be the case based on their record tbh. 

Val might have an epiphany and change everything about his style and tactics. 
He shows no evidence of doing this and the performances are 100% at his feet.

Other than Fulham and possibly Bournemouth i don't see greater quality elsewhere. That's not to say this isn't the poorest Albion side for 20 years. But the standard in the Championship at present is truly dreadful.

(01-30-2022, 01:07 PM)Dial M for Mick Wrote: We have more in common with Huddersfield a couple of years back. Initially one of the promotion favourites, a lot of money spent in the PL but when you look at what they spent it on you realise why they nearly got relegated twice in a row. The only reason we were one of the promotion favourites is because we were in the PL last season. If we weren't, I'm sure the general consensus would be "playoffs at best". It doesn't excuse Val, but the players have been poor for a long time now.

Not really. Hudds got promoted finishing 6th with a negative goal difference. This set of players finished 2nd two years ago.

Why is this repeated. It’s such bollocks. Our top scorers that year were Austin and Kanu who scored 10 each, our next highest scorer was Pereira who also had one of the highest number of assists totals in Championship (what was it, 18?) and we got promoted by one goal. It’s not the same squad when you take out the vast majority of our attacking talent and the best player in the league by a country mile.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: