![]() |
|
Liverpool. - Printable Version +- WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk) +-- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=3) +--- Forum: WBAUnofficial (https://wbaunofficial.org.uk/forumdisplay.php?fid=4) +--- Thread: Liverpool. (/showthread.php?tid=23581) |
Liverpool. - Birdman1811 - 01-17-2022 Chatting to a Liverpool fan about Klopp, they said so much of the same our fans do about Val early on. Klopps personality helped him a lot. No plan B, one formation, one tactic. More interested in his philosophy than improving players, players going backwards under him, definately won't do it long term. A few even called to sack him after the Europa League loss as he early wasn't Liverpool level. This is the problem with 'Philosophy' managers, short term they don't always do too well, of course Liverpool had a pretty good squad and resources. However if given the chance, they may develop something much more enduring. Do our board have the guts to see this out and hope it pays off? Every chance it won't too, its no guarantee of success. We can't go back to bouncing from one type of manager to another when the average life span of our managers is a season at most it seems. If they are seeing it through, he needs to be backed, he needs a squad developed for his ideals, not patched together. If we wanted a short term fix, Wilder was the right man. Not saying keep him because of this, more a conversation starter on what the club is thinking and trying to do. RE: Liverpool. - Spandaubaggie - 01-17-2022 This is a good post Birdy- a different way of looking at it. Perhaps with the right players this system can work, but in the short-term we do have to see improvement as the natives are getting restless. RE: Liverpool. - Lurker#3 - 01-17-2022 Good post Birdy. Similarly to my post about Utd and Us. My missus is from Birkenhead and a lot of her friends and family are Red, and I remember these discussions back when quite clearly. And even today it doesn't take them long to start getting pissy about not playing 2 out and out forwards, or not having more progressive midfielders. After all this is why they signed Thiago, to try and improve them but quickly realised he completely throws their entire shape, structure and playing style out of kilter. P.s. Am I allowed to call them bin dippers?
RE: Liverpool. - Big Daddy Cool - 01-17-2022 Klopp came to Liverpool as one of the best managers in the world and had the reputation of building a great team in Dortmund so earned patience. He also has a brand of football that's great to watch. The problem is we don't look as though we're making progess in fact we are getting worse. If you look at Val's CV he doesn't stay at clubs long so there's nothing there for me to think that he should be given time. The aim is to get promotion as quickly as possible and then stay up. If those targets don't look like being met then the manager goes. Our fanbase is growing increasingly bored and frustrated and Val needs results in the next few games otherwise I can see it turning nasty. RE: Liverpool. - Birdman1811 - 01-17-2022 (01-17-2022, 03:03 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Klopp came to Liverpool as one of the best managers in the world and had the reputation of building a great team in Dortmund so earned patience. He also has a brand of football that's great to watch. Don't disagree at all. It's a very risky strategy and as said certainly doesn't mean it'll be successful if he's backed and given the time. However if the board are intent on seeing it through, they need to show it, Dike was a prime example of that to be fair. Originally there was no January budget then some was made to get him in. The club needs a culture. Since Ashworth left there hasn't been any form of underlying culture or plan at the club at all. Pulis kept something going in his way, but it'd never long term as the squad gets older and older. RE: Liverpool. - Birdman1811 - 01-17-2022 And as always, I don't give a flying fuck about great to watch, that's subjective. I detest seeing goals conceded, would rather just score one and have a clean sheet than win 5-4. RE: Liverpool. - Lightnin - 01-17-2022 (01-17-2022, 03:08 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:(01-17-2022, 03:03 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Klopp came to Liverpool as one of the best managers in the world and had the reputation of building a great team in Dortmund so earned patience. He also has a brand of football that's great to watch. There was a budget, there has always been a healthy budget to sign players but we were constricted by the wage bill. Maybe there has been something happen internally that wasn't on payroll staff that has helped create a bit of room? Whatever it was, it was needed. Val still has positions that he wants to strengthen, he's desperate for another centre midfielder as he can see the issue that we've got but I'd also point to the fact that he signed Molumby and hasn't played him. I can see why he thought Molumby would be ideal though and now I've seen him, I can also see why he often doesn't get picked. I get your opening post though, very good point made. RE: Liverpool. - Bob Fossil - 01-17-2022 You are comparing him with a very successful "philosophy" manager, there are many others whose "philosophy" failed miserably. We also have to factor in money. Liverpool had enough for Klopp to transition the squad far quicker than we can. Ideally we needed someone with an ultimate goal, as in the way we play, but a bit more flexibility and experience in the interim. I fully agree that we need a plan and a clear direction and was optimistic when we got Val, but, as always, I believe 50% of what I hear and 100% of what I see and despite Val's wise words and pontificating, I just don't see it translating on the pitch. At this moment in time, I don't see him succeeding, but, as ever, come Saturday I will behind him all the way. RE: Liverpool. - Big Daddy Cool - 01-17-2022 (01-17-2022, 03:08 PM)Birdman1811 Wrote:(01-17-2022, 03:03 PM)Big Daddy Cool Wrote: Klopp came to Liverpool as one of the best managers in the world and had the reputation of building a great team in Dortmund so earned patience. He also has a brand of football that's great to watch. Agree we definitely need a long term plan at the club with a DOF. We seem to go from one manager to the next with each having their own style of playing football and wanting certain players to fit that and its getting us nowhere. We need a vision at the club of how we're going to play, what sort of players we'll target and the manager should come in and fit the philosophy of the club. RE: Liverpool. - Birdman1811 - 01-17-2022 As said, this isn’t a "Must give him time." Post, more a look at the boards thinking and plan, and why the usual short term solution may not be in play here. I have concerns, I know in the modern, black and white, hyperbole world me not calling for him to be sacked, his family slaughtered and all mention of his name illegal means I support him totally. (Not here thankfully, this place stays a bastion of rationality somehow.) However I can get why the board may be in this for the long haul, if so, he needs backing and support from them, guess that's my point though here. |