Monday Madness
#21
I really enjoyed the first half of Bilic's promotion season, loads of entertaining games and good football.
Second half of the season was hard work.

Not a massive fan of Ismaels football, but it would be a better watch with better players in some key positions   particularly wing back.
Reply
#22
(01-17-2022, 03:12 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 03:07 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 02:51 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote: Is it just me that doesn't think we've been 'utter rubbish' this season?

Defense has been mostly solid bar a few individual mistakes, clearly intending to play on the front foot and mostly in the opposition half. Thing is we don't have creative, skillful players, we have pretty average workhorses with a smattering of skill here and there.

I thought we played worse than this under Bilic after lockdown that's for sure, and definately so in the prem.

Isn't that the sort of player Val wants in his side though?

Don't know.

He certainly really wanted to fit Grady in, I do know that.

Be interesting to see who he actually wants to sign. Personally if I was building a team for his style, the skill is in the wing back positions and the two wider forwards. Midfield is for winning and moving the ball quickly.

Robertson and TAA are key attacking players for Klippety, even with the wealth of talent they have up front.   And there is a reason Pep spent hundreds of millions on full backs (£50 million for Kyle Walker seemed bonkers at the time, but...) to try and find the right combo.  Real key positions in modern football. Klopp doesn't really have a playmaker in Keira, Henderson or Fabhino although they can all hit a pass due to the level Liverpool are at.
Reply
#23
(01-17-2022, 02:24 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 02:04 PM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote: Slav should've in hindsight been let go of before we went into the PL

Meh, I'm no fan of Slav but that would have been very unfair, and would have caused a lot of unrest.

That summers recruitment was a bigger fuck up.

True, would've been very difficult to do, as the fans and a portion of the squad would've gone ballistic. 

Purely hypothetically on performances/stats though, it would've been a justified decision.
Reply
#24
(01-18-2022, 07:01 AM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 02:24 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:
(01-17-2022, 02:04 PM)AmsterdamBaggie Wrote: Slav should've in hindsight been let go of before we went into the PL

Meh, I'm no fan of Slav but that would have been very unfair, and would have caused a lot of unrest.

That summers recruitment was a bigger fuck up.

True, would've been very difficult to do, as the fans and a portion of the squad would've gone ballistic. 

Purely hypothetically on performances/stats though, it would've been a justified decision.

Thing is, it was quite clear early on that Bilic had no interest in being the manager of a PL club with a minuscule budget and was looking for a way out, hence all the nonsense he was spouting to the media when Hegazi was sold. The glorious benefit of hindsight, there should have been a mutual parting of the ways when we got promoted. But yes, fans blinded by their adoration of Slav would have blamed our apparently evil board.
Reply
#25
Squid Wrote:
AmsterdamBaggie Wrote:
Birdman1811 Wrote:
AmsterdamBaggie Wrote:Slav should've in hindsight been let go of before we went into the PL

Meh, I'm no fan of Slav but that would have been very unfair, and would have caused a lot of unrest.

That summers recruitment was a bigger fuck up.

True, would've been very difficult to do, as the fans and a portion of the squad would've gone ballistic. 

Purely hypothetically on performances/stats though, it would've been a justified decision.

Thing is, it was quite clear early on that Bilic had no interest in being the manager of a PL club with a minuscule budget and was looking for a way out, hence all the nonsense he was spouting to the media when Hegazi was sold. The glorious benefit of hindsight, there should have been a mutual parting of the ways when we got promoted. But yes, fans blinded by their adoration of Slav would have blamed our apparently evil board.
Hindsight indeed. I too would have gone ballistic had Slav been sacked after promotion. It also would have further damaged our reputation as a managers graveyard. How could the fans ever be privy to the inner workings? Slav brought us some great football and some very promising players, he made pro-active subs and the team did not know when they were beaten. In  lockdown, everyone at the club went into a deep coma. Someone way closer to the training ground should have noticed the lack of fitness and Slav's indifference to staying on and should have seen the rift between Bilic and the DoF and the damage it was doing to our budget. We shot ourselves in the foot the year Pulis and Pardew managed to get a top half Premiership side relegated, and blew a hole in the other foot during that summer after promotion.
If we are to continue with an absentee owner then he would be in a much better position if he appointed somebody that knows how a football club works. We're currently worse off behind the glass doors than when Megsons dad was collecting Shell points.
Reply
#26
I wouldn't rush to get him back. But let's not forget that from September to season end we were never outside the top 2. Under Ismael we are struggling to maintain a top 6 position. I would far prefer Bilic to Ismael.
Reply
#27
(01-18-2022, 09:05 AM)Cunninghamismagic Wrote: I wouldn't rush to get him back. But let's not forget that from September to season end we were never outside the top 2. Under Ismael we are struggling to maintain a top 6 position. I would far prefer Bilic to Ismael.

With Pereira, a Purple patch HRK, an in firm Diangana and confident, in form Sawyers...

Still looked like conceding every time a team attacked.
Reply
#28
I'll always look back on the first half of Slav's time here with great fondness. There was a feel-good factor, attacking football that we hadn't seen in years with young hungry players. But lets not forget that there was some turgid shite thrown in for good measure. Wigan away, PNE away, Blues away (saved by Austin), Barnsley at home, Boro at home, Wigan at home. Leading to the same criticisms we're hearing now (no 'Plan B' etc). After the restart we were mostly shite and unfit, and the less said about the first few months of the PL season the better.
Reply
#29
People see Bilic's tenure through the rose tinted spectacles of promotion. 

But things were going wrong long before we got promoted. 

The contrast between the first half of the season and the second is stark.

The first half on course to over 100 points and failed to score in only 1 match.

Second half of the season we got 31/32 points, replicated over the whole season probably not enough to get into the play offs.  We failed to score in 7 games, nearly one third and that with Pereria in the side.

And people wonder why we struggle to score now, it's been a live issue for 2 years now.

It's really sad to have to admit that first half season under Bilic was an outlier, in what has been a period of gradual decline .
Reply
#30
(01-18-2022, 10:06 AM)Shabby Russian Wrote: People see Bilic's tenure through the rose tinted spectacles of promotion. 

But things were going wrong long before we got promoted. 

The contrast between the first half of the season and the second is stark.

The first half on course to over 100 points and failed to score in only 1 match.

Second half of the season we got 31/32 points, replicated over the whole season probably not enough to get into the play offs.  We failed to score in 7 games, nearly one third and that with Pereria in the side.

And people wonder why we struggle to score now, it's been a live issue for 2 years now.

It's really sad to have to admit that first half season under Bilic was an outlier, in what has been a period of gradual decline .

Is the truth.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)