Squad 22/23, the evolution.
#11
(01-11-2022, 10:31 AM)MrFizz Wrote: Pretty decent assessment there. But i think Molumby is loan to perm, he'll be here. I think Jake might still be around but as CB cover. It seems to suit him.

As good a fullback as Townsend is he aint no wing-back. Might get some decent money for him to fund a couple.

I would have thought it's a loan to perm if both parties want to make it one? So far, other than a couple of decent cameos from the bench, I've been very underwhelmed with him. I think the fee is around £1m if I recall correctly? I'd like to think we could invest that amount more prudently with a lower league or overseas player. (Don't ask me who as don't watch enough footy these days - Someone on this forum has mentioned Kamara from Plymouth as an option?)
Reply
#12
(01-11-2022, 10:26 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Harsh to say that Ajayi has a clanger a game in him, and Kipre is improving game on game... when the latter has played a major roll in losing us a point and then got sent off...costing us a 4th round game...(which could be a blessing). Personally I think all of our defenders have the potential for clangers in games. Then again, playing in defence such clangers tend be a lot more noticeable and costly than say midfield clangers (unless of the level of Sawyers v Leeds)

Our defence though, in the main isn't a problem area.

No really, Ajayi is a liability. Kipre has promise and is a lot younger. I'm not sure why Kean Bryan has been discarded by Lurker. He signed a 2 year deal and is also younger than Bartley and Ajayi.
Reply
#13
(01-11-2022, 10:59 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 10:26 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Harsh to say that Ajayi has a clanger a game in him, and Kipre is improving game on game... when the latter has played a major roll in losing us a point and then got sent off...costing us a 4th round game...(which could be a blessing). Personally I think all of our defenders have the potential for clangers in games. Then again, playing in defence such clangers tend be a lot more noticeable and costly than say midfield clangers (unless of the level of Sawyers v Leeds)

Our defence though, in the main isn't a problem area.

No really, Ajayi is a liability. Kipre has promise and is a lot younger. I'm not sure why Kean Bryan has been discarded by Lurker. He signed a 2 year deal and is also younger than Bartley and Ajayi.

I thought it was a short term signing to cover Dara. In which case we will find it harder to let him go I guess
"IMO of course..."
Reply
#14
(01-11-2022, 11:01 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 10:59 AM)Cheshire East Baggie Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 10:26 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Harsh to say that Ajayi has a clanger a game in him, and Kipre is improving game on game... when the latter has played a major roll in losing us a point and then got sent off...costing us a 4th round game...(which could be a blessing). Personally I think all of our defenders have the potential for clangers in games. Then again, playing in defence such clangers tend be a lot more noticeable and costly than say midfield clangers (unless of the level of Sawyers v Leeds)

Our defence though, in the main isn't a problem area.

No really, Ajayi is a liability. Kipre has promise and is a lot younger. I'm not sure why Kean Bryan has been discarded by Lurker. He signed a 2 year deal and is also younger than Bartley and Ajayi.

I thought it was a short term signing to cover Dara. In which case we will find it harder to let him go I guess

Give the guy a chance. He may be OK. I certainly haven't been wowed by Clarke, although I have to admit that it's partly because I don't understand how such a young player can look so old.

Apart from O'Shea, is any single one of our centre backs remotely in the same league as McAuley, Evans, Hegazi, Olsson, Dawson, Lescott?
Reply
#15
Would like to see Griffiths get the nod from next season, always performed well out on loan and is highly rated by the club.

I would look to sign Clarke, I've been impressed with much of what I've seen. Likewise, Kipre is improving. Bartley has a year or so left and often performs better as skipper, I'd give him the armband full time.

Townsend is inconsistent, I think he's found his level. Furlong too is hit and miss. Agree with whoever made the point about Furlong potentially being an option on the right of the back three. We'd need a couple of new wing backs. Middlesbrough must have some good ones if they're willing to let Spence go out on loan, he would be a great signing in that position.

The middle of midfield needs a lot of work. Mowatt is fine and I'd like to see him given a go with TGH, the game at Cov was one of our better midfield displays recently and I reckon the game passes TGH by a little when he's at wing back. Livermore should be moved on, likewise Snodgrass. Molumby don't we have a deal in place? Wouldn't be the worst option providing the fee is low. I'm not sure Castro is anywhere near ready yet.

Don't think Phillips will go anywhere after his contract extension. Grant, Robinson are both fine. Diangana is a weird one, if we can't get him firing second half of the season perhaps a loan deal away to see if he can rediscover some form would be a decent shout? Dike I have high hopes for but we will need more in reserve than just Cleary.

There's a good amount of work to be done there but all the noises Val has made about long term recruitment are positive. He deserves a summer window where he is backed to bring in his own players.
Reply
#16
(01-11-2022, 11:13 AM)Ted Maul Wrote: Would like to see Griffiths get the nod from next season, always performed well out on loan and is highly rated by the club.

I would look to sign Clarke, I've been impressed with much of what I've seen. Likewise, Kipre is improving. Bartley has a year or so left and often performs better as skipper, I'd give him the armband full time.

Townsend is inconsistent, I think he's found his level. Furlong too is hit and miss. Agree with whoever made the point about Furlong potentially being an option on the right of the back three. We'd need a couple of new wing backs. Middlesbrough must have some good ones if they're willing to let Spence go out on loan, he would be a great signing in that position.

The middle of midfield needs a lot of work. Mowatt is fine and I'd like to see him given a go with TGH, the game at Cov was one of our better midfield displays recently and I reckon the game passes TGH by a little when he's at wing back. Livermore should be moved on, likewise Snodgrass. Molumby don't we have a deal in place? Wouldn't be the worst option providing the fee is low. I'm not sure Castro is anywhere near ready yet.

Don't think Phillips will go anywhere after his contract extension. Grant, Robinson are both fine. Diangana is a weird one, if we can't get him firing second half of the season perhaps a loan deal away to see if he can rediscover some form would be a decent shout? Dike I have high hopes for but we will need more in reserve than just Cleary.

There's a good amount of work to be done there but all the noises Val has made about long term recruitment are positive. He deserves a summer window where he is backed to bring in his own players.

Next season, if we are in the Champ, without any additions we could still line up:

Button
O'Shea Bartley Kipre
Furlong TGH Mowatt Townsend
Phillips Dike Grant

Griffith, Bryan, Ajayi, Reach, Diangana, Robinson and potentially Molumby.

That's without including C.Taylor, Ingram, Tulloch... 

With a couple of additions, that side is still capable of maintaining a top 6 finish,

Sadly I imagine Zohore will still be either here, or we'll be feeling the cost of paying off his contract.
Reply
#17
No Cleary in that lot SW4? Watching him on saturday, and it is a bit harsh based on one game under the circumstances (10 men) but I thought he would be more suited to a front 2 than the system we play, in the traditional big fella (Dike) and fast fella combination in a 4-4-2. He seemed small and a bit lost in comparison to the big experienced centre halves that could keep him in their pocket.
Reply
#18
(01-11-2022, 11:51 AM)baggy1 Wrote: No Cleary in that lot SW4? Watching him on saturday, and it is a bit harsh based on one game under the circumstances (10 men) but I thought he would be more suited to a front 2 than the system we play, in the traditional big fella (Dike) and fast fella combination in a 4-4-2. He seemed small and a bit lost in comparison to the big experienced centre halves that could keep him in their pocket.

Cleary is 17 and hasn't signed a pro-deal yet... Feels a bit early to be planning to include him in next year's squad... this time LY we all thought Irobegum would be involved for us this season.
Reply
#19
(01-11-2022, 12:00 PM)SW4Baggie Wrote:
(01-11-2022, 11:51 AM)baggy1 Wrote: No Cleary in that lot SW4? Watching him on saturday, and it is a bit harsh based on one game under the circumstances (10 men) but I thought he would be more suited to a front 2 than the system we play, in the traditional big fella (Dike) and fast fella combination in a 4-4-2. He seemed small and a bit lost in comparison to the big experienced centre halves that could keep him in their pocket.

Cleary is 17 and hasn't signed a pro-deal yet... Feels a bit early to be planning to include him in next year's squad... this time LY we all thought Irobegum would be involved for us this season.

Shame he turned out to be a money grabbing Villa cunt.
Reply
#20
I would hope we give Morton a go next season (he is older than Dike), Fellows and Taylor will hopefully get a chance as well

I like Clarke but we are well covered in defence and would spend the money , which will be in short supply, on midfielders and attackers unless any defenders leaves.

Would let Livermore go if he is out of contract and Phillips because he is injury prone. I assume (and hope) Hugill, Snodgrass and Zohore will be gone and we have learnt our lesson in signing journeymen player on the way down, I am sure we have not!

Would only sign players to whom WBA represents a move up, together with a few young loanees from premier clubs (like Barnes)
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: