Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
01-11-2022, 10:19 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-11-2022, 10:31 AM by Lurker#3.)
A few of us have consistently said that we need another window to sort the squad out so it can be competitive. What do you see us needing and who would be the core of the squad that remains? I genuinely don't think what league we are in matters, as it will just effect the quality of the incomings require.
For me:
GK - SJ, Palmer/Griffiths (one out on loan), Button
No signings needed, SJ I think will be gone regardless. Button as back up, one of the promising lads as #1
CB - Kipre, Bartley, O'Shea, Ajayi, Kean Bryan, Clarke
Ajayi seems to have lost his way and always seems to have a clanger in him. Lost his place to Kipre who has improved game upon game. If Clarke is available at the right price I wouldn't be against signing him as the replacement for Bartley in the middle fo the back 3, but not to play LCB. I think we need at least 1 or potentially 2 new players with the right profile here as none of the younger players seem able to me. +1
LB/LWB - Townsend, Reach
I think we need a new LWB in this system, somebody in the Rico Henry, Anthonee Robinson mould. Lots of pace, ability to dribble and cross. +1
RB/RWB - Furlong
A real weak area of the squad. Furlong is a capable squad player and I think could make a good RCB, but as on the left we need a more capable attacking full/wingback. +1
CM - Mowatt, TGH, Snoddy, Livermore, Molumby
Real issue for us and where some real money will be spent in close season. The 3 left above need to be complimented by 2 new signings. +2
FW,L/R - Grant, Robinson, Phillips, Diangana
We need an out and out right sided forward, with blistering pace and power. +1
CF - Dike, Hugill, Zahore, Cleary
As long as DK is as good as we all hope, we will only need one other signing. Hopefully we will see the emergence of Cleary if/when he signs his new contract as the 3rd option. +1
I look at Reach and Livermore as utility players and 2 perfect subs, as between them they can pretty much fill in all over the pitch bar in goal and CF, and regardless of the hate Jake gets he is a passionate advocate of the club and is a positive influence around the place and rarely lets us down.
So in my opinion we need 7 ins/outs. Hopefully the Cleary for Hugill will happen this month, and perhaps a CM in for Snoddy. That would leave 5 lots of ins and outs for the summer, which is more than doable.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
Harsh to say that Ajayi has a clanger a game in him, and Kipre is improving game on game... when the latter has played a major roll in losing us a point and then got sent off...costing us a 4th round game...(which could be a blessing). Personally I think all of our defenders have the potential for clangers in games. Then again, playing in defence such clangers tend be a lot more noticeable and costly than say midfield clangers (unless of the level of Sawyers v Leeds)
Our defence though, in the main isn't a problem area.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(01-11-2022, 10:26 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Harsh to say that Ajayi has a clanger a game in him, and Kipre is improving game on game... when the latter has played a major roll in losing us a point and then got sent off...costing us a 4th round game...(which could be a blessing). Personally I think all of our defenders have the potential for clangers in games. Then again, playing in defence such clangers tend be a lot more noticeable and costly than say midfield clangers (unless of the level of Sawyers v Leeds)
Our defence though, in the main isn't a problem area.
Agree partly mate. I think Ajayi just isn't a very natural footballer. He's a fantastic athlete, but he shits himself when the ball is near his feet. Kipre has good feet for a big lad, and he still very young. I am not sure Ajayi will progress any further than his current standard which is disappointing as I had really high hopes for him.
Regarding the defence as a whole. Absolutely, we are great defensively. But some of attacking shortcomings are down to the back players being awkward and clumsy on the ball and lack any range of passing. Thats what we need to address, the transition.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 7,371
Threads: 181
Joined: Jul 2020
Reputation:
27
Pretty decent assessment there. But i think Molumby is loan to perm, he'll be here. I think Jake might still be around but as CB cover. It seems to suit him.
As good a fullback as Townsend is he aint no wing-back. Might get some decent money for him to fund a couple.
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(01-11-2022, 10:31 AM)MrFizz Wrote: Pretty decent assessment there. But i think Molumby is loan to perm, he'll be here. I think Jake might still be around but as CB cover. It seems to suit him.
As good a fullback as Townsend is he aint no wing-back. Might get some decent money for him to fund a couple.
I think Townsend can do either role quite well he's just not reached his usual levels recently.
Posts: 2,414
Threads: 94
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
19
01-11-2022, 10:35 AM
(This post was last modified: 01-11-2022, 10:36 AM by ChamonixBaggie.)
Townsend was doing well as a wing-back earlier in the season and was by far our best crosser so he does have it in him. He's recently signed a new contract so won't be going anywhere, we just need him to re-discover some form. It does seem to me there's a bit of tactical confusion between our wingbacks and our wide forwards sometimes about who's doing what.
I think by far the main issue is some central midfielders that can unlock a defence when sides sit back and let us have the ball. Assuming of course that Dike is the next Shearer - which I am
Posts: 13,407
Threads: 402
Joined: Jul 2019
Reputation:
14
(01-11-2022, 10:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (01-11-2022, 10:26 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Harsh to say that Ajayi has a clanger a game in him, and Kipre is improving game on game... when the latter has played a major roll in losing us a point and then got sent off...costing us a 4th round game...(which could be a blessing). Personally I think all of our defenders have the potential for clangers in games. Then again, playing in defence such clangers tend be a lot more noticeable and costly than say midfield clangers (unless of the level of Sawyers v Leeds)
Our defence though, in the main isn't a problem area.
Agree partly mate. I think Ajayi just isn't a very natural footballer. He's a fantastic athlete, but he shits himself when the ball is near his feet. Kipre has good feet for a big lad, and he still very young. I am not sure Ajayi will progress any further than his current standard which is disappointing as I had really high hopes for him.
Regarding the defence as a whole. Absolutely, we are great defensively. But some of attacking shortcomings are down to the back players being awkward and clumsy on the ball and lack any range of passing. Thats what we need to address, the transition.
I don't disagree about the defence not helping the attack, it's why we've missed O'Shea so much.
I don't see much between Barrtley, Ayaji and Kipre to be honest, all much of a muchness. Heck it's arguable but I think Livermore had his best game this season at the back too.
it's interesting though, as over the course of this and the end of last seasons, (based on posts on here) Furlong has gone from one of the best and most improved players to the worst, then it was Townsend, Bartley, Ayaji.... it's cyclical, one minute they've massively improved the next they need getting rid of. I think someone was saying Townsend was worth £8m the other day.
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(01-11-2022, 10:36 AM)MassDebater Wrote: (01-11-2022, 10:29 AM)Lurker#3 Wrote: (01-11-2022, 10:26 AM)MassDebater Wrote: Harsh to say that Ajayi has a clanger a game in him, and Kipre is improving game on game... when the latter has played a major roll in losing us a point and then got sent off...costing us a 4th round game...(which could be a blessing). Personally I think all of our defenders have the potential for clangers in games. Then again, playing in defence such clangers tend be a lot more noticeable and costly than say midfield clangers (unless of the level of Sawyers v Leeds)
Our defence though, in the main isn't a problem area.
Agree partly mate. I think Ajayi just isn't a very natural footballer. He's a fantastic athlete, but he shits himself when the ball is near his feet. Kipre has good feet for a big lad, and he still very young. I am not sure Ajayi will progress any further than his current standard which is disappointing as I had really high hopes for him.
Regarding the defence as a whole. Absolutely, we are great defensively. But some of attacking shortcomings are down to the back players being awkward and clumsy on the ball and lack any range of passing. Thats what we need to address, the transition.
I don't disagree about the defence not helping the attack, it's why we've missed O'Shea so much.
I don't see much between Barrtley, Ayaji and Kipre to be honest, all much of a muchness. Heck it's arguable but I think Livermore had his best game this season at the back too.
it's interesting though, as over the course of this and the end of last seasons, (based on posts on here) Furlong has gone from one of the best and most improved players to the worst, then it was Townsend, Bartley, Ayaji.... it's cyclical, one minute they've massively improved the next they need getting rid of. I think someone was saying Townsend was worth £8m the other day.
I think both fullbacks are vastly improved, and both are more than capable players even at Prem level. But in our system, at times, we need a different profile of player.
Regarding the CBS, I have before stated that out of the "big 'ens" ( Kipre, Ajayi, Bartley, Clarke) only 1 should play so we can find that extra attacking edge from our wider CB's. This is where I think Furlong could come into his own.
"IMO of course..."
Posts: 8,845
Threads: 269
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
29
(01-11-2022, 10:35 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Townsend was doing well as a wing-back earlier in the season and was by far our best crosser so he does have it in him. He's recently signed a new contract so won't be going anywhere, we just need him to re-discover some form. It does seem to me there's a bit of tactical confusion between our wingbacks and our wide forwards sometimes about who's doing what.
I think by far the main issue is some central midfielders that can unlock a defence when sides sit back and let us have the ball. Assuming of course that Dike is the next Shearer - which I am 
This in spades
Posts: 9,603
Threads: 515
Joined: Jan 2019
Reputation:
32
(01-11-2022, 10:35 AM)ChamonixBaggie Wrote: Townsend was doing well as a wing-back earlier in the season and was by far our best crosser so he does have it in him. He's recently signed a new contract so won't be going anywhere, we just need him to re-discover some form. It does seem to me there's a bit of tactical confusion between our wingbacks and our wide forwards sometimes about who's doing what.
I think by far the main issue is some central midfielders that can unlock a defence when sides sit back and let us have the ball. Assuming of course that Dike is the next Shearer - which I am 
I noticed a few games back our wide forwards started playing much narrower, but we were struggling to get our wingbacks/CM up to support the overloads. This is mainly down to a lack of pace and power in wide areas and in CM. Furlong has both pace and power in him but has been miles off recently, and Townsend has been out of form for 2 months now since his new contract funnily enough.
"IMO of course..."
|