Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-23-2022, 12:31 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:28 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:23 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:18 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:15 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Form since the end of September:-
LWLWLWDLDDWWDLDLLW
6 wins in 18
23 points from 54
15 goals scored - 12 at home, 3 away
Failed to score in 8 games
So no, I don’t have “an agenda against Val”, the form speaks for itself. I hope yesterday gives us the confidence to go on a run. I hope Val succeeds because that means WBA succeed.
this, totally this.
It's not wrong. However you can't be shocked when folks accuse you of having an agenda when you come on and say a game we completely dominated from start to finish by every single metric (including goals for once) was boring or dull.
Wasn't just me though was it. Every single person around us was saying the same stuff, the level of noise from anywhere other than the Smethwick tells you how bored and fed up pretty much everyone is.
We simply never looked like scoring, until Grady came on. it was yet more of the same rubbish. That's not an agenda, it's just how it is.
If you enjoyed our utterly dominant performance then i am very glad for you, nobody I know did. Yes we enjoyed the result, but once again that's not what I am on about.
Stats mean jack all, as they have done all season, we may have had more possession, but we did not look like scoring, until we look more dangerous i will not buy into the well we dominated that because stats say so.
For me, the people I know who went, and for others I overheard on the tram it really was rubbish and felt like papering over the cracks (I heard that at least 5 times from different people as we walked to the tram)
It didn't paper over any cracks, it was a must win that we won. If we don't win Wednesday then I'd say it was all for nothing. However, it could well be the catalyst we needed.
Out of interest, what would have been acceptable for you?
The result was acceptable, but that doesn't make the game suddenly totally enjoyable does it? Doesn't even mean that we played well, scoring 3 against a team that lets in 2 per game.
I must have been one of the very few who said at half time, we're going to score 4 in the second half, as I thought we would.
I'm just fed up of feeling that we play each game like it's an end of season dead rubber, I don't see this intensity that some claim, I don't see the passion that some claim to see. I see a confused bunch of players who keep lumping the same badly hit crosses into the box over and over again, and none of them seem particularly bothered by the bad crosses, the over hit crosses or that without Dike nobody gets / tries to get to them. For me and others I know, it's an overwhelming sense of nothingness, that's how it feels. And yes, that firmly comes into the perception camp of things, there is very little in the matches to get the fire in the belly and to get the fans going, the reaction of the fans bears that feeling out, as it feels like life has been sucked out of us because of what is happening on the pitch. Others will claim it's COVID etc... but we had the passion and fire at the start of the season, and even in the prem, this is firmly to do with perception and feelings as I've said elsewhere.
Football is about emotions and all of that, otherwise it's a dry stats thing in a computer game where you don't even need to watch it. If we had a highly motivated midfielder who shows some of the fire then it might get the fans going and that in turn might get the players going, right now it's a cycle of well nothing from players to fans, to players.... For me, that comes squarely down to the so called style. Hence the chants yesterday about the football being shit. it really is not just me saying these things, and as I've said before I used to be one of the happiest of clappers, so giving my head a wobble, me not having any clue, football not being for me, Albion not being for me and all that tired drivel, well tell me something positive (result excepted) that should be getting fans like me fired up again?
We all hope it's a catalyst, and maybe it will be, from shit covered acorns can mighty oaks grow, and I for one will be happy to admit I'm wrong, and won't gloat if I am not, that's the last thing I want, as that will mean all of my doubts and fears have manifested, and I really don't want that. But expressing concerns on such things on here should be allowed without petty sniping and name calling being bought into it.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
01-23-2022, 12:44 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-23-2022, 12:49 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
XfuckingG my arse! We know we create numerous half chances but not many decent ones, we know we don’t score many goals. We know our crosses, corners and throw-ins have been dreadful for the last twelve or so matches. If a professional football coach cannot recognise where we are failing without looking at graphs and tables on a laptop then he’s shite at his job and we may as well get that McDoughnut bloke back to run the football department.
Seriously I and others have pointed out the bleeding obvious for weeks!
My opinion on stats… they are a very blunt tool to judge football and someone somewhere is getting very rich whilst wearing fuck all flogging the software that supports the ‘science’ behind the game.
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-23-2022, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: XfuckingG my arse! We know we create numerous half chances but not many decent ones, we know we don’t score many goals. We know our crosses, corners and throw-ins have been dreadful for the last twelve or so matches. If a professional football coach cannot recognise this is where we are failing without looking at graphs and tables on a laptop then he’s shite at his job and we may as well get the McDoughnut bloke back to run the football department.
Seriously I and others have pointed out the bleeding obvious for weeks!
Bu bu bu XG is all that matters nowadays Derek... Scoring is not needed as long as the xG says we should have won that's all some care about.
When xG measures the danger of shots and any quality tackles / saves needed to thwart them, then it may be useful. I assume the 3 p[art of our xG relates directly to the 3 goals we scored? Therefore our xG without the goals was actually 0.91? Yes I realise it probably has more to it than that, but well stats can be used anyway one likes.
I wonder what Fulham's xG for yesterday was?
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(01-23-2022, 12:47 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: XfuckingG my arse! We know we create numerous half chances but not many decent ones, we know we don’t score many goals. We know our crosses, corners and throw-ins have been dreadful for the last twelve or so matches. If a professional football coach cannot recognise this is where we are failing without looking at graphs and tables on a laptop then he’s shite at his job and we may as well get the McDoughnut bloke back to run the football department.
Seriously I and others have pointed out the bleeding obvious for weeks!
Bu bu bu XG is all that matters nowadays Derek... Scoring is not needed as long as the xG says we should have won that's all some care about.
When xG measures the danger of shots and any quality tackles / saves needed to thwart them, then it may be useful. I assume the 3 p[art of our xG relates directly to the 3 goals we scored? Therefore our xG without the goals was actually 0.91? Yes I realise it probably has more to it than that, but well stats can be used anyway one likes.
I wonder what Fulham's xG for yesterday was?
So what I think you're saying there is that you wanted us to miss more chances yesterday?
Of course it matters, it shows that barring poor play in front of goal we would be winning games. It's probably the best gauge for how a game has played out there is.
Fulham's xG when they put 6 past Blues in the week was 1.44. just goes to show the difference form, confidence and a finisher can make.
Posts: 852
Threads: 60
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
10
(01-23-2022, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: XfuckingG my arse! We know we create numerous half chances but not many decent ones, we know we don’t score many goals. We know our crosses, corners and throw-ins have been dreadful for the last twelve or so matches. If a professional football coach cannot recognise where we are failing without looking at graphs and tables on a laptop then he’s shite at his job and we may as well get that McDoughnut bloke back to run the football department.
Seriously I and others have pointed out the bleeding obvious for weeks!
My opinion on stats… they are a very blunt tool to judge football and someone somewhere is getting very rich whilst wearing fuck all flogging the software that supports the ‘science’ behind the game.
First my post isn’t about anyone having an agenda. It’s about the way we perceive the game. Everyone is happy to trash the stats but back their perception and emotion. I think it’s just about some balance and I’m not saying either one is more valid.
What does frustrate is an almost evangelical (believe or none believer in stats). xG doesn’t just look at singular chances, it looks at the quality of chance and the historical evidence of the likelihood that chance being taken from actual games. Does that on its say we played well or the game was interesting? Absolutely not.
However, I think it’s a bit rich for people to think their current mindset on Val and the team isn’t causing bias. That’s fair as we’ve been poor for a while as the win/loss stats show. But to think we don’t carry that with us is bonkers.
My personal view is we were better yesterday than the majority of posts (that I have been able to read) suggest - they came for one thing and we were able to negate that and get three points
One final thing…one thing the stats won’t show, is that the biggest thing yesterday was Diang. The rocket seemed to have worked and if that form continues we will be a much better team.
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
(01-23-2022, 12:47 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: XfuckingG my arse! We know we create numerous half chances but not many decent ones, we know we don’t score many goals. We know our crosses, corners and throw-ins have been dreadful for the last twelve or so matches. If a professional football coach cannot recognise this is where we are failing without looking at graphs and tables on a laptop then he’s shite at his job and we may as well get the McDoughnut bloke back to run the football department.
Seriously I and others have pointed out the bleeding obvious for weeks!
Bu bu bu XG is all that matters nowadays Derek... Scoring is not needed as long as the xG says we should have won that's all some care about.
When xG measures the danger of shots and any quality tackles / saves needed to thwart them, then it may be useful. I assume the 3 p[art of our xG relates directly to the 3 goals we scored? Therefore our xG without the goals was actually 0.91? Yes I realise it probably has more to it than that, but well stats can be used anyway one likes.
I wonder what Fulham's xG for yesterday was?
2 of Fulhams goals yesterday were not what you would call 'chances'. 2nd and 3rd i think. Half-chances/wonder strikes at best. Therein lies the difference. Quality front men, mixed in with a bit of luck.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(01-23-2022, 01:18 PM)MrFizz Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:47 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: XfuckingG my arse! We know we create numerous half chances but not many decent ones, we know we don’t score many goals. We know our crosses, corners and throw-ins have been dreadful for the last twelve or so matches. If a professional football coach cannot recognise this is where we are failing without looking at graphs and tables on a laptop then he’s shite at his job and we may as well get the McDoughnut bloke back to run the football department.
Seriously I and others have pointed out the bleeding obvious for weeks!
Bu bu bu XG is all that matters nowadays Derek... Scoring is not needed as long as the xG says we should have won that's all some care about.
When xG measures the danger of shots and any quality tackles / saves needed to thwart them, then it may be useful. I assume the 3 p[art of our xG relates directly to the 3 goals we scored? Therefore our xG without the goals was actually 0.91? Yes I realise it probably has more to it than that, but well stats can be used anyway one likes.
I wonder what Fulham's xG for yesterday was?
2 of Fulhams goals yesterday were not what you would call 'chances'. 2nd and 3rd i think. Half-chances/wonder strikes at best. Therein lies the difference. Quality front men, mixed in with a bit of luck.
Incorrect. It shows that it's all Val's fault.
Posts: 7,412
Threads: 124
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
11
(01-23-2022, 01:19 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-23-2022, 01:18 PM)MrFizz Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:47 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: XfuckingG my arse! We know we create numerous half chances but not many decent ones, we know we don’t score many goals. We know our crosses, corners and throw-ins have been dreadful for the last twelve or so matches. If a professional football coach cannot recognise this is where we are failing without looking at graphs and tables on a laptop then he’s shite at his job and we may as well get the McDoughnut bloke back to run the football department.
Seriously I and others have pointed out the bleeding obvious for weeks!
Bu bu bu XG is all that matters nowadays Derek... Scoring is not needed as long as the xG says we should have won that's all some care about.
When xG measures the danger of shots and any quality tackles / saves needed to thwart them, then it may be useful. I assume the 3 p[art of our xG relates directly to the 3 goals we scored? Therefore our xG without the goals was actually 0.91? Yes I realise it probably has more to it than that, but well stats can be used anyway one likes.
I wonder what Fulham's xG for yesterday was?
2 of Fulhams goals yesterday were not what you would call 'chances'. 2nd and 3rd i think. Half-chances/wonder strikes at best. Therein lies the difference. Quality front men, mixed in with a bit of luck.
Incorrect. It shows that it's all Val's fault.
Posts: 17,074
Threads: 614
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
114
01-23-2022, 01:28 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-23-2022, 01:35 PM by Derek Hardballs.)
(01-23-2022, 01:08 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:47 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: XfuckingG my arse! We know we create numerous half chances but not many decent ones, we know we don’t score many goals. We know our crosses, corners and throw-ins have been dreadful for the last twelve or so matches. If a professional football coach cannot recognise this is where we are failing without looking at graphs and tables on a laptop then he’s shite at his job and we may as well get the McDoughnut bloke back to run the football department.
Seriously I and others have pointed out the bleeding obvious for weeks!
Bu bu bu XG is all that matters nowadays Derek... Scoring is not needed as long as the xG says we should have won that's all some care about.
When xG measures the danger of shots and any quality tackles / saves needed to thwart them, then it may be useful. I assume the 3 p[art of our xG relates directly to the 3 goals we scored? Therefore our xG without the goals was actually 0.91? Yes I realise it probably has more to it than that, but well stats can be used anyway one likes.
I wonder what Fulham's xG for yesterday was?
So what I think you're saying there is that you wanted us to miss more chances yesterday?
Of course it matters, it shows that barring poor play in front of goal we would be winning games. It's probably the best gauge for how a game has played out there is.
Fulham's xG when they put 6 past Blues in the week was 1.44. just goes to show the difference form, confidence and a finisher can make.
You don’t need these stats to know what is going on on the pitch. We can see that our crossing has been poor, we can see that our set pieces have been very poor, we can see that many of those chances that the stats show are no more than half chances, we can see that we aren’t converting enough decent chances we do create. We don’t need a spreadsheet to tell us that we have dominated games but not scored goals, it’s right in front of us when we are watching games.
XG is the new possession stat that was lauded a few years ago as how to judge a game. Oh look we played well and deserved to win because we had 65% of possession said Mowbray fans after every defeat in the Prem.
The game is very simple, made complicated by people who don’t really understand the game so break it down into a pseudo-intellectual puzzle.
Anyway we played ok yesterday, Posh failed to gain the point they came for, we scored the important first goal that allowed us the space to score the second and third, before this we missed a few chances, created some half chances and dominated the game. End of match report.
Posts: 10,546
Threads: 95
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
96
(01-23-2022, 01:28 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: (01-23-2022, 01:08 PM)Ted Maul Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:47 PM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-23-2022, 12:44 PM)Derek Hardballs Wrote: XfuckingG my arse! We know we create numerous half chances but not many decent ones, we know we don’t score many goals. We know our crosses, corners and throw-ins have been dreadful for the last twelve or so matches. If a professional football coach cannot recognise this is where we are failing without looking at graphs and tables on a laptop then he’s shite at his job and we may as well get the McDoughnut bloke back to run the football department.
Seriously I and others have pointed out the bleeding obvious for weeks!
Bu bu bu XG is all that matters nowadays Derek... Scoring is not needed as long as the xG says we should have won that's all some care about.
When xG measures the danger of shots and any quality tackles / saves needed to thwart them, then it may be useful. I assume the 3 p[art of our xG relates directly to the 3 goals we scored? Therefore our xG without the goals was actually 0.91? Yes I realise it probably has more to it than that, but well stats can be used anyway one likes.
I wonder what Fulham's xG for yesterday was?
So what I think you're saying there is that you wanted us to miss more chances yesterday?
Of course it matters, it shows that barring poor play in front of goal we would be winning games. It's probably the best gauge for how a game has played out there is.
Fulham's xG when they put 6 past Blues in the week was 1.44. just goes to show the difference form, confidence and a finisher can make.
You don’t need these stats to know what is going on on the pitch. We can see that our crossing has been poor, we can see that our set pieces have been very poor, we can see that many of those chances that the stats show are no more than half chances, we can see that we aren’t converting enough decent chances we do create. We don’t need a spreadsheet to tell us that we have dominated games but not scored goals, it’s right in front of us when we are watching games.
XG is the new possession stat that was lauded a few years ago as how to judge a game. Oh look we played well and deserved to win because we had 65% of possession said Mowbray fans after every defeat in the Prem.
In fairness, I've taken to xG as the rebuke to those who deny that we are dominating games.
Those who are anti-Val claim we don't create anything, that we haven't deserved to win more than we have. I present the facts to the contrary.
In fairness, possession shouldn't have ever been used to judge a game by anyone who knows what they're talking about. Might explain why it was so widely discussed on here.
|