![]() |
|
Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate (/showthread.php?tid=23875) Pages:
1
2
|
Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - Cheshire East Baggie - 01-30-2022 I deplore the notion of player power. Way back in 1992 they coasted to a seventh place finish to see Gould off (not that it was a bad result). The rebellion against McDonough was probably a professional move by players who cared and the resistance to Mel's tactics was at least backed up by a competent coaching staff and an alternative plan. These players seemed oblivious to the slow decline under Bilic and were actively opposed to the changes Sam tried to bring in. Relegation seemed to be someone else's fault, not theirs. Now they don't like what Ismael is asking them to do. Is it true that they are an idle bunch, resistant to training hard? Is Ismael an arrogant and impatient coach with "my way or highway" tattooed on his soul? They seem to be trying and failing to play it his way, playing with fear of the consequences. They seem to care about defeat, they don't stroll off smirking after the final whistle. But what is Ismael trying to achieve? Is there a set of players somewhere who could make it work? Can his style of play win the Championship and thrive in the Premier League? I'm not convinced that it's a winning formula - I accept that we haven't seen it done properly but the players have tried (at times) and you can't just change them all out like a game of Scrabble when you have all the Qs, Xs and Zs. Ismael's Barnsley record of 55 goals in 41 matches (?) including play-offs isn't a scintillating effort. You need to defend well to progress if you're scoring at that rate. All I know at the moment is that it isn't working and it isn't going to start working any time soon. Regardless of the financial implications, the club can't let this toxic situation go on for much longer. A run of wins might pull us out of the mire. Does anyone think that likely? RE: Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - baggiebloke - 01-30-2022 Afraid not. RE: Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - Cunninghamismagic - 01-30-2022 Bomber Brown made the point that his form and desire slipped under Don Howe. Human nature that will happen under a poor manager like Ismael. We are sleep walking out of even a play off place in a really poor standard League this season. Needs to be arrested. And now. While a new manager won't arrest all the issues it will at least give the players a lift. Look out how Forest, Boro and Sheff Utd have improved since they changed manager. RE: Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - Loanee - 01-30-2022 Starting to get confused by: “Players aren’t good enough, whoever the manager” And “The manager should have this squad in the top 2 as we’ve got a good squad, sack him” RE: Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - Derek Hardballs - 01-30-2022 (01-30-2022, 11:34 AM)Loanee Wrote: Starting to get confused by: Here to end the confusion we aren’t playing to the players strengths, results are poor, performances are getting worse and we are slowly slipping out the play-offs. The buck stops with the manager who is blunting a decent quality squad through either a lack of managerial ability or sheer bloody mindedness not to alter his rather one dimensional philosophy. RE: Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - Spandaubaggie - 01-30-2022 (01-30-2022, 11:58 AM)Derek Hardballs Wrote:This precisely. A good manager gets players on his side. He is alienating good pros, getting rubbish results and playing dreadful rubbish.(01-30-2022, 11:34 AM)Loanee Wrote: Starting to get confused by: The bloke is a total friggin waste of space. Still the fact that our clueless owners gave him a 4 year contract says more. RE: Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - Sliced - 01-30-2022 It’s not one or the other. The players are not that great. Andy Carroll wouldn’t walk into the starting 11 of any other team in the top half of the table, and Matt Phillips up front is something that can probably extended to the bottom half. However, they are better than our recent form and it doesn’t look like it’s going to turn around. That’s the managers fault RE: Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - Tom Joad - 01-30-2022 (01-30-2022, 12:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: It’s not one or the other.Is correct. RE: Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - Bob Fossil - 01-30-2022 It's the manager's job to get the best out of the players he has. Does anyone think that Forest, Boro, QPR, Blackburn, Huddersfield, Stoke wouldn't like better players and improvements in certain areas? Of course they would, It doesn't stop them competing and that's the thing that is going unsaid here, it's not about not winning, we are simply not even competitive! If Val had tried everything and it still failed, yes you could lump it on the players but, when he ridiculously and stubbornly just keeps doing the same thing over and over again, then I'm sorry but it's on him. His style just doesn't suit so many of this squad and he just refuses, or is just too limited, to compromise. If the next bloke comes in tries a different formation, say 433, and it's a success, does anyone think the penny will drop and Val will go "Oh yes, that's what I was doing wrong" RE: Conflicted by this "players or Ismael" debate - Swagbaggie - 01-30-2022 (01-30-2022, 12:43 PM)Sliced Wrote: It’s not one or the other. Agreed. The squad is about 6th-8th in quality but not much behind those in the 3rd - 5th range. A good manager gets us comfortably in the play off perhaps having a go at the 2nd place. A poor one like Val gets us in the 8th - 10th mark and well out of contention. Put the discussion about the 'talent' of this group to one side, as a squad is made up of much more than this. It has to be resolute and resilient. It has to be solid and dependable and play as a team. This lot have not done this for anyone since Bilic left and he had other issues. It's questionable that they are a 'squad' at all and there are not many of them playing for the shirt. Self interest seems to be the driver. They are certainly lily livered. I am surprised at how few did not suspect this would be the case based on their record tbh. Val might have an epiphany and change everything about his style and tactics. He shows no evidence of doing this and the performances are 100% at his feet. |