WBAUnofficial
Perception, Reality, Statistics - Printable Version

+- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk)
+-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3)
+--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Thread: Perception, Reality, Statistics (/showthread.php?tid=23688)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


Perception, Reality, Statistics - BurleyBaggie - 01-23-2022

Very interesting today reading the mix of comments. On the one side you have the ‘it was better, more intensity, more threat’ camp. In the other, ‘we were carp for 70 minutes and only looked dangerous when posh were chasing the game.’

I’m probably in the former, as a flat back 10, wasting time from the get go, used the lowest of low blocks to frustrate. Tempered with a bit of doing it to ourselves, as if Dike had scored first half it’s a different game. 

What occurred to me this morning is the stats, how they suggest we killed them, yet I don’t think anyone thinks this:

- 3.91 xG the highest in the championship yesterday 
- 63% Possession
- 27 shots, 6 on target
- 10 Corners 

What I’m trying to work out is whether our current pessimism is driving bias and we are seeing us through a certain negative lens, or Benjamin Disraeli’s view on statistics is right or maybe a bit of both…


RE: Perception, Reality, Statistics - Tom Joad - 01-23-2022

What the stats overlook is the extreme things like precision or luck. If you have either of those you have a better than average chance. We can't do much about precision-without the tools,  but if you work hard, you can improve your chances of buying a little luck.


RE: Perception, Reality, Statistics - Dumbo - 01-23-2022

Form since the end of September:-

LWLWLWDLDDWWDLDLLW

6 wins in 18
23 points from 54
15 goals scored - 12 at home, 3 away
Failed to score in 8 games

So no, I don’t have “an agenda against Val”, the form speaks for itself. I hope yesterday gives us the confidence to go on a run. I hope Val succeeds because that means WBA succeed.


RE: Perception, Reality, Statistics - MassDebater - 01-23-2022

(01-23-2022, 12:15 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Form since the end of September:-

LWLWLWDLDDWWDLDLLW

6 wins in 18
23 points from 54
15 goals scored - 12 at home, 3 away
Failed to score in 8 games

So no, I don’t have “an agenda against Val”, the form speaks for itself. I hope yesterday gives us the confidence to go on a run. I hope Val succeeds because that means WBA succeed.

this, totally this.


RE: Perception, Reality, Statistics - Ted Maul - 01-23-2022

(01-23-2022, 12:18 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 12:15 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Form since the end of September:-

LWLWLWDLDDWWDLDLLW

6 wins in 18
23 points from 54
15 goals scored - 12 at home, 3 away
Failed to score in 8 games

So no, I don’t have “an agenda against Val”, the form speaks for itself. I hope yesterday gives us the confidence to go on a run. I hope Val succeeds because that means WBA succeed.

this, totally this.

It's not wrong. However you can't be shocked when folks accuse you of having an agenda when you come on and say a game we completely dominated from start to finish by every single metric (including goals for once) was boring or dull.


RE: Perception, Reality, Statistics - MassDebater - 01-23-2022

(01-23-2022, 12:23 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 12:18 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 12:15 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Form since the end of September:-

LWLWLWDLDDWWDLDLLW

6 wins in 18
23 points from 54
15 goals scored - 12 at home, 3 away
Failed to score in 8 games

So no, I don’t have “an agenda against Val”, the form speaks for itself. I hope yesterday gives us the confidence to go on a run. I hope Val succeeds because that means WBA succeed.

this, totally this.

It's not wrong. However you can't be shocked when folks accuse you of having an agenda when you come on and say a game we completely dominated from start to finish by every single metric (including goals for once) was boring or dull.

Wasn't just me though was it. Every single person around us was saying the same stuff, the level of noise from anywhere other than the Smethwick tells you how bored and fed up pretty much everyone is.

We simply never looked like scoring, until Grady came on. it was yet more of the same rubbish. That's not an agenda, it's just how it is.

If you enjoyed our utterly dominant performance then i am very glad for you, nobody I know did. Yes we enjoyed the result, but once again that's not what I am on about.

Stats mean jack all, as they have done all season, we may have had more possession, but we did not look like scoring, until we look more dangerous i will not buy into the well we dominated that because stats say so.

For me, the people I know who went, and for others I overheard on the tram it really was rubbish and felt like papering over the cracks (I heard that at least 5 times from different people as we walked to the tram)


RE: Perception, Reality, Statistics - Derek Hardballs - 01-23-2022

(01-23-2022, 12:05 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Very interesting today reading the mix of comments. On the one side you have the ‘it was better, more intensity, more threat’ camp. In the other, ‘we were carp for 70 minutes and only looked dangerous when posh were chasing the game.’

I’m probably in the former, as a flat back 10, wasting time from the get go, used the lowest of low blocks to frustrate. Tempered with a bit of doing it to ourselves, as if Dike had scored first half it’s a different game. 

What occurred to me this morning is the stats, how they suggest we killed them, yet I don’t think anyone thinks this:

- 3.91 xG the highest in the championship yesterday 
- 63% Possession
- 27 shots, 6 on target
- 10 Corners 

What I’m trying to work out is whether our current pessimism is driving bias and we are seeing us through a certain negative lens, or Benjamin Disraeli’s view on statistics is right or maybe a bit of both…

That’s not what many have said. We played well throughout the match but goals change games. We scored the first goal from a scrappy set piece and Posh then had to change their tactics which allowed us more room to attack them and made it easier to attack and ultimately score. 

The stats are meaningless, it’s the result that matters.

If you want to read anything into the stats it looks like we create a lot of half chances and are guilty of wastefulness when in good positions. This kind of backs up the argument we put aimless crosses, punts, poor set pieces into the box and feed off too many straps rather than create many decent chances.


RE: Perception, Reality, Statistics - Ted Maul - 01-23-2022

(01-23-2022, 12:28 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 12:23 PM)Ted Maul Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 12:18 PM)MassDebater Wrote:
(01-23-2022, 12:15 PM)Dumbo Wrote: Form since the end of September:-

LWLWLWDLDDWWDLDLLW

6 wins in 18
23 points from 54
15 goals scored - 12 at home, 3 away
Failed to score in 8 games

So no, I don’t have “an agenda against Val”, the form speaks for itself. I hope yesterday gives us the confidence to go on a run. I hope Val succeeds because that means WBA succeed.

this, totally this.

It's not wrong. However you can't be shocked when folks accuse you of having an agenda when you come on and say a game we completely dominated from start to finish by every single metric (including goals for once) was boring or dull.

Wasn't just me though was it. Every single person around us was saying the same stuff, the level of noise from anywhere other than the Smethwick tells you how bored and fed up pretty much everyone is.

We simply never looked like scoring, until Grady came on. it was yet more of the same rubbish. That's not an agenda, it's just how it is.

If you enjoyed our utterly dominant performance then i am very glad for you, nobody I know did. Yes we enjoyed the result, but once again that's not what I am on about.

Stats mean jack all, as they have done all season, we may have had more possession, but we did not look like scoring, until we look more dangerous i will not buy into the well we dominated that because stats say so.

For me, the people I know who went, and for others I overheard on the tram it really was rubbish and felt like papering over the cracks (I heard that at least 5 times from different people as we walked to the tram)

It didn't paper over any cracks, it was a must win that we won. If we don't win Wednesday then I'd say it was all for nothing. However, it could well be the catalyst we needed. 

Out of interest, what would have been acceptable for you?


RE: Perception, Reality, Statistics - Lurker#3 - 01-23-2022

I think the biggest problem is the difference between those who only draw conclusions from inferential statistics, such as the ones Dumbo has posted above and those of us who place a much greater importance on more descriptive statistics.

Descriptive statistics, by and large, are what drive hypotheses and what allow us to draw conclusion in the form of inferential statistics.

The fact our descriptive stats are some of the best in the league and our outcomes aren't, points towards external factors playing a big role, such as deep, low blocks and teams time wasting, as well as a lack of quality in important areas of the pitch on our behalf.

As with anything. People will always pick the stats to suit their agenda, and very few of us in this polarised, populist, tribal new world will want to or will change our minds. Sad really.


RE: Perception, Reality, Statistics - TartanRug - 01-23-2022

(01-23-2022, 12:05 PM)BurleyBaggie Wrote: Very interesting today reading the mix of comments. On the one side you have the ‘it was better, more intensity, more threat’ camp. In the other, ‘we were carp for 70 minutes and only looked dangerous when posh were chasing the game.’

I’m probably in the former, as a flat back 10, wasting time from the get go, used the lowest of low blocks to frustrate. Tempered with a bit of doing it to ourselves, as if Dike had scored first half it’s a different game. 

What occurred to me this morning is the stats, how they suggest we killed them, yet I don’t think anyone thinks this:

- 3.91 xG the highest in the championship yesterday 
- 63% Possession
- 27 shots, 6 on target
- 10 Corners 

What I’m trying to work out is whether our current pessimism is driving bias and we are seeing us through a certain negative lens, or Benjamin Disraeli’s view on statistics is right or maybe a bit of both…

Interesting with xg. I was looking at Fulham v Brum and Fulham had 1.44 xg I think it was. Suggests they score more from places where you wouldn't expect a goal very often. We're the opposite with xg exceeding how many we score quite often, suggesting we miss when we should score. Fulham with our xg from yesterday would probably have got 6 or 7!