Elvis Costello- Oliver's Army (is no longer on its way)
#41
(01-13-2022, 12:28 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-13-2022, 09:30 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I see a fist being shaken at a cloud Spandau. 

There’s millions of offensive songs out there, go listen to the Macc Lads if you want your daily fill.

Dr Jimmy by The Who surprises me that it is still around, I think it’s a great song, but it has some “contentious” lyrics. If you take it in the context of the song about the split personality then it makes sense and is slightly less offensive.

True enough CA, but mainstream hits of the past that are part of the fabric of our rich pop culture is a different thing.

I don't know how there could be a poll finding out the real thoughts of people, but I would say the overwhelming majority in society are very concerned about cancel culture and revisiting the past with a 2020s lens.

There is a very vocal minority, mostly very left of centre that dictate an awful lot of media output now generally through nothing more than taking to social media to vent their outrage. As I've said before I've friends in their 30s, Uni educated lads and they feel the same.

On a separate lighter issue Accidents Will Happen is my favourite Elvis Costello song.

As a species, we've consistently revisited the past with a contemporary lens. Things have always been 'cancelled'. I could list examples, but you can probably think of a fair few yourself. 

Whether or not you agree with the current lens, you are (unfortunately for you) metaphorically shaking your fist at a cloud, whether you like it or not.

I suppose you could hold out for things to be 're-evaluated', it does happen....

I suspect I'm older than you. I've learnt that after you get to a certain age it doesn't matter what you think any more - that ship has sailed. It's not fair, but I'm okay with that. I had my turn and I didn't listen then either!

FWIW, If I was going to be contentious, I would argue that it is my generation that is self-entitled and easily outraged. Why should the young leave things as they were? We didn't!

If the 'art' holds up, it will still be as good with the contentious bits taken out. If it doesn't work quite as well, you can still buy it online and enjoy it. I don't think you need to be panic-buying dvd's of 'Are you being Served?' and 'Oliver's Army (the original Mix)' just yet! Wink
Reply
#42
Lipstick vogue

Great drumming on that track
Reply
#43
(01-13-2022, 01:37 PM)Duffers Wrote: Pump it up is alright but never really clicked with Costello. Saw him at Glastonbury once and found him rather dull.

I thought he was a bit pretentious.
Reply
#44
(01-13-2022, 09:46 AM)Gzbaggy Wrote: Has Some Girls by the Stones been retired yet?

Probably not but not heard Schoolboy Blues on Radio 1 lately.
Reply
#45
(01-13-2022, 01:55 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(01-13-2022, 12:28 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-13-2022, 09:30 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I see a fist being shaken at a cloud Spandau. 

There’s millions of offensive songs out there, go listen to the Macc Lads if you want your daily fill.

Dr Jimmy by The Who surprises me that it is still around, I think it’s a great song, but it has some “contentious” lyrics. If you take it in the context of the song about the split personality then it makes sense and is slightly less offensive.

True enough CA, but mainstream hits of the past that are part of the fabric of our rich pop culture is a different thing.

I don't know how there could be a poll finding out the real thoughts of people, but I would say the overwhelming majority in society are very concerned about cancel culture and revisiting the past with a 2020s lens.

There is a very vocal minority, mostly very left of centre that dictate an awful lot of media output now generally through nothing more than taking to social media to vent their outrage. As I've said before I've friends in their 30s, Uni educated lads and they feel the same.

On a separate lighter issue Accidents Will Happen is my favourite Elvis Costello song.

As a species, we've consistently revisited the past with a contemporary lens. Things have always been 'cancelled'. I could list examples, but you can probably think of a fair few yourself. 

Whether or not you agree with the current lens, you are (unfortunately for you) metaphorically shaking your fist at a cloud, whether you like it or not.

I suppose you could hold out for things to be 're-evaluated', it does happen....

I suspect I'm older than you. I've learnt that after you get to a certain age it doesn't matter what you think any more - that ship has sailed. It's not fair, but I'm okay with that. I had my turn and I didn't listen then either!

FWIW, If I was going to be contentious, I would argue that it is my generation that is self-entitled and easily outraged. Why should the young leave things as they were? We didn't!

If the 'art' holds up, it will still be as good with the contentious bits taken out. If it doesn't work quite as well, you can still buy it online and enjoy it. I don't think you need to be panic-buying dvd's of 'Are you being Served?' and 'Oliver's Army (the original Mix)' just yet! Wink
I don't know FB, many might want to here about Mollie Sugden's pussy still?

There's a lot of validity in what you say, but when we have the likes of JK Rowling seriously damaged as an icon for daring to say there is a thing called biological gender we do have issues. People find themselves being distanced as for daring to have an opinion that isn't going with the flow.

Do watch David Baddiel programme recently on social media anger if you haven't.

we're all part of a huge debate in strange times.
Reply
#46
(01-13-2022, 01:55 PM)fuzzbox Wrote:
(01-13-2022, 12:28 PM)Spandaubaggie Wrote:
(01-13-2022, 09:30 AM)CA Baggie Wrote: I see a fist being shaken at a cloud Spandau. 

There’s millions of offensive songs out there, go listen to the Macc Lads if you want your daily fill.

Dr Jimmy by The Who surprises me that it is still around, I think it’s a great song, but it has some “contentious” lyrics. If you take it in the context of the song about the split personality then it makes sense and is slightly less offensive.

True enough CA, but mainstream hits of the past that are part of the fabric of our rich pop culture is a different thing.

I don't know how there could be a poll finding out the real thoughts of people, but I would say the overwhelming majority in society are very concerned about cancel culture and revisiting the past with a 2020s lens.

There is a very vocal minority, mostly very left of centre that dictate an awful lot of media output now generally through nothing more than taking to social media to vent their outrage. As I've said before I've friends in their 30s, Uni educated lads and they feel the same.

On a separate lighter issue Accidents Will Happen is my favourite Elvis Costello song.

As a species, we've consistently revisited the past with a contemporary lens. Things have always been 'cancelled'. I could list examples, but you can probably think of a fair few yourself. 

Whether or not you agree with the current lens, you are (unfortunately for you) metaphorically shaking your fist at a cloud, whether you like it or not.

I suppose you could hold out for things to be 're-evaluated', it does happen....

I suspect I'm older than you. I've learnt that after you get to a certain age it doesn't matter what you think any more - that ship has sailed. It's not fair, but I'm okay with that. I had my turn and I didn't listen then either!

FWIW, If I was going to be contentious, I would argue that it is my generation that is self-entitled and easily outraged. Why should the young leave things as they were? We didn't!

If the 'art' holds up, it will still be as good with the contentious bits taken out. If it doesn't work quite as well, you can still buy it online and enjoy it. I don't think you need to be panic-buying dvd's of 'Are you being Served?' and 'Oliver's Army (the original Mix)' just yet! Wink

That’s a great point.
Reply
#47
This is it though, JK Rowling hasn't been seriously damaged as an icon.  To the vast, vast majority of the world she is a highly succesful author of children's books.  She's only a transphobe in the eyes of the people who decide to attach themselves to that cause and rant about it on the only social media site that gives a shit - Twitter.  Maybe the Guardian wrote about it too.  But nobody has succesfully 'cancelled' JK Rowling.
Reply
#48
can you give examples of things that have been "cancelled" in the past?

Clockwork Orange?
Relax - Frankie Goes to Hollywood


Perhaps we were more enlightened in the past
Reply
#49
(01-13-2022, 03:45 PM)Gzbaggy Wrote: can you give examples of things that have been "cancelled" in the past?

Clockwork Orange?
Relax - Frankie Goes to Hollywood


Perhaps we were more enlightened in the past

Life of Brian
The Exorcist
National Socialism

(01-13-2022, 03:08 PM)SophLad Wrote: This is it though, JK Rowling hasn't been seriously damaged as an icon.  To the vast, vast majority of the world she is a highly succesful author of children's books.  She's only a transphobe in the eyes of the people who decide to attach themselves to that cause and rant about it on the only social media site that gives a shit - Twitter.  Maybe the Guardian wrote about it too.  But nobody has succesfully 'cancelled' JK Rowling.

This is the point I always try to make on threads like these. There are people who seem to believe that there is a rabbid woke mob out there trying to cancel anything and everything. There really isn’t, there never has been, I’m more than happy to concede that there are a small number of irritatingly loud “ban everything” idiots out there, but the actual numbers are really quite small.

There are always more people offended by the idea that something causes offence than those who are actually offended.
Reply
#50
(01-13-2022, 03:08 PM)SophLad Wrote: This is it though, JK Rowling hasn't been seriously damaged as an icon.  To the vast, vast majority of the world she is a highly succesful author of children's books.  She's only a transphobe in the eyes of the people who decide to attach themselves to that cause and rant about it on the only social media site that gives a shit - Twitter.  Maybe the Guardian wrote about it too.  But nobody has succesfully 'cancelled' JK Rowling.

Well, whilst the word cancelled may be harsh, she's been damaged and continues to be. Here's an example in recent weeks. https://www.express.co.uk/news/uk/154455...ans-rights

I had to, not so long ago, give media advice to a very senior barrister against all kinds of abuse he got for tweeting about an ex legal big wig who'd died, just for saying he agreed this chap was right above a smart appearance in court helping people get on.

He got heaps of abuse from Rastafarian barristers etc, etc, and it went off on a right hideous angle, when it was totally innocuous, and the Times came calling for this chap, so I had to help him get out of this mess.

He's now taken himself off social media- one of the leading legal minds in this country. He says it's not worth the hassle as people are looking for rows and offence.

This is a huge debate, but trying to make out it's much ado about nothing clearly isn't so.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)