Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
we don't have the luxury of the Liverpool's and Man U's, it's a bit of a meh comparison. I'm sure there are other less successful clubs who have tried 'philosophy' managers and have failed even more so than Six is with us.
The board think they're in this for the long haul, simply because they were sold on 'well look what he did with no money at Barnsley, surely with a bit of cash and our existing squad being better than Barnsely's it cannot fail, can it', is what I believe the board are / were thinking. There's no plan B from them as much as Six is likely to try a slightly different tactic during a game.
Posts: 669
Threads: 36
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation:
2
Good post.
VI plays a certain style and will need players who can play it. It seems we don't. So we either stick with the coach (and find the right player) or the players (and find the right coach).
I remember a few pointing out Liverpools defensive weakness's, was it the players or the coach?
Posts: 9,616
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(01-17-2022, 04:06 PM)MassDebater Wrote: we don't have the luxury of the Liverpool's and Man U's, it's a bit of a meh comparison. I'm sure there are other less successful clubs who have tried 'philosophy' managers and have failed even more so than Six is with us.
The board think they're in this for the long haul, simply because they were sold on 'well look what he did with no money at Barnsley, surely with a bit of cash and our existing squad being better than Barnsely's it cannot fail, can it', is what I believe the board are / were thinking. There's no plan B from them as much as Six is likely to try a slightly different tactic during a game.
In recent years most clubs who have got up have had a "journey" or a "project" before their success.
Norwich, Brentford, Burnley, Brighton, Sheff Utd, Hudds, Leeds.
Many clubs with former glories that perhaps were victim of trying to keep pace with the Jones', and then had to re-establish themselves. Many on that list have clear and varying identities.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 10,863
Threads: 497
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
23
01-17-2022, 08:51 PM
(This post was last modified: 01-17-2022, 08:52 PM by Peachy.)
If the board are going to back Val long term then great. The problem is Val needs to stop this rot/malaise bloody quickly or he is going to force the boards hand as it will become toxic.
Despite what anyone says about injuries, suspensions etc Val is under performing massively at the moment with the players he has at his disposal. We are dropping like a stone and as far as I can see we are blindly walking into every game doing exactly the same as the game prior.
I absolutely love his passion and his drive but I have grave doubts about his methods and in game management.
Posts: 12,682
Threads: 1,158
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
15
(01-17-2022, 02:56 PM)Lurker#3 Wrote: Am I allowed to call them bin dippers? 
What else would they be called?!?
Posts: 270
Threads: 3
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
0
Great post. My take on the comparison, is that with Liverpool, Klopp was/is given the resources (money/players) to suit his style. Also, he had enough clout to say “my philosophy works, just do it better”. Unfortunately, we as West Brom do not have those resources, or players with the ability, willingness or intelligence to adapt. The big question for me is will the board back Val, and his philosophy even with poor results/performances, or sack him and start again with a more “traditional” approach. Big questions, risks either way.
Posts: 19,492
Threads: 824
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
60
It’s also worth considering that Liverpool had a board who’d done painstaking research before plumping for Klopp, and although roundly mocked at the time, introduced their transfer acquisition panel which put recruitment of the right players at the heart of everything they did.
They had/have a plan that runs through the core of the club and have top quality people like Michael Edwards and Klopp in key positions. We have a half way house where Val is left to hold the whole ship together whilst general football administration failure Ron Gourlay chucks in an invoice every couple weeks.
Whilst it’s true Klopp had money to spend, it was a fraction of what the clubs around him spent, with a lot of it being raised through selling players (mainly to Eddie Howe) for vastly inflated sums.
Put simply, I agree with what you’re saying Birdie, but the infrastructure needs to greatly improve if we are giving balls deep on Val, and Val needs to foster his relationship with the fans in the way Klopp did as it’s getting very, very edgy.
Posts: 15,278
Threads: 273
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
57
(01-18-2022, 08:10 AM)SW4Baggie Wrote: It’s also worth considering that Liverpool had a board who’d done painstaking research before plumping for Klopp, and although roundly mocked at the time, introduced their transfer acquisition panel which put recruitment of the right players at the heart of everything they did.
They had/have a plan that runs through the core of the club and have top quality people like Michael Edwards and Klopp in key positions. We have a half way house where Val is left to hold the whole ship together whilst general football administration failure Ron Gourlay chucks in an invoice every couple weeks.
Whilst it’s true Klopp had money to spend, it was a fraction of what the clubs around him spent, with a lot of it being raised through selling players (mainly to Eddie Howe) for vastly inflated sums.
Put simply, I agree with what you’re saying Birdie, but the infrastructure needs to greatly improve if we are giving balls deep on Val, and Val needs to foster his relationship with the fans in the way Klopp did as it’s getting very, very edgy.
Agreed.
Posts: 974
Threads: 11
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
2
01-18-2022, 08:25 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-18-2022, 08:30 AM by Lillwall's left foot.)
(01-18-2022, 03:29 AM)Pfister Wrote: Great post. My take on the comparison, is that with Liverpool, Klopp was/is given the resources (money/players) to suit his style. Also, he had enough clout to say “my philosophy works, just do it better”. Unfortunately, we as West Brom do not have those resources, or players with the ability, willingness or intelligence to adapt. The big question for me is will the board back Val, and his philosophy even with poor results/performances, or sack him and start again with a more “traditional” approach. Big questions, risks either way.
FWIW I think the board will back Val. My reasoning behind this is the Fat Sam fiasco. The board knee jerked (rightly or wrongly) and bought in what they thought was a sure thing with Mr Never Been Relegated. However
Pay off for Slav + SA salary + increased wages = same result. Hammerings and relegation.
The evidence would suggest that this has shaped their thinking towards the "project". And spending £7 million on a CF would evidence the backing.
This is my only frustration with a lot of the posts. I get a lot of fans want him gone, they are frustrated and it's their opinion, but nothing suggests that the owners feel the same so the expectation that he'll be under serious pressure if we don't win next weekend feels hopeful at best on their part.
In addition I also can't see how we will be weaker next year if we don't go up. We have ZERO players that PL teams might target, Val will have had another window and a couple more of the kids (including a 21 year old Dike) will be established.
Just can't see it myself. And going back to Liverpool I also look to them. More money, better quality of player but same change to the system and force of the managers personality. Klopp needed his players before he achieved success, it was a couple of years before they made the step up with Van Dike being the last piece in the puzzle.
Posts: 15,040
Threads: 339
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
93
SW4Baggie Wrote:It’s also worth considering that Liverpool had a board who’d done painstaking research before plumping for Klopp, and although roundly mocked at the time, introduced their transfer acquisition panel which put recruitment of the right players at the heart of everything they did.
They had/have a plan that runs through the core of the club and have top quality people like Michael Edwards and Klopp in key positions. We have a half way house where Val is left to hold the whole ship together whilst general football administration failure Ron Gourlay chucks in an invoice every couple weeks.
Whilst it’s true Klopp had money to spend, it was a fraction of what the clubs around him spent, with a lot of it being raised through selling players (mainly to Eddie Howe) for vastly inflated sums.
Put simply, I agree with what you’re saying Birdie, but the infrastructure needs to greatly improve if we are giving balls deep on Val, and Val needs to foster his relationship with the fans in the way Klopp did as it’s getting very, very edgy. I agree hugely re the infrastructure. We simply must get the best DoF available. Or else we just go see-sawing between managers and their different methods like a husband and wife team arguing over the map while driving through an unfamiliar city. Sometimes, it is not simply the manager and pointing at other clubs and their apparent recent resurgence does no good at all.
|